Tag:Poll Reactions
Posted on: September 26, 2011 3:04 pm
Edited on: September 26, 2011 3:38 pm
 

Pac-12 poll reactions, Week 4

Posted by Bryan Fischer

This week's polls have been released. Here's how the Pac-12 fared, from the top of the polls to its bottom, and what it means.

(AP/Coaches)

6/5. Stanford

The Cardinal were off this past weekend as they rest up for Pac-12 play and figure out how to replace starting linebacker Shayne Skov, who was lost for the season. Stanford appears to ease into conference play with a home game against UCLA before Colorado comes into Palo Alto. Despite the bye, they actually leapfrogged Boise State in Coaches Poll, which is pretty interesting/bad voting on the coaches' part.

12/14. Oregon

Nothing like a late-night blow out vs. Arizona to bump the Ducks up in the polls (some losses to teams ahead of them helped too). LaMichael James' school-record breaking rushing performance will likely help Oregon get more positive attention nationally as well. They moved up four spots in the AP Poll and three in the Coaches'.

25/NR. Arizona State

Dennis Erickson's squad is back in the AP top 25 after dropping out briefly following their loss to Illinois. A thumping of USC to give the Sun Devils their first win over the Trojans since 1999 will tend to do that. The coaches are not as thrilled with their play as voters are, keeping them behind Houston and Ohio State in the "Others receiving votes" category. They'll play lowly Oregon State at home this week, so they should rise with another win and several teams in front of them losing.

Others receiving votes: Utah (12 points in the AP poll/11 Coaches), Washington (4 AP/3 Coaches), USC (2 AP)


Posted on: September 26, 2011 2:13 pm
Edited on: September 26, 2011 5:34 pm
 

SEC Poll Reactions, Week 4

Posted by Jerry Hinnen

This week's polls have been released. Here's how the SEC fared, from the top of the polls to the bottom, and what it means.

LSU. We wrote late Saturday that you couldn't go wrong with either the Bayou Bengals or the Crimson Tide at the top of a ballot, so yes, from here LSU's ascension to the No. 1 spot in the AP poll looks entirely deserved. What's interesting is that the voting wasn't even that close; Les Miles's team drew more the double the first-place votes of previous No. 1 Oklahoma and the Tide combined.

Two points to be made from this development:

1. Aggressive nonconference scheduling can pay off. The "three victories over ranked teams on the road" soundbite is a bit of an exaggeration -- the "neutral" site in Dallas was far closer and cozier to LSU than Oregon, and Mississippi State, only No. 25 at the time, is deservedly nowhere near the polls now -- but there's still no question which team has the best overall resume in the country right now. That LSU is now in poll position to potentially lose a game somewhere and still reclaim their BCS title-game spot with a win over Alabama is a just reward for their willingness to challenge themselves.

2. The AP poll deserves kudos for their voters' willingness to respond to results on the field and adjust accordingly. It wasn't that long ago the Sooners would have held the top spot come hell or high water, as long as they didn't lose. Thankfully, where the AP is concerned, those times are behind us.

ALABAMA. As much fun as the polls are to track and debate, when you're in the Tide's position, it doesn't honestly matter where you're ranked at this stage. If Alabama continues winning -- particularly against LSU -- it will reach the No. 1 spot, no questions asked.

But it remains odd to see the Tide badly trailing LSU and Oklahoma in first-place votes, leaving them third in the AP and tied for second with LSU in the Coaches. If the Tide don't have LSU's overall body of work, in Saturday's total domination of Arkansas they also put together the most complete single-game performance of any team in the FBS this year, considering the opponent. With Oklahoma struggling to put away Missouri at home and Florida State absorbing a second loss (and in turn making the Sooners' win in Tallahassee less impressive), it's a close call ... but after watching Saturday's performance, we'd favor the Tide, and we find it surprising more voters don't.

SOUTH CAROLINA. The Gamecocks are now officially a top-10 team in both polls, moving up to 9th in the Coaches and 10th in the AP. But they're still not doing it by overwhelming the voters' impression of them; they simply moved up one spot to account for Texas A&M's loss in the Coaches and two for that and Florida State's in the AP.

No one in Columbia's going to complain about occupying a top-10 slot when Stephen Garcia's playing as poorly as he is, but we asked last week why the Gamecocks were ranked behind an Oregon team with a worse record and worse resume, and that still stands. Carolina is undefeated, the Ducks aren't; Carolina has beaten Georgia on the road, Navy and Vanderbilt all teams with better records than anyone the Ducks have beaten. To rank Oregon higher means voters are simply guessing that they're better--and at this point of the season, shouldn't they be relying on something other than guesswork?

