Blog Entry

In Cubs vs. Umps, umpires will win

Posted on: May 27, 2009 7:50 pm

Maybe the Chicago Cubs are right and they've been hosed by a rash of bad umpire calls lately.

Or maybe they're dead wrong and totally delusional.

Whatever, one thing could not be more clear in the midst of the emotion:

The Cubs are going to have to get a grip, because there is no way they can win this battle.

While Carlos Zambrano's sensational meltdown against Pittsburgh on Wednesday will be grist for video highlights and high entertainment the rest of this season and beyond, it was the Cubs' third major incident with an umpire in the past four days.

One day after being called out on strikes by plate umpire Doug Eddings, Milton Bradley on Sunday told Paul Sullivan of the Chicago Tribune that, following an April 16 run-in with umpire Larry Vanover that resulted in a one-game suspension for Bradley, Vanover's colleagues are out to get him.

Monday night, starting pitcher Ted Lilly was ejected for chirping at plate umpire Bob Davidson over balls and strikes calls from the dugout. Lilly wasn't even the starter that night -- he had pitched Sunday in San Diego. Lilly told reporters that he was run after telling Davidson to "concentrate" more.

Tuesday, Davidson accused Lilly of lying, telling The Tribune's Sullivan that "everything [Lilly] said was bull. Everything I read in the paper that he said was untrue. He never said one of those words. What he said to me, you couldn't print in the paper."

Wednesday came Zambrano's tirade against plate umpire Mark Carlson. Zambrano was just activated from the disabled list on Friday. Now he's certain to miss more time with a hefty suspension.

One thing manager Lou Piniella liked about the addition of Bradley was that he thought the outfielder might bring an edge to the club that at times was soft last year. But they can't keep going on like this.

Losers of eight of their past 10 games, clearly, the Cubs are frustrated. But right now, they have the look of a team that's totally out of control.

If this persists, say goodbye to the notion of any close call going in their favor. The umpires have the final word. Teams have to figure out a way to get along with them. It's just the way it is.

Likes: Zack Greinke just keeps on rolling in Kansas City. He's now gone 14 consecutive starts without allowing a home run. That's a good baseball city in need of a good story, and good for Greinke. ... Baltimore set to summon catcher Matt Wieters from the minors on Friday. The Orioles continue to sail north under president/GM Andy MacPhail, even if they are fifth in the AL East. In Wieters, Nick Markakis and growing star center fielder Adam Jones, and with some young pitching developing quickly in the minors, this is a team that's a year -- maybe two at the most -- away. ... Texting taking a toll on America's teenagers? Very interesting story in the New York Times the other day.

Dislikes: You get the DVD from Netflix, you set aside for a few days, you finally pop it in and sit down to watch it one night and ... it's cracked and unplayable. At least Netflix is terrific in quickly solving the problem, and it happens only very rarely. But you've still gotta come up with Plan B that night.

Rock 'N' Roll Lyric of the Day:

" If you want you can get to know me well
We get along so we shouldn't argue
And I don't know, said I don't know
All these feelings, cloud up my reasoning"

-- Matchbox 20, Argue


Since: Aug 14, 2007
Posted on: May 27, 2009 9:51 pm

In Cubs vs. Umps, umpires will win

I have to say, I am not a Cubs fan, nor am I a fan of the team they were playing. I read about the incident and checked out the video. To those who say that the umpire blew that call and that the runner was out, you blew the call. The umpire was right on that, he had an excellent view on the play and he made the correct call. If you check out the video, you will easily see on the replays they show that the runner slipped his left hand in before Zambrano could tag him. His tag had to hit the chest, and he had the ball but waited for the runner to slide into the glove. If he tried to move the glove towards the runner, he probably would have gotten him out, but he blew that play, just like those that said he was out blew the call.

Since: Aug 17, 2006
Posted on: May 27, 2009 9:40 pm

In Cubs vs. Umps, umpires will win

Umps may win but baseball loses, not just the Cubs! When a player is suspended it is front page news. When an ump screws up and is disciplined it is covered up.  Modern technology has made umps unnecesary. We have devices that can call balls and strikes with greater acuracy, cameras shoot more angles of a play and can show whether a player is safe or out or a ball fair or foul better than the umps. Instead we rely on umps who have axes to grind make calls based upon the player and not the play.

Since: Mar 21, 2009
Posted on: May 27, 2009 9:33 pm

In Cubs vs. Umps, umpires will win

If you see the highlight, THE UMPIRE INITIATED THE CONTACT!!! Why dont they slap him with a fine and suspend him for a week...

There have been alot of bang bang plays this week for the Cubs and it seems that all the calls are going to the opposition. The only close one the Cubs got today was Soto's insurance run in the 9th, even though that was pretty obvious he was safe. The Pirates got the rest.

I agree 100%, the umps are way too confrontational now.

Since: Aug 11, 2008
Posted on: May 27, 2009 9:31 pm

In Cubs vs. Umps, umpires will win

well said...that call was really bad, he was clearly out...zambrano had every right to complain...then the ump bumps him and now zambrano will get suspended...i really hope they review that closely and suspend the ump for that bullshit

Since: Jul 14, 2008
Posted on: May 27, 2009 8:38 pm
This comment has been removed.

Post Deleted by Administrator

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or