Blog Entry

Farrell has what Jays need: Pitching knowledge

Posted on: October 25, 2010 6:11 pm

The Toronto Blue Jays interviewed something like six dozen candidates to replace Cito Gaston as manager ... and they wind up hiring a man who has managed nothing other than pitching staffs during his coaching career?

Moving to hire John Farrell as skipper is either going to be young general manager Alex Anthopoulos' most brilliant move yet ... or a crashing disaster.

In the AL East, with a Blue Jays team that fared better than expected post-Roy Halladay in 2010, there will not be any in-betweens.

As Boston's pitching coach the past four seasons, Farrell was the typical genius when the Red Sox won the World Series in 2007 and, well, not-so-genius in 2010, when most every pitcher other than Jon Lester and Clay Buchholz under-performed.

Still, he's got a strong background in player development in Cleveland, he helped develop young arms like Lester and Buchholz in Boston and that's exactly what the Blue Jays want. Even in the post-Halladay days, they've got a strong nucleus of young pitchers, guys like Ricky Romero, Brett Cecil, Brandon Morrow and Kyle Drabek.

Anthopoulos is overseeing Toronto's latest rebuilding project, and based on the Blue Jays' 85-77 finish in 2010, fourth in the AL East, it's moving along more quickly than anticipated.

But here's the key: Toronto, over the next two or three seasons, will move as far as those aforementioned pitchers will take it.

If they stay healthy and continue to progress, the Blue Jays may finally get over the hump and climb back into the upper reaches of the AL East.

If too many of those pitchers flat-line, then all 2010 was for Toronto was one more mirage.

I like that Anthopoulos is thinking outside the box, so to speak. No, Farrell does not have any managerial experience. Yes, he knows pitching. And given where the Jays are, and that the game is returning to an emphasis on pitching, this has a chance to be one of Toronto's wisest moves yet.

Time was, former big league pitchers were looked upon skeptically as future managers. But look at what Bud Black is doing in San Diego. That perception is beginning to change.

Obviously, it is imperative that Toronto hires a bench coach who has been a manager, a wise old coot who knows strategy and rules. That's the type of guy who can help Farrell, with his knowledge of pitching, make a major difference as the Blue Jays look to soar.


Since: Jul 27, 2009
Posted on: October 27, 2010 12:06 am

Farrell has what Jays need: Pitching knowledge

As a Red Sox fan, I think this is a great hire by Toronto.  Farrell really helped Jon Lester become a top pitcher in the league and helped Clay Buchholz overcome a confidence problem to become a very good pitcher.  He'll have one of the best corps of young pitchers to work with in Toronto.  I don't think I would be overly concerned about him not being a "hitter's manager."  He learned under Terry Francona, who is regarded as one of the best players' managers in the game.  Toronto could really be a sleeper next year, especially if Tampa Bay can't retain its top free agents.

Since: Nov 3, 2006
Posted on: October 26, 2010 8:55 am

Farrell has what Jays need: Pitching knowledge

"a Blue Jays team that fared better than expected post-Roy Halladay in 2010 "

Most people who actually knew anything about this team had them pegged to finish where they did.  Most so-called experts only knew that they had lost Roy Halladay, and that they play in someplace called Canada, and therefore based on the knowledge they possesed had them pegged to finish dead-last in the AL.
Red Sox fans, who actually know something about Farrell, consider it to be a great hire for Toronto, and a huge loss for them.

Since: Sep 19, 2007
Posted on: October 25, 2010 10:04 pm

Farrell has what Jays need: Pitching knowledge

I like it... but I worry about the major change in philosophy. You go from Cito who was a hitters coach, to a guy that is clearly going to be a pitchers coach.  
AS you said, they need to get a bench coach who is going to compliment farrell and not just be a yes man.  The Jays have some very promising young talent that has already debuted and also coming up in the system.  
This was risky, but I have a hunch this is going to pay off.... 

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or