FLORIDA. The Gators continue to rise, moving from 15th to 12th in both polls thanks to losses from the Aggies, 'Noles, and Razorbacks. The same complaint regarding Oregon could maybe be repeated here (the Ducks are one spot ahead in the Coaches, three in the AP), but with wins over FAU, UAB and a terrible Kentucky team, the Gators don't have nearly the quality-of-victory the Gamecocks do.

ARKANSAS. The Razorbacks fell to 18th in both polls, a slide of six spots in the Coaches and just four in the AP. This seems extremely generous on the part of the voters--yes, the Hogs are likely good enough to eventually win their way back into the top 15 or even top 10 by season's end, but at this point their entire resume consists of: 1. Blowing out an FCS team; 2. Blowing out New Mexico, potentially the worst team in the FBS; 3. Beating Troy by 10 points 4. Being routed by Alabama.

The Razorbacks are a good team. But until they prove it by beating quality competition, they have no business being ranked in front of teams like Michigan, Georgia Tech or Illinois, all of which have victories (or two) over likely bowl teams tucked away. Again: guesswork should be for preseason polls, not for those in Week 4.

EVERYBODY ELSE: In the Coaches, no other SEC team is receiving more than the 3 points pulled by Tennessee, good enough to make the Vols "No. 37." Auburn somehow checks in the third-team-out position in the AP -- clearly, not media members saw the Tigers wheeze past awful FAU Saturday night, when they outgained the Owls by all of eight yards -- but aren't quite "knocking on the door" of the poll yet; they're still 97 points behind No. 25 Arizona State.

Still, a win at South Carolina this weekend (however unlikely that seems after Saturday) would seem to lock up an AP spot for Auburn next week.


Posted on: September 26, 2011 11:36 am
 

Big East poll reactions (Sept. 25)

Posted by Chip Patterson

The new polls were released on Sunday, and as suggested by Brett McMurphy - holder of an AP ballot - LSU has taken over as the top team in the nation. The coaches poll reflects otherwise, with the Sooners holding on to No. 1 and Alabama locked with the Tigers in a tie for second.

In the Big East, the conference continues to only see South Florida and West Virginia receive any attention from the voters. The Bulls continue their climb up the rankings after their third straight 35+ point performance. West Virginia slipped to No. 22 after falling to LSU at home on Saturday night. With Cincinnati still trying to prove themselves and Pittsburgh continuing to frustrate their fans with inconsistent play, it is hard to find many more teams in the conference worthy of even consideration for a national ranking.

South Florida (AP: 16/Coaches: 14) - The Bulls weren't exactly known for their high-powered offense in 2010, and averaged just 11.0 points in their five losses. But four games into the 2011 season, junior quarterback BJ Daniels is leading one of the most prolific offenses in the nation. Voters and fans alike are impressed with 523.3 yards per game (9th nationally) and 45.5 points per game (10th nationally). The fast start will be met with a challenging stretch ahead for Skip Holtz's team. USF has just one home game (Oct. 22 against Cincinnati) between now and the mid-November. Surviving the extended road test will make or break the Bull's Big East title chances and be reflected in their climb or fall in the polls.

West Virginia (AP: 22/Coaches: 23) - The Mountaineers get credit for climbing back in the third quarter against the AP's new No. 1 team, still hanging on near the bottom of the rankings. Quarterback Geno Smith made some plays under center, but when you throw the ball 65 times against LSU's secondary you are going to expect some interceptions. After facing Maryland and LSU, the Mountaineers will face Bowling Green on Saturday before finishing their schedule against all seven Big East opponents. Rankings will mean much less to West Virginia for the rest of the season, with the focus being on winning the conference title.

Other receiving votes: Not Applicable

Keep up with the latest college football news from around the country. From the regular season all the way through the bowl games, CBSSports.com has you covered with this daily newsletter. | Preview
Posted on: September 19, 2011 6:01 pm
Edited on: September 19, 2011 6:35 pm
 

Big Ten poll reactions, Week 3

Posted by Adam Jacobi

This week's polls have been released. Here's how the Big Ten fared, from the top of the polls to the bottom, and what it means.

