Blog Entry

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

Posted on: January 19, 2012 12:27 pm

In the second installment of our plus-one lookback (2003-2007), USC takes over from Miami to forge a dynasty before the SEC begins to go reticulated python on college football.  Oh, and sorry Texas. That 2005 title never happened.

(All plus-one games played on neutral fields. Here’s how things looked from 1998-2002.)



BCS champion: LSU 21, Oklahoma 14

The setup:  By now, epic BCS fails were becoming commonplace. This time Oklahoma blew through the first 12 games of the season winning by an average of more than 32 points. That was before a four-touchdown loss to Kansas State in the Big 12 title game.

So much for the dangers of losing late.  Not only didn’t No. 1 OU fall out of the top two, it didn’t fall from the top spot! (It dropped from No. 1 to No. 3 in the human polls.) That was the first problem.  The second, more significant issue, is that USC was a consensus No. 1 in the human polls but No. 3 in the BCS.

Complicating matters, if that was possible, was three major-college, one-loss teams occupying the top three spots in the final BCS (OU, LSU, USC). One of them didn’t win its conference. The BCS commissioners swallowed hard, averted their eyes and tried to explain an LSU-Oklahoma championship game. The final absurdity: That meant the coaches poll would not even be considering its No. 1 team (USC) for the national championship.

Thank goodness for the AP poll.  After USC beat Michigan in the Rose Bowl, AP gave its final No. 1 ranking to the Trojans. For the first time in the BCS era, there was a split national championship. While that was OK with most folks, certain LSU fans couldn’t stomach sharing anything with anyone. Two things wrong with that: Like five other teams prior to the bowls that year, LSU was a one-loss team. By now it was becoming clear that if you lose a game in the BCS system, you lose the right to argue.

Isn’t it enough that national championships are forever? I still get emails from angry Tiger fans who claim they are the true national champs. Who cares?

How a four-team playoff would have changed things:  No. 1 Oklahoma vs. No. 4 Michigan, No. 2 LSU vs. No. 3 USC. OU would have easily mauled Michigan. The Rose Bowl that season proved it. USC outclassed the slower Wolverines by two touchdowns in Pasadena. Oklahoma 35, Michigan 17.

Many would have considered LSU-USC the real championship game. This was the year LSU freshman sensation Justin Vincent ran for 1,000 yards. Defensive tackle Chad Lavalais was the SEC defensive player of the year. USC had Reggie Bush as a freshman, Matt Leinart as a sophomore throwing to the  fantastic Mike Williams. This was the beginning of a Troy dynasty with the Trojans at least playing for three consecutive national championships in the real world. In this alternative universe it would have been a thriller, USC 27, LSU 20.

Championship game: Heisman winner Jason White was beat up for the Sooners at this point in the season. He hung in gamely against LSU but the Tigers defense and the Superdome crowd were too much. USC would have brought a similar kind of hurt. USC 23, Oklahoma 14.

Fantasy quote: “Sure we deserve a championship berth. It wasn’t like we lost to K-State by five touchdowns.” –Bob Stoops.

Who got screwed: Obviously USC, but AP was there to bail it out. That would change after the 2004 season, though, as the news organization rethought its influence on the national championship race and the money that went with it.



BCS champion: USC 55, Oklahoma 19

The setup: For the first time in the BCS era, three undefeated teams stood atop the polls at the end. The BCS quickly realized that three don’t fit into two championship berths. Auburn eventually “lost”. There is still the lasting image of Tommy Tuberville working the press box for AP votes at the Orange Bowl after the BCS had kept the undefeated SEC champions out of the BCS title game. While the Trojans and Sooners played, Auburn’s coach was literally glad-handing media, hoping against hope.

It didn’t happen for Auburn which finished third in the BCS and second in the final human polls. SEC types were outraged that their undefeated champion wasn’t worthy of playing for it all. As you might have noticed, things would change quickly for the SEC.

The difference was Auburn’s non-conference schedule and perhaps an Oklahoma-friendly Bowling Green AD.  Elsewhere, both the Trojans and Sooners were in the middle of historic runs. OU played in its third championship game since 2000. USC was in the middle of its own 34-game winning streak. Only Stanford, Cal and UCLA came within a touchdown of the Trojans that season.

