Blog Entry

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

Posted on: February 17, 2012 2:09 pm
Edited on: February 17, 2012 5:47 pm
The Pirates, spurned by free agents Edwin Jackson and Roy Oswalt this winter, need pitching. The Yankees, bastion for tabloid headlines run amok, need less chaos and fewer knuckleheads.

Call the deal sending A.J. Burnett to Pittsburgh a win-win for both clubs.

Talks for this trade have been so interminable that they've made Best Picture Oscar nominee Tree of Life seem rapid-fire. But the deal finally is moving from the on-deck circle to completion: Colleague Jon Heyman reports that the Pirates have agreed to pay $13 million of the remaining $33 million on Burnett's deal, and that two low-level minor-leaguers will move from Pittsburgh to New York: right-hander Diego Moreno, 25, and outfielder Exicardo Cayones, 20.

Only losers in this trade are the New York tabloids ("After Yankees ace flops, here comes joker" read one classic headline as Burnett followed CC Sabathia in the playoffs against the Tigers last October).

It wasn't official, but Burnett's departure papers from the Yanks' rotation were punched on that dramatic Friday evening last month when general manager Brian Cashman deftly moved to acquire Michael Pineda from Seattle and sign free agent Hiroki Kuroda. The moves were stellar and stealth, immediately adding depth and talent that has been lacking from Joe Girardi's rotation for at least the past couple of years.

That wasn't supposed to be the case with Burnett, who donated his arm to the Bronx cause (and, apparently, his brain to science) when he signed the six-year $82.5 million deal before the 2009 season. For that, the Yankees got 34 victories from him over three seasons, and a clutch (and pivotal) Game 2 win in the 2009 World Series against Philadelphia.

But more often than not, it was the Land of 1,000 Headaches with A.J. as the Yankees spend inordinate amounts of time over the past two seasons trying to fix him like a broken-down sports car on the side of the road. Who knows how many man-hours pitching coach Larry Rothschild invested in him alone last season? And just think how much quality time Rothschild now will have available for Sabathia, Kuroda, Pineda, Ivan Nova, Phil Hughes and others.

And for his part there's a good chance that, away from the New York spotlight and howling masses, Burnett can put some of the pieces back together again and help the Pirates. For one thing, he won't be freaking out about whether yet another potent AL East lineup will bash his brains in every fifth day. Facing St. Louis without Albert Pujols, Milwaukee without Prince Fielder and the Astros without anybody in the NL Central might be just what the shrink, er, doctor ordered.

Look, Burnett is a nice guy, a well-meaning guy and a hard-worker. But there historically has been a disconnect between his million-dollar arm and his brain. He was great at times, but always inconsistent, in Florida. He was at his best in Toronto when he was trying to emulate Roy Halladay and Doc's incredible work habits. He's a classic second-fiddle guy, needing to play Robin to someone else's Batman, even he's had the arm of Superman.

Pittsburgh, which has now suffered losing seasons dating back to Pie Traynor (or something like that), happily showed some signs of bounceback last year, especially early. At the All-Star break, the Bucs were in the thick of the NL Central race. But a pitching staff that owned a 3.17 ERA on July 25 fell apart thereafter. Not enough stamina or talent to last. No staying power.

Manager Clint Hurdle has some pieces in James McDonald, Jeff Karstens and Charlie Morton. GM Neal Huntington acquired Erik Bedard over the winter, which is worth a shot. Problem for the Pirates is, in their current state, their most folks' 10th or 11th choice on the free agent market. Jackson signed with the Nationals. Oswalt remains unsigned, scouring high and low for another landing spot.

Which is why focusing on a trade, and Burnett specifically, maybe isn't the first choice for the contenders out there but is the perfect move right now for Huntington. As maddeningly inconsistent as he's been, Burnett did throw 190 1/3 innings for the Yanks last summer, 186 2/3 before that and 207 innings in 2009.