(AP/Coaches)

6/7. Wisconsin

Wisconsin stays moving up, and for this I'm happy; the Badgers have looked like a Top 5 or 6 program every step of the way thus far, and now they're only 5 voter points away from overtaking Oklahoma State in the coaches poll. Of course, some voters might have a problem with the Wisconsin schedule thus far, and that's a valid thing to take into account (especially at this point in the season). So no howls of outrage here by any stretch -- especially when there's the rest of the poll to take umbrage with.

9/9. Nebraska

Needless to say, if I didn't agree with Nebraska's ranking last week, I'm not going to agree with it this week -- they're No. 16 in my Top 25, because I don't do the straight win-go-up, lose-go-down polling thing. The Huskers don't look like a Top 10 team at all so far -- not when it takes so long for the Huskers to put away the likes of Fresno State and Washington in Lincoln. They also don't look like a .500 team either, because this year's crop of teams drops off pretty precipitously after the first two tiers, and Nebraska looks to be on that third tier. Don't get me wrong -- they're still the team to beat in the Legends division. But 9th in the nation? No. Nooo no no no. Not yet. Not like this. 

22/21. Michigan

I personally still don't have Michigan in my Top 25 yet -- they're mighty close -- but I understand this ranking and I don't have much of a problem with it -- as of right now. Denard Robinson still terrifies me throwing the ball, though, and I still think this all crashes down in the last half of the season in a big way, but if Michigan takes care of SDSU this weekend and handles its first road test at Northwestern (who should have a healthy Dan Persa by then), it'll have earned a Top 20 spot.

UR/23. Michigan State

Yes, Michigan State is still ranked in the coaches poll and Illinois is not. The coaches poll is a joke. The real coaches don't even participate. I don't want to cover it like a serious thing anymore, but it just so happens to be a third of the BCS calculations so here we are every week, going through with this. Ugh.

24/UR. Illinois

With the Saturday win over then-No. 22 Arizona State, Illinois catapulted itself into the national conversation for the time being, and good for the Illini; they've got a legit quarterback in Nathan Scheelhaase, a productive defense with a mean streak, and a schedule that lends itself to maybe as many as 10 regular season wins. They could -- nay, should be 6-0 heading into a home date with Ohio State on October 15. Giddyup!

Also receiving votes: Illinois (90 coaches votes), Michigan State (42 AP votes), Ohio State (16 AP votes, 92 coaches votes), Penn State (19 coaches votes), Northwestern (1 coaches vote)

Posted on: September 19, 2011 5:38 pm
 

Big East poll reactions, Week 3

Posted by Chip Patterson

The new polls were released on Sunday, and the Big East saw their two nationally ranked representatives make a step up after convincing wins. West Virginia had a convincing win by defeating a competitive opponent away from home. South Florida impressed voters with a casual 745 yards of total offense in a 70-17 win.

West Virginia (AP: 16/Coaches: 16) - The Mountaineers have continued to be incredibly efficient on offense, but it was the defense's ability to come up with stops and turnovers early that impressed on Saturday. Maryland was able to climb back into the game with a bruising rushing attack, but all things considered it was an impressive non-conference victory for head coach Dana Holgorsen. The Mountaineers face their toughest challenge of the season on Saturday, welcoming the No. 2 LSU Tigers to Morgantown in primetime. If the Mountaineers can produce some offense on the rigid Tigers' D, they could give themselves a chance for the upset.

South Florida (AP: 18/Coaches: 17) - After three weeks of observation, the Bulls are finally starting to prove that their opening week upset of Notre Dame was no fluke. USF once again mightily handled their MEAC opponents, as quarterback BJ Daniels broke his own career-high numbers that were set just a week before. South Florida currently has no ranked opponents on their schedule before the season finale against No. 16 West Virginia on Dec. 1., so it will be difficult to make big jumps in the polls. Under the direction of head coach Skip Holtz, I don't expect the Bulls to get distracted by rankings anytime soon.

Other Receiving Votes - None. Pittsburgh blew a fourth quarter lead to Iowa, Syracuse lost by three touchdowns to USC, and Cincinnati blasted an inferior Akron squad. For right now, the Mountaineers and Bulls are representing the entire conference by themselves in the eyes of the national fan. Could be worse, there have been times it is ONLY West Virginia's banner to carry.