How a four-team playoff would have changed things: No. 1 USC vs. No. 4 Texas, No. 2 Oklahoma vs. No. 3 Auburn.  Texas wasn’t quite there yet despite 1,000-yard rushing seasons from both Cedric Benson and Vince Young. Meanwhile, USC sported a Heisman winner (Leinart) as well as three other consensus All-Americans. This was arguably the best Trojan team of the Pete Carroll era. USC 37, Texas 24.

Would have loved to see the nation’s No. 1 scoring defense (Auburn) against No. 8 in total offense (Oklahoma). Using LSU’s D in 2003 as evidence, OU doesn’t show up offensively in a plus-one against a quality SEC defense. Auburn 25, Oklahoma 21.

Championship game: Auburn gets its title shot but just can’t overcome perhaps the team of the decade. USC 26, Auburn 13.

Fantasy quote: “How many voters does a commissioner have to bribe for the SEC to get to the championship game?” – Mike Slive

Real quote: “Where’s Your God Now?” – sign taunting BYU fans at Rice-Eccles Stadium in the final seconds of Utah’s 52-21 win over the Cougars that clinched the Utes’ first BCS berth.

Who got screwed: Cal. With one BCS bowl berth left, the No. 5 Bears lost a propaganda war with No. 4 Texas. Both were 10-1 on pick ‘em day. Knowing that finishing at No. 4 guaranteed his team a BCS bowl, Mack Brown had no problem campaigning for his Longhorns while Cal’s Jeff Tedford pretty much refused to engage.

Cal would have been the obvious Pac-10 replacement in the Rose Bowl with USC playing for the national championship. But Texas’ bum rush created feelings that what Bevo wants, Bevo gets long before the Longhorn Network.

“"I guess we didn't run up the score at the end, or beg for votes after the game," Cal’s Aaron Rodgers said. "I thought it was [wrong] for coach Brown to beg for votes.”

AP withdrew its poll from the BCS after the controversy.


BCS champion: Texas 41, USC 38

The setup: On paper USC never won a game this season. On the field, it ravaged the field. We would find out years later that Bush competed the entire 2005 season while ineligible having taken cash and benefits from two would-be agents.

Dismiss that from your mind considering how these Trojans were completing that 34-game winning streak. They failed to score less than 34 in any game. They scored at least 50 in seven games. They scored 60 twice and 70 once. This was the team that couldn’t be outscored -- until it was, by Vince Young.

On the night of Jan. 5, 2006 Texas’ quarterback proved himself to be the best player in the school’s glorious history. Completing a game in which he had almost 500 yards in total offense, Young pulled it down and scored the winning touchdown with 19 seconds left.

USC was denied a third straight national championship. Texas won its first in 35 years because of a singular talent.

"Without question that was the best [performance] by one guy [I've seen]," Pete Carroll said.

How a four-team playoff would have changed things: No. 1 USC vs. No. 4 Ohio State, No. 2 Texas vs. No. 3 Penn State. Anyone else have a letdown here? Ohio State was a year away in 2005 having lost to Texas and Penn State in the regular season. JoePa rebounded from downturn to begin the century to grab a share of the Big Ten. It is interesting that two Big Ten teams would have been in a plus-one. Does it matter, though, given the greatness at the top?

USC 42, Ohio State 20. Texas 44, Penn State 17.

Championship game: With his defense gassed and resting on the sidelines, this time Carroll decides to use Bush on fourth down. In the real game he didn’t. That allowed Texas to stop LenDale White on fourth down which led to the Horns’ winning drive. USC 38, Texas 35.

Fantasy quote: “I’m predicting two Super Bowls for Vince Young.” – Beano Cook

Who got screwed:  USC players who gave their heart, soul, blood, sweat and tears for the program only to have the season ripped away in disgrace because of Bush’s selfishness. In case you forgot, the NCAA vacated USC’s 2005 season as part of the Bush penalties.



BCS champion: Florida 41, Ohio State 14

In the latest BCS game ever played (Jan. 9), the system began to take different turns. Double-hosting debuted. A few days before the Gators swamped the Buckeyes, Boise beat Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl in one of the sport’s greatest upsets. A player proposed to a cheerleader. The Broncos proved they could play with the big boys, a cry that still is ringing in our ears today.

Oh yeah, and the SEC started a streak for the ages. The first of six consecutive titles by the Strength Everywhere Conference began with Florida thrashing Ohio State.

That year the immortal Chris Leak was backed up at Florida by some kid named Tebow. During the season we were treated to the jump pass, winning a game by a fingernail and first of two national championships by Urban Meyer.

