powered by Google  
  Track your favorite teams and players.
Free membership, Register Now
Already a member, Log In
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg Sports News
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
  Home   Fantasy     NFL  |  MLB  |  NBA  |  NHL  |  College FB  |  College BK  |  Golf  |  More CBS College | MaxPreps | Mobile | Shop  
Community Home | My Profile | My Blog | Groups | My Settings | My Account | Member Search | Blog Search | About Community

Dennis Dodd

Dodds and Ends  RSS - Dodds and Ends

Name: Private | Gender: | Member Since February 8, 2008
Current Level: Superstar | Email: Private
Favorite
Teams
Blog Home

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

Posted on: June 16, 2009 12:06 am
Score: -704
 
AUSTIN, Texas -- John Bianco's phone blew up at dinner. That was the first sign -- of a Texas football apocalypse.

You should know that Bianco is the football SID at Texas. One of the best. Sometimes it seems he knows something has happened at with the football program before it actually happens. Not this time. Silly him for thinking that he could have a nice, quiet dinner with friends at a trendy Austin fish place on Monday night.  

His cellie began buzzing with cryptic texts as we were looking over the menu. Something about Colt McCoy's compound leg fracture. TV and radio guys were calling. If it was true ... well, no one around here wanted to think that it was true. Texas' promising fall would have turned into a nuclear winter. Still, when you're the SID at a big dog like Texas you don't ignore even the flimsiest of rumors.

Believe me, this one was flimsy. I might not have this right but apparently a radio production assistant in San Antonio had heard from a guy who had it on good authority that Texas' quarterback had broken his leg. That was news to Bianco and other three of us gathering around our fish. But in this instant information age, a message board post can become like a wildfire. You have to put it out.

By the time the check came, Bianco had it under control. No one of substance was going with the news that proved to be false the moment we stopped by Monday's seven-on-seven drills. There was McCoy, Heisman hopeful and Texas' leading career passer, zipping passes to his mates.

As he came off the field, we kidded him about how good his leg looked -- considering.

"Iced it up," McCoy said. "Shot me up, I'm good."

What was troubling was that five of McCoy's teammates had come up to him inquiring about his busted leg. This literally could have been something someone made up. For a couple of hours, it had Texas Nation trembling. That's what scares me. Wherever this came from, someone is likely to blame "the media."

This was not a media creation. As Dave Simon said last week at the National Press Club, "I don't believe in unprofessional journalism. I don't believe in bloggers." Simon is the former Baltimore Sun reporter who created the HBO series "The Wire". You should read and listen to him. 

Simon rails against the idea that Joe Six Pack sitting in his underwear can post his thoughts on the internet and be considered credible. His point is that real journalists take years trying to perfect their craft. Ours is more of a vocation than a job.

I blog. A lot of us at CBSSports.com blog. The difference is our names are on our work. There is someone, somewhere in the company who thinks what  we write is worth paying for. That's professional.

Persons with no formal training in how to communicate -- or how to write -- can become celebrities because they are able to spew a blog. My point is, that's essentially what happend Monday night at Texas. There is a lot to like about what the web has become. Example: A post on a Texas A&M message board led to the breaking of the Big Red Motors scandal at Oklahoma.

There is a lot to hate too. We Twitter, we blog, we gossip, we report facts. There needs to be a separation. You need to know where the line is drawn. Take the time to know and believe in Simon's professional journalism. Newspapers have cut staff, shrunk news hole and increased the price of the product. We're supposed to believe newspapers are better? They won't be until someone figures how to re-invent an entire industry. 

That saddens me because there are fewer watchdogs these days. That's why the media exists, to have an adversarial relationship with those in power. That will never change. This website has spent 14 years establishing itself. It is part of the CBS empire. It is accountable. Whoever vomited that rubbish about McCoy deserves a punch in the face from Dave Simon. He (they) diminished all of our lives a little on Monday.

 
Category: NCAAF
coggins2
Reputation: 90
Level: All-Star
Since: Apr 4, 2009
Posted on: June 16, 2009 1:16 am
Score: 51
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

Who care's. This article is a waist of your time Dodd.



SkyHawk09
Reputation: 98
Level: Superstar
Since: Aug 21, 2006
Posted on: June 16, 2009 1:25 am
Score: 69
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

Dodd, I disagree with you on a lot of things, but you nailed this one. The world needs quality sportswriters, and it's a shame that they are disappearing because newspapers are struggling. People need to realize how important real, professional sportswriters are.



Football Savant
Reputation: 97
Level: Superstar
Since: Apr 17, 2009
Posted on: June 16, 2009 6:45 am
Score: 123
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

How important real, professional sportswriters are?  Why are they so important.  If they all quit tonight, would the world go into Chaos?  I don't think so, we would just turn on FOX or ESPN and watch the game or listen to some guy tell us in his own words what is going on.  And if there were no more sports, would cancer begin to spread faster?  No, we would probably be healthier ourselves because now instead of sitting around on our butts watching and drinking beer, we might actually go outside and do something on Sunday afternoons.