Keep up with the latest college football news from around the country. From the regular season all the way through the bowl games, CBSSports.com has you covered with this daily newsletter. | Preview
Posted on: September 19, 2011 4:40 pm
Edited on: September 19, 2011 4:41 pm
 

Big 12 Poll Reactions, Week 3

Posted by Tom Fornelli

The new polls came out on Sunday, so let's take a look at which schools in the Big 12 get to continue putting a number next to their name this week, and discuss whether they should have that number or not.

Oklahoma (AP:1/Coaches:1) - The last few weeks I had some questions about whether or not Oklahoma truly deserved to be the top-ranked team in the country since the Sooners had only won one game against Tulsa, while LSU went out and beat Oregon to start the season. Well, I can keep my mouth shut now because Oklahoma went on the road -- something it's had trouble with the last few years -- and took down Florida State in front of a very hostile crowd in Tallahassee. The majority of the credit for the win, however, has to go to the Oklahoma defense. It wasn't exactly a wonderful night for Heisman hopeful Landry Jones, as he threw for only 199 yards and 1 touchdown while also throwing 2 interceptions. Not exactly the kind of performance a Heisman Trophy winner has in big games.

Oklahoma State (7/6) - The Cowboys jump up a spot in each poll, and a part of me has to laugh at this a little bit. Not because I don't feel that Oklahoma State deserves the ranking, but only because I have serious doubts about how many voters in both polls actually watched Oklahoma State's victory over Tulsa early Sunday morning. I'd also bet that most of them turned in their ballots before the game even started under the impression of "They're gonna kill Tulsa, so let's rank 'em a bit higher this week." Truth be told, Oklahoma State's defense did not have it's best night/morning of the season, but I'm going to give the unit a break seeing as how most of the points it surrendered came after 2am. I know this because I actually watched the game. Why? I don't know. I have a problem.

Texas A&M (8/8) - Much like the Cowboys, the Aggies also enjoyed the fruits of Oklahoma's victory by climbing up a spot following Florida State's loss. The Aggies haven't exactly faced a team that can truly test their top ten status in their first two games, but they've gone out and filled the role of what a team with this ranking is supposed to do with inferior competition thus far. So it's hard to argue with A&M's ranking, but a pretty large game looms on the schedule this weekend when Oklahoma State comes to town. Only one of these two teams will be in the top ten next week.

Baylor (17/19) - I'd like to take a moment to congratulate the voters of the coaches poll. Sure, seeing Baylor beat TCU on the first weekend of the season wasn't enough for you to justify putting Baylor ahead of TCU in your rankings the first two weeks, but after seeing the Bears take care of mighty Stephen F. Austin this weekend, you finally took them seriously. Good for you.

Texas (19/18) - Longhorns, I hadn't been all that kind to you in the poll reactions the last two weeks. It was my feeling that the only reason you were ranked was because you were Texas, and not because of anything you'd done on the football field. Well, that has changed thanks to a very nice win on the road against UCLA this week. Am I convinced that you're a top 20 team? No, the quarterback situation is still a bit iffy, even if it does seem more stable at the moment. However, you definitely deserve to be ranked, but I'd have you more in the 21-25 range.

Drop Outs: None.

Receiving Votes: Iowa State showed up on a few more ballots in both polls this week after beating UConn on the road Friday night, but it didn't get enough to gain entrance to the top 25. Which is probably right. Iowa struggling at home to beat Pitt kind of lessened that win for Iowa State last week, and UConn isn't exactly a powerhouse, but Iowa State should be happy with what it's done and where it is.  The Cyclones have a week off before hosting Texas in their next game. Win that one, and we'll see you up above.

Then there's Missouri, which bounced back from its loss against Arizona State with an easy 69-0 win over Western Illinois. Of course, how many votes Missouri gets next week after travelling to Norman this weekend, we'll have to wait and see.
Posted on: September 18, 2011 10:04 pm
Edited on: September 26, 2011 2:10 pm
 

SEC Poll Reactions, Week 3

Posted by Jerry Hinnen

This week's polls have been released. Here's how the SEC fared, from the top of the polls to its bottom, and what it means.

LSU/ALABAMA. Back and forth we go. A week after the Tide leapfrogged the Bayou Bengals in the AP poll by the slimmest of margins, LSU's overwhelming defensive performance on the road in Starkville -- and in Thursday night prime-time -- was enough to push them back ahead in the media balloting. Alabama couldn't have been much more dominant than they were in thumping North Texas 41-0 ... but with the game airing on regional pay-per-view, did enough media get a look at it?