How a four-team playoff would have changed things: No. 1 Ohio State vs. No. 4 LSU, No. 2 Florida vs. No. 3 Michigan. The Buckeyes blitzed through the regular season setting up Jim Tressel for his second national championship in five years. Les Miles was just getting going, posting his second straight 11-2 season. We were going to see LSU-Ohio State in 2007 anyway. In a playoff, the Buckeyes arrived a year early with Troy Smith, Ted Ginn Jr. and company winning a close one. Ohio State 31, LSU 27.

Denied a rematch with Ohio State by the pollsters and computers, Michigan would have welcomed a playoff. Coming off one of the most emotional games in Michigan history (losing to Ohio State the day after Bo Schembechler’s passing), there was a chance to sneak in the back door for a national championship. Florida’s D would have denied it. Florida 37, Michigan 21.

Championship: We’re assuming that Ginn Jr. doesn’t injure his foot celebrating a kickoff return. We still can’t assume Ohio State would have an answer for Florida’s team speed. Florida 31, Ohio State 21.

Fantasy quote: “We got tattooed.” – Tressel.

Who gagged: USC. Needing only to win over sliding UCLA to play for another title, the Trojans coughed up one of the program’s largest hairballs. The 13-9 loss to the Bruins on the last day of the regular season remains inexplicable to this day except to then-UCLA defensive  coordinator DeWayne Walker. He helped hold the Trojans to less than 20 points for the first time in 64 games



BCS champion: LSU 38, Ohio State 24

Let’s see … LSU in New Orleans? Again? Call it another unintended consequence of the BCS. The commissioners probably never imagined the Tigers being good at the exact same time the Superdome was hosting the big game. Call it purple and gold serendipity.

And luck. In the fastest and more furious finish of the BCS era, both No. 1 (Missouri) and No. 2 (West Virginia) lost on the last day of the season allowing  the Buckeyes and Tigers to move up. A week earlier, LSU had lost at home, giving up 50 to Arkansas. After beating Tennessee in the SEC championship game, the Tigers moved from No. 7 to No. 2.

How a four-team playoff would have changed things: No. 1 Ohio State vs. No. 4 Oklahoma. No. 2 LSU vs. No. 3 Virginia Tech. This was an unspectacular Oklahoma team that lost to Colorado and Texas Tech before being smoked by West Virginia in the Fiesta Bowl. Ohio State 31, Oklahoma 23.

In a plus-one, the ACC champion would have played for a national championship in a rematch we didn’t need to see. In the second week of the season, the Tigers smoked the Hokies 48-7 in Baton Rouge. Play it again, Les? LSU 33, Virginia Tech 14.

Championship game: What hurt Buckeye pride is that LSU was the last comic standing in 2007 in a wild finish to the season. The Tigers were the first two-loss team to win a national championship in 47 years. And still, LSU was able to score 31 unanswered to bury the Bucks. By now, the jokes and labels associated with Ohio State were beginning to leave a mark.

“Yeah, and that hurts," said Ohio State linebacker James Laurinaitis, "just because the media really builds it up like we are slow and all that stuff."

The Bucks football reputation was in tatters after two straight championship losses. In a few years, that rep was about to get a whole lost worse. LSU 42, Ohio State 17.

 Fantasy quote: “Next?” – SEC

Who got screwed: The fans. Hawaii was non-competitive against Georgia in the Sugar Bowl. The Rose Bowl got three-loss Illinois to match against USC. West Virginia lost Rich Rod, then promoted Bill Stewart before a rout of Oklahoma in the Fiesta Bowl. The average margin of victory in the five BCS bowls (20 points) was second only to 2002 (22.5 points).

Plus-one champions, 2003-2007: USC, USC, USC, Florida, LSU.

Tomorrow: A plus-one from 2008 to 2011.   


Since: Oct 14, 2010
Posted on: January 20, 2012 9:37 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

Someone have a man-crush on USC?  Come on.

Since: Aug 24, 2006
Posted on: January 20, 2012 9:34 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

What a stupid "what if" article about.  Who cares.  Can't you find anything to write about besides fantasy land.   If we're going to play this stupid game then "what if" Reggie Bush didn't illegally push Matt Leinart into the endzone as time expired in the Notre Dame game.  It really doesn't matter. Reggie Bush officially never played college football and any mention of his name has already been erased from mention any where on USC's campus.  That being said the infractions at USC were nothing compared to Ohio State because the coach was part of the cover up there.

