Play Fantasy Use your Fantasy skills to win Cash Prizes. Join or start a league today. Play Now
Blog Entry

Valentine falls into bed of Red Sox roses

Posted on: November 30, 2011 9:11 pm
For all the talk about how Bobby Valentine can change the Red Sox, let's remember that he's taking over a team that spent 4 1/2 months as the best team in baseball.

"He fell into a bed of roses," another big-league manager said Wednesday, the day the Red Sox made it official that Valentine will take over as their new manager.

Valentine will try to avoid the thorns. The Red Sox front office gets to spend the next couple of months finding a few more roses.

It can't be any harder (or as time-consuming) as finding a new manager, right?

Besides, the Sox got a good long look at what needs to be done, in the form of September's painful collapse.

The problem is that we're now two months into Boston's offseason, and rather than get a start on fixing what's wrong on the roster, the Red Sox added to their issues by losing free-agent closer Jonathan Papelbon to the Phillies.

Somewhere, the Red Sox will find a new closer. One rival official predicted Wednesday that the Sox will be the team that ends up trading for Andrew Bailey, the very-available A's right-hander.

But where will the Sox find two or more new starting pitchers?

If there was one biggest key to sinking the Sox in September -- yes, bigger than clubhouse beer and fried chicken -- it was the failure to find or develop enough rotation depth. Aces Josh Beckett and Jon Lester were subpar in the final month, and Clay Buchholz was hurt, but the Sox were forced to use the overmatched Kyle Weiland or the over-age Tim Wakefield to start far too many games.

The Red Sox also need another outfielder. No, they need a right-handed hitting outfielder.

Boston's collapse was mostly pitching-driven, but Kevin Youkilis' injury also left the Red Sox lineup far too weak against left-handed pitching. The Red Sox tried to add a right-handed hitter at the July 31 deadline last summer, but couldn't get it done (just as they couldn't add enough pitching depth).

More roster depth all-around wouldn't hurt. One scout who saw the Red Sox in September said Wednesday that he was surprised by how much the team seemed to be affected, offensively and defensively, by the Youkilis injury.

The problems are obvious. The solutions are out there, and maybe front-office power-broker Larry Lucchino and general manager Ben Cherington won't have as hard a time agreeing on the answers as they did on a manager.

Just remember that the Red Sox are fixing a team that is already one of baseball's very best, despite what you saw in September (and despite the chaos you've seen since then).

"They're loaded," the rival manager said.

Yes, they are.

Since: Apr 6, 2007
Posted on: December 1, 2011 4:46 am

Valentine falls into bed of Red Sox roses

Valentine was a douche with the Mets, didn't win much, and went to Jap Town to manage.  He returns after a decade as the lovable annoying douche on ESPN.  Now he's the coach for the Red Sox.  That surprises me that BeanTown would do that.

Since: Jan 6, 2007
Posted on: November 30, 2011 11:55 pm

Valentine falls into bed of Red Sox roses

Early Xmas for Bobby, and coal in the stockings for a few Xmases to come for the majority of Red Sox Nation who seemed to be giving a big thumbs down to Valentine.

Since: Oct 11, 2011
Posted on: November 30, 2011 11:09 pm

Valentine falls into bed of Red Sox roses

I think this is a really good hire for the BoSox.  Valentine said last week something like "30 whippings' isn't today's discipline, so I think he will be toned down a bit for this job...with emphasis on "a bit".  Can't mistake that he has a fine baseball mind, is good for the short term and will be a thorn in the Yankees side.  I am a big time Yankee follower and he took the Mets-Yankees rivalry very seriously and played around with the Yankees emotions at that time.  I can only imagine how seriously he will take beating, and finishing ahead of, the Yankees.  He might have a "churn and burn" 2-3 years with Boston, but I can't see them being nothing short of second place in the AL East and serious WS contenders during those 2-3 years.  After that, he will likely wear out his welcome like he has done before. 

Since: Jan 7, 2009
Posted on: November 30, 2011 10:27 pm

Valentine falls into bed of Red Sox roses

To have an old-school manager like Valentine, with an established team like the Red Sox will be a bad mix. He was an average manager his whole career. On top of that, that last time he managed in the big leagues was 2002. Nine years is an awful long time to be away fron ANY profession, let alone a profession that has the turnover that baseball has.
One of the biggest complaints about Valentine, is his handling of pitching staffs. That's only the Red Sox biggest problem. Could the Sox play so well the first part of the season, that could just hide fron the rest of the division? Possibly, but not likely. Therefore the problem of handling the pitching staff, in the toughest division in baseball, will come up most every night.

The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or