Pittsburgh can use that. And Burnett can use a low-key place -- at least, a place lower key than Yankee Stadium -- as he reaches out to recapture lost glory for a team doing the same.

Here's hoping he does. Pittsburgh can really use it. And, from Burnett, the Yankees no longer need it.

Since: Oct 26, 2006
Posted on: February 17, 2012 4:59 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

yhater1, the yankees basically consider AJ a sunk cost of only 20 million instead of 33 million now. The prospects back aren't important for the yankees. They use the money for what they need, which 13 over 2 years can fetch you a good amount, and the roster spot for someone they can use out of the bullpen instead of having a time bomb sitting there.

Since: Aug 24, 2006
Posted on: February 17, 2012 4:38 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

You left out corriea who I think was pretty decent for the most part.  Burnett will be the opening day starter and should provide a nice shot in the arm for the startign rotation (provided he stays healthy).  I think it's a good move by both teams.  I'm surpirsed you didn't say Honus Wagner instead of Pie traynor haha!  Good article...

Since: Nov 20, 2011
Posted on: February 17, 2012 4:04 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

For those that think Burnett is a victim of Yankee stadium, look at his numbers on the road the last couple years.  He had a rode ERA of 5.76 in 2011 and 6.28 in 2010.  Maybe he isn't a victim of his home field or lacking confidence.  Maybe he is just washed up?  Don't get your hopes up too high. 

Since: Jan 28, 2012
Posted on: February 17, 2012 3:46 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City


Since: Jan 18, 2012
Posted on: February 17, 2012 3:35 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

Please someone explains how this is a win for the Yankees paying 20 million plus dollars for a guy not to pitch for them

This is a total disaster for the Yankees.  Mr. Cashman is lucky the Boss is still not there.  It would not be just Burnett packing his bag.

I still cannot understand why the Pirates would want Burnett either.  Maybe Mr. Cashman has photos of the Pirate GM out on a double date with Mr. Cashman and neither women were their wives.     

Since: Oct 26, 2006
Posted on: February 17, 2012 3:30 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

I think AJ will rebound quite well. The AL East is brutal for pithers with those lineups, small parks and the DH. The NL and the Central will help considerably. The 2 and 8 hitters all suck, you get to pitch to the pitcher and many teams 6 and 7 spots aren't great. His problem is confidence and I think he'll get that back once he leave the AL east. Hou, the Cubs and many weak hitting line-ups will help that. I think he gets his ERA under 4 and wins all depends on the club.

Since: Feb 17, 2012
Posted on: February 17, 2012 3:23 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

Hooray for the Buccos for signing Burnett - a much needed move for both of them!   With Burnett, Bedard, McGahee, and Barmes, I'm looking at 12-13 additional wins minimum - and that SHOULD be enough to put them over the elusive .500 mark . . . assuming the rest of the staff stay healthy and have consistent results throughout the year.  Can't wait for Opening Day!   Go Bucs!

Since: Sep 2, 2006
Posted on: February 17, 2012 3:21 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

What you will get in Bedard is heartache. This guy had the talent to be a Cy Young calliber pitcher but the body of J.D. Drew. Burnett may do a decent job with absolutely no pressure on him at all. Good deal by the G.M. Only on the hook for $13 mil over 2 years. If they get a .500 pitcher it was well worth it.

Since: Mar 14, 2008
Posted on: February 17, 2012 3:18 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

Definitely worth a shot to see if it was just the NY pressure, especially with what Pitt is paying. Just pitching in the NL Central this year instead of the AL East should shave at least 1.5 off his ERA. Going back to the NL may turn him back into the pitcher that the Yankees thought they were getting.

Since: Jul 29, 2009
Posted on: February 17, 2012 3:06 pm

Burnett needs to be more steely in Steel City

I agree, Burnett still has one of the nastiest curve balls in baseball and if he can get some run support he could do big things in Pittsburgh.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or