Blog Entry

D-men and discipline

Posted on: October 12, 2010 12:15 pm
Edited on: October 12, 2010 12:18 pm
A few thoughts for a Tuesday as we wonder if the Anaheim Ducks will manage to keep an opponent to fewer than 45 shots per game this season.  With the problems Anaheim has along the blue line, you should wonder too.

In the meantime there are other things to consider, like how many games Chicago’s Niklas Hjalmarsson and James Wisniewski of the Islanders will get for what they did on Columbus Day.  The holiday was pretty busy for the NHL with six games on tap, but those two stood out and because of it, seemed destined for suspensions. The question is for how long.

Hjalmarsson’s hit from behind on Buffalo’s Jason Pominville was probably the more egregious of the two because his victim suffered a concussion, although the consensus from both teams dressing rooms in the aftermath was that it was more the result of carelessness by the young Blackhawks defenseman than malicious intent. But Wisniewski miming of a sexual act to the Rangers choirboy Sean Avery was on YouTube before the game was over and had lots more viral appeal, and things that embarrass the league tend to rate just as highly on its required disciplinary meter.

Of course there is no defined penalty for being stupid, which is how you would describe Wisniewski’s action on a day when commissioner Gary Bettman was in attendance on Long Island. Bettman was there to help the Islanders owner lobby for improved facilities, the kind of information usually passed along to players before games when they are reminded to put on a ‘good show’ for the matinee crowd.

Then again, you have to figure that Wisniewski is someone who tends to block things out. He had no problem blocking out that he was going to be Brent Seabrook’s best man when he crushed his former teammate into the glass last season. Wisniewski started at Chicago’s blue line and plastered Seabrook into the glass well after he got rid of the puck, causing the Blackhawks player to crumple in a heap and suffer a concussion. 

Wisniewski sat eight games for that, although wasn’t penalized following this latest incident.  Hjalmarsson was, getting ejected for the boarding major after he hit Pominville from behind. It wasn’t a particularly dirty hit  to the shoulder area and there will be those who think Pominville left himself vulnerable, but the upshot is that Buffalo’s forward went face first and hard into the glass and was carried off on a stretcher.  And that requires some sort of suspension, if only so the NHL can send the message that players have to think more on the ice.

Decisions should come down soon.

Oh yes and as far as Anaheim goes, Ducks defenseman Paul Mara says the team’s weak start should be put into perspective.

“Three games in, I don’t think it’s time to panic,” he told NHL Home Ice. “Once the 10-, 15-,20-game mark hits and you don’t have the wins you thought, then it’s time  to hit the panic button and figure out what’s going on.”

We can wait. Can they?
Category: NHL

Since: Oct 18, 2006
Posted on: October 12, 2010 6:23 pm

D-men and discipline

My only objection or observation is that if a suspension is issued, as it is early in the new season and there seems to be an emphasis on concussions, that the same call on the ice be made in every game with equal discipline being doled out for equal hits. In short, sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander.

Since: Oct 12, 2010
Posted on: October 12, 2010 3:59 pm

D-men and discipline

Like Coach Quenneville said in his postgame interview, it would be tough to suspend Hjalmarsson for many, if any, games for his hit last night. He was going for the puck, he said he thought it would be a shoulder-to-shoulder hit, and he doesn't really have any prior offenses like this. Yes, it was a very hard hit and was unfortunate in how it ended, but it is tough to argue that the injury was intentional. Also, I believe that it was Seabrook who was supposed to be Wiz's best man this past summer.  

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or