In any case, the coaches didn't mind; though the Tigers collected five first-place votes to the Tide's four, Alabama's 38-point margin only shrunk to 29. And it's not like the Tide won't have a chance to surge back in front -- possibly for good -- when they tangle with Arkansas in the league's highest-profile game to-date this Saturday.

SOUTH CAROLINA. It's not an easy trick to fall two spots in one poll and rise one space in the other, but after the Gamecocks' 24-21 escape against Navy, Carolina managed it. Only eight points separate teams 10 through 12 in the media poll, but unfortunately for the Gamecocks, they wound up team No. 12, five points behind Florida State and three more behind Oregon.

On the one hand, the Gamecocks can't complain too much when they struggle so badly with a lesser opponent like the Midshipmen. On the other, the four teams defeated by the Seminoles and Ducks so far this season are ULM, Charleston Southern, Nevada and Missouri State--as strong as the teams FSU and Oregon lost to are, should they really be ranked ahead of an undefeated team with two wins (Navy and Georgia) stronger than any claimed by the two teams in front of them?

The Coaches would seem to agree; the Seminoles dropped to No. 14 and the Gamecocks moved up a slot to No. 11.

ARKANSAS. The poll-vs.-poll debate regarding Florida State also affected the Hogs. With the Coaches dropping the 'Noles to 14, the Hogs got a one-spot bump from 13 to 12; the AP keeping FSU up at No. 11 meant the Hogs likewise stayed at 14. Given the cupcake-laden slate the Hogs have faced thus far (and their struggles with Troy), though, it's hard to argue Arkansas deserves to be any higher.

FLORIDA. No SEC team has made a more consistent charge up the ballots than the Gators, who after their decisive win over Tennessee have reached the No. 15 spot in both polls. But with the 14 teams in front of them all members of the preseason top 15, the Gators may have hit their ceiling until a few more losses open things up. (Which is not to say that's how it should be; having seen off a quality team in the Vols, the same complaints regarding Carolina vs. Oregon and Florida State apply here, too.)

EVERYBODY ELSE. With Auburn falling to Clemson and Mississippi State dismissed so rudely by LSU, the SEC can still claim a full third of the top 15--but after starting the season with eight teams of the polls, those first five teams are now the only ones to still make the top 25 cut. Auburn is the only team even close, ranking "No. 27" in the AP.

And frankly, that's the way it should be. With the Tigers so unimpressive in getting clubbed by their South Carolinian mascot equivalents, the Vols unable to survive the Swamp, and Vanderbilt not yet proven top-25 caliber (though we applaud the 'Dores for picking up a handful of votes in both polls), the next SEC team to make the ballot will have to prove it belongs.



Posted on: September 11, 2011 10:12 pm
 

Pac-12 poll reactions, Week 2

Posted by Bryan Fischer

This week's polls have been released. Here's how the Pac-12 fared, from the top of the polls to its bottom, and what it means.

(AP/Coaches)

6/6. Stanford

The Cardinal traveled east to play Duke in week two and while they didn't start out particularly sharp, they finished as you would expect and rolled to a 44-14 victory. The team hasn't really played a marquee game yet but they're led by one of the preeminent players in the country in Andrew Luck so they're still on the national radar. They picked up points in both polls and should figure to move up with a late night win against Arizona this weekend since either Oklahoma or Florida State figure to slide down after the two meet in Tallahassee.

12/14. Oregon

Nevada seemed to be the perfect cure for the Ducks' Texas hangover. The defense was swarming and the offense looked like they were back in top gear. Darron Thomas was sharp and efficient but the star of the game was freshman athlete De'Anthony Thomas, who racked up 204 all-purpose yards and two touchdowns. Oregon is behind a host of undefeated teams and will make a slow climb back into the top 10 as they keep winning big and others start losing games as the season progresses. They're better than their ranking indicates but it will take a while for them move up.

22/18. Arizona State

Dennis Erickson's squad is back in the top 25 after a three-year absence thanks to a big overtime win against Missouri in front of a national television audience. It's a little concerning that they allowed the Tigers to come back in the 4th quarter but the offense looked much better than many people thought. They'll be back in the spotlight again this week with a game against Illinois before starting conference play against USC.

Others receiving votes: USC (68 points in the AP poll), Washington (12 AP, 7 Coaches), Cal (6 Coaches)


 
 
 
 
The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or CBSSports.com