Since: Jan 20, 2012
Posted on: January 20, 2012 9:26 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

This whole article of pure speculation is a waste of time and energy.
Write about something that has a chance of occuring.

Since: Jan 17, 2012
Posted on: January 20, 2012 9:06 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

Dodd your a dud

Since: Aug 17, 2006
Posted on: January 20, 2012 7:31 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

Could you please stop this nonsense.  Seriously.  I know a lot can't be expected from you since you write for a website, but even you must be able to come up with something better to write about.

Since: May 11, 2011
Posted on: January 20, 2012 4:54 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

USC puts up 42 on Ohio St in '05.. Hawk and CO would have something to say first

Since: Feb 11, 2009
Posted on: January 20, 2012 3:52 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

One more time, this is a bunch of nnsense, a waste of cyberspace.  And I am an SEC fan as well as a Gator alumnus.  When are you going to get it into yor head, Dodd, that no one care about your "what if's."  You are so ready to play with the long gone past or speculate about the future, because you rarely get the current correct.  You really don't understand the game, how teams line up and battle it out.  If you aren't playing the specualtion game (remember the whole series dedicated to the supr-conference future?) then you are retelling us things which we already know but with some moralism thrown in.  The biggest, and I mean biggest, telltale in this current piece is the way you treat the 2006 national chanpionship game.  You and all your CBS buddies derided the Gators going into the game.  The Florida's defense flattened the hell out of Ohio State, best exemplified by the picture of a helmetless Earl Everett tracking down and tossing Troy Smith to the ground.  Of course, after the game and now, you acted as if you knew that Florida was going to win the game along.

Since: Dec 6, 2006
Posted on: January 20, 2012 1:09 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

Best article ever! Your what if game still puts Texas and USC playing for the title in 2005. What if Bush ran the ball instead of White? He would have been stuffed and lost more yardage than their bruising back. What if VY had 600 total yards? They lost in a real game, not hypothetical. They won playing against a technically ineligible Reggie Bush. What if Bush never played that season is the real question. USC would have never made it to the big game.

What if you actually wrote an intelligent meaningful article?

What if... VY was called down before  throwing that TD pass, What if.... USC wasn't called for a " Bogus Face mask" with 2:19 and 3 & 12 for the horns to give them a 1st down. What if.... Number 5 didn't do the most stupid thing he ever did in his career at USC and try and lateral the ball on the 1 yard line.

BTW, Number 5's parents didn't do anything to increase his abilities, so you to can whine like a little school Beoyatch all you want. USC was the better team that day, Vince Young was the better player that day. 

College football is full of what-ifs. That is what makes it so great, but I do not think it is right to change the outcome of a game solely based on which team should have won. If that were the case USC would have won every national championship since 2003. They never would have lost a single game. They had the best team at that time and they no doubt would have won those three national titles, brought in the best recruits and had the best team the next year, and the next, and the next.... What if Texas had scored every possession, or if Leinart had thrown a pick on that last series. All it would have taken was a receiver tripping up and a defender being in good position. It is football, and anything can happen. Let's not diminish what is arguably the greatest game in the history of the sport with should haves and could haves. USC lost fair and square and I don't see the grueling extra game they had to play in Dodd's imaginary system causing them to play the game any differently than they did.

Since: Jan 19, 2012
Posted on: January 20, 2012 12:38 am

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

Good point Chiefs.  I mean, while he's making it up on the fly and replacing actual results with what he wished would have happened, why not go all out and knock off some 1 seeds?  

Really, given his track record, I can't believe he didn't have OSU losing by five touchdowns in the first round in 06 and 07.  

Who wants to bet Dennis works at least one shot at OSU into tomorrow's column even though they underachieved and were too awful to even factor in the NC in that time span?  Go ahead Dennis, keep bashing OSU players for selling stuff they owned for a few bucks here and there while you email the Auburn SID and tell him how sad you are and how you'll go easy on a guy who got $200K to play there. 


Since: Sep 26, 2006
Posted on: January 19, 2012 11:07 pm

A plus-one playoff through the years: 2003-2007

Another post and still no Number 4 team upsetting a #1 team??? Maybe it wouldn't have happened but I'm assuming at least once in a 10 year span. I think in 2003 Michigan could've beat Oklahoma. In 2003, Michigan was riding high after beating Ohio State, preventing them from going back to the NCG and winning the computer while Oklahoma was embarrased by K-State and I believe the momentum would've swung in Michigan's favor.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or