The world needs quality sportswriters like it needs McDonalds, Coke and candy bars.  No, what the world needs is less A-holes like Kim what's his name in Korea, countries like Iran and Syria, and people with no bigger view of the world's issues than to think sports writers are the cure.



BigBlueLonghorn
Reputation: 91
Level: All-Star
Since: Oct 2, 2007
Posted on: June 16, 2009 10:07 am
Score: 64
 

And trust me, if this guy qualifies as a pro ...

Then just imagine how bad those bloggers must be. Just look at the mistakes in this thing:

Second Paragraph, Third Sentence

Sometimes it seems he knows something has happened at with the football program before it actually happens.

At With the football program? On to the fourth paragraph:

That was news to Bianco and other three of us gathering around our fish.

You mean THE other three of us? Third paragraph from the bottom, second sentence:

My point is, that's essentially what happend ...

Happend?

Somebody get this guy an editor fast ...



philatio11
Reputation: 98
Level: Superstar
Since: Nov 3, 2006
Posted on: June 16, 2009 11:47 am
Score: 138
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

tee hee
The world needs more professional journalists.  Quite a statement from a guy that isn't considered a professional journalist by a lot of his own readers. 

Kinda like the fat old man baseball writers who shunned my sister when she was first breaking into the business.  She's a blogger all right.  A blogger with a Master's from Emerson, whose day job is editing baseball writers and running a publishing company.

I'm not sure it's even fair to consider CBS Sports as a professional news gathering organization; it seems likes it's primarily just wire stories mixed in with a handful of inflammatory columnists.  Basically a blog with added wire stories, I guess.



The512
Reputation: 96
Level: Superstar
Since: Dec 13, 2008
Posted on: June 16, 2009 12:25 pm
Score: 94
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

Just because dd has opinions that differ from yours or he said or wrote something you didn't/don't agree with doesn't make him a bad journalist. 

I'm sure these writers on this site LOVE the fact we can post our opinions, rants, and our two cents on these articles...

I personally think it's funny when these posters come on here and bash, bash, bash the writers, like they could do a better job.

Keep up the good work dd.



SkyHawk09
Reputation: 98
Level: Superstar
Since: Aug 21, 2006
Posted on: June 16, 2009 2:16 pm
Score: 113
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

The world needs all of those things. I never said sportswriters were the cure. But they do provide an important service. Without sportswriters, ESPN and Fox lose much of their ability to get news to you fast. That news matters to most people.

Your view of the world without sports is an impossible utopia. Humans aren't wired like that. They'd find another way to waste their time. As much as you don't like to admit it, the world needs quality sportswriters.



Statalyzer
Reputation: 87
Level: All-Star
Since: Aug 20, 2006
Posted on: June 16, 2009 10:23 pm
Score: 99
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

It's funny how people are letting their personal dislike of Dodd scramble their reasoning.  People passing themselves off as sportswriters, journalists, bloggers, whatever, that report rumors and made-up BS as facts are a problem.  No, not a problem on the level of North Korea threatening nuclear war - but in the sports world (which you care about, or you wouldn't be reading this in the first place), it's a problem.



Dogbert
Reputation: 91
Level: All-Star
Since: Dec 9, 2006
Posted on: June 16, 2009 10:43 pm
Score: 130
 

regarding professionalism

I'm not a frequent poster here, coming in mostly to check scores and maybe play a bit of fantasy football/basketball, but your definition of professionalism in journalism caught my eye. Professionalism ought never be defined by who is paid, and who is not paid; I know of many writers who are paid and yet conduct themselves in a completely unprofessional manner. I don't think Dave would agree with that definition, either; I think what Dave was trying to capture was the spirit of professionalism, rather than the outward evidences of professionalism. This is important because anyone can act professionally, and if people reading blogs had kept level heads, this issue would never have arisen.

I believe the real issue here is a lack of discretion, which I define as the ability to understand what is worth believing and what is worth spreading. Of course, most of the onus for discretion lies on the readers -- you make that point when you say that people have to understand the difference between gossip and fact -- and that also means that the content of your average Joe's blog shouldn't affect as many opinions as this one did. Gossip about Colt McCoy is obviously important enough to check before reapeating, and that's what should have happened here. This means that your heated words about average people blogging are unecessary, because their blogs aren't the problem.

Perhaps that's what I'm trying to say. You should see unpaid bloggers as being on your side, because they'll continue to blog come hell or high water. Media needs to respond by providing guaranteed sources of accurate information, and working to discover how they can help bloggers be as accurate as possible. In the end, that's all you can do to prevent messes like this one.



lifeoverrace
Reputation: 41
Level: Rookie
Since: Jun 17, 2009
Posted on: June 17, 2009 1:23 am
Score: 14
 

Colt McCoy's (non-)broken leg

"That's why the media exists, to have an adversarial relationship with those in power."  
Tell me you didn't just write that with a straight face. You know you work for CBS....right?



About Dodds and Ends
Follow me on Twitter: @dennisdoddcbs
Recent Blog Entries
Dodds and Ends
CBS Sports Blogs

Dodds and Ends' Tags
Dennis Dodd's Favorites
No Favorites

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or CBSSports.com