Blog Entry

Girardi: "I screwed up"

Posted on: April 25, 2010 8:22 pm
Edited on: April 25, 2010 9:39 pm

ANAHEIM, Calif. -- Even World Series-winning managers get the blues.

The Yankees' 8-4 loss to the Los Angeles Angels in the series finale here Sunday came complete with a very unusual moment in the seventh that directly preceded Kendry Morales' three-run homer that salted away the win for the Angels.

With Angels on first and second, two out, the Yankees trailing 5-4 and Kendry Morales at the plate, Joe Girardi ordered an intentional walk to Yankee-killer Kendry Morales.

And then he didn't.

Afterward, Girardi acknowledged, "I probably should have gone with my first instinct."

Follow along:

With Morales at the plate (and hitting .390 -- 23 for 59 -- lifetime against the Bronx Bombers), Girardi waved four fingers in the dugout, catcher Francisco Cervelli reinforced it and reliever Damaso Marte threw intentional ball one.

Then, confusion.

Girardi called off the walk and popped out of the dugout, taking a couple of steps toward the mound.

His intention: To summon reliever David Robertson to finish the intentional walk. Then, with two out and the bases loaded, have Robertson go hard after the next hitter, Juan Rivera.

But a few steps out of the dugout, Girardi suddenly changed his mind and U-turned.

So the lefty Marte resumed pitching to the switch-hitting Morales (batting righty) and threw ball two. But, now, not intentionally.

And taking full advantage of the Yankees' hesitation, Torii Hunter stole third base to put runners on first and third.

Next pitch, ball three.

Next, with Angels manager Mike Scioscia smartly green-lighting Morales on 3 and 0, the first baseman crushed a fat Marte fastball for a three-run homer.

Morales at the time was 1 for 3 against Marte in his career, the one hit being a double.

Had Girardi gone with his first instinct and brought Robertson in to face Juan Rivera with the bases loaded, for the record, Rivera had one RBI single in one lifetime at-bat against Robertson.

The only thing more extraordinary than a sense of wavering from the Yankees' skipper was how bluntly he assessed himself afterward, even acknowledging that once the count on Morales ran to 3 and 0, he "probably could have put up four fingers again."

"I screwed up, in a sense," Girardi said. "Not everything I do is going to be right."


Since: Aug 7, 2008
Posted on: April 25, 2010 11:11 pm

Girardi: "I screwed up"

It's all on Marte for being ineffective. Girardi showed confidence in his players which is always a good thing. Marte, a Pirates reject...what did we expect?

Since: Oct 10, 2007
Posted on: April 25, 2010 9:52 pm

He Screwed Up When He Left Marte on the Roster.

Damaso Marte has pretty much been worthless since being aquired 2 years ago.  His only redeeming quality was his performance in last years W.S. versus  the Lefty bats of the Phils. (which was a big deal)  Besides those moments he done nothing but give out walks, wild pitches, hit batters, and homeruns. He is a lefty specialist who can't get out lefties.  A left handed version of Tanyon Sturtze or Kyle Farnsworth.

Since: Oct 26, 2008
Posted on: April 25, 2010 9:47 pm

Girardi: "I screwed up"

"SAY IT AIN'T SO, JOE."  Man, the rare breed of athlete/manager, a stand up guy.  In an age where the umpire can't call his strike zone, the refs missed the foul, the linesman couldn't tell the difference in motion or drawing the opponent off sides, Joe calls it on himself.  Hey, Tony Larussa, Mike Singletary, Urban Meyer, Mike Leach, Mike "I'm 40" Gundy, learn a lesson from the manager of NY Yankees.

You look smarter calling a penalty on yourself than looking like a self-righteous fool.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or