Protocol in Tackling
The storylines are all too familiar in this week’s NFL: concussions, Big Ben injury updates, Giants mid-season funk, dysfunction in Jetsland, Tebow talk, etcetera.
And when the topic is concussions, “protocol” is the buzz word that swarms the hive. Protocol, in health assessment, is a good thing. It means people are taking notice and then steps to try to prevent, or at least lessen a dangerous state.
Here’s another word to put in your cabeza when the talk is concussions: cheap-shot.
Cheap-shot practitioners have been around since the days of leather-helmets. But it was the Raiders Jack “Assassin” Tatum who popularized the dirty hit in the 70s (SB11 / White) and began the gradual amelioration of their negative perception by fans and players alike.
Some concusses are unavoidable, part of the inherent danger of the game. Cases in point: Mike Vick, Ryan Clark and Cliff Avril all concussed on routine plays in Wk-10. Others are of the cheap-shot variety, a product of choice, like the too-wicked hit laid on Bears’ QB Jay Cutler by Houston Texans’ linebacker and Tatum disciple Tim Dobbins in Sunday night‘s wet clash.
Dobbins sighted his victim and then, rather than lower his shoulder, aim at Cutler’s mid-region and knock the wind out of him, he aims high, leads with helmet and after laying Jay out, raises his hands in a weak-attempt to avoid criticism he knows is due. It’s a too-dangerous tactic too many defenders refuse to lose. Tim was flagged (UR) (fined 30T) and Cutler pulled himself up off the ground and stayed in until tossing an INT.
Funny how baseball players charge the field at the drop of a hat to defend a teammate’s honor, while footballers stand around their fallen brother, acting the models of good behavior. The League does what it can by way of instruction, fines & suspensions, but cheap-shots won’t wane until players take matters into their own hands and police the hit-parade. I’m not holding my breath.
Coaches, on the other hand, they can find shelter behind protocol.
Bears Coach Lovie Smith speaking after Texans game: “Symptoms (concussion) weren’t displayed right away (by Jay)…There’s a protocol we go through when a player has a concussion.” That’s cute, Lovie. Any lay-person who saw the too-heavy hit on Jay and the prone state it put him in, could easily discern that the QB was a serious candidate for a medical determination of concussion. But rather than take a pro-active approach by taking Jay out of the game and harm’s way, Smith (like others) bank on a standard that buys time and waits first for “symptoms” to manifest.
Because the League’s ham-strung (NFLPA / captured media), because players won’t institute their own tackling protocol, coaches, on-field and in the booth, become the last line of defense on concussion matters. If Lovie Smith can’t meet this reasonable duty, Halas Hall best find someone who can.
A belated thank you to all military veterans, past and present, in air, land & sea, American and allied. I’d like to think my enjoyment of combat movies stems in part from my appreciation for the risks and sacrifices service people make. A favorite is Darryl Zanuck’s 1962 B&W, star-studded film “The Longest Day,” a multi-national work that chronicles D-Day, the Allied landing at Normandy on June 6, 1944. Top notch.
Cherry Picks Week 11
Green Bay Packers (6-3) @ Detroit Lions (4-5) (11-18 / Fox 1:00)
Best of Wk-11’s intriguing field general match-ups. Seems like oft-injured Stafford’s never made it this far into a season. Stats aren’t showy but Matt, along with capable D, keeps Lions viable, while low-priority run-game withers. Pack feels dangerous coming off bye and 4-gm win-streak, but like Lions, GB run-show under-whelms (2TD). Rodgers is sublime (25-5), just spare us the pantomime, okay Aaron? Foot facts: Vet Lions’ K’er Hanson PROB (L), GB P’er Masthay super IN-20 (24). Edge to hometown Lions.
New York Jets (3-6) @ St. Louis Rams (3-5-1) (CBS 1:00)
Both QBs having sub-par years and looking for break-out game. Bradford’s got the edge in YDS, COMP%, TD-ratio, AVG, Sanchez should get a medal for bearing the pressure. Mark’s decision-making must improve and up-tick run-game might help his focus. Side generals spice it up, Fisher gets time to build, Ryan feeling the heat. With injuries rising and effort being questioned, emotions running high and Gang green wins one for Rex.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers (5-4) @ Carolina Panthers (2-7) (Fox 1:00)
This one’s got potential for fireworks. Bucs surging of late (4-1) while 4 of Cats last 5 losses (bar DEN) average by < 3 pts. Skills are there but Cam must embrace the pain, ride out storm and feast on TB pass-D (32). Carolina team-ranks decent (Kuechly 87T) but Rivera’s wrong allowing QB as top runner. Freeman solid (18-5) and RB Martin (862-7) making waves, though SD slowed the surge (68). WTW: Cat pressure (25-S) on guarded Josh (13-S) and Newton ability to sit-tite & spread the pass . Panthers get a W.
New Orleans Saints (4-5) @ Oakland Raiders (3-6) (Fox 4:05)
A return of all-purpose Sproles (PROB) adds dimension to Brees offense, though Ivory & Ingram picked-it-up vs Falcons. Gotta’ like Palmer’s production (15-9 / 2723 / 61%) with pedestrian run-game. Only thing worse than NO’s run-D (30) is their pass-D (31) so CP should work the air-lanes. But key Q’ables (Branch / H-Bey / Goodson / McFad’n / Myers / Janikowski / Seymour) make much needed home win that much harder. Saints keep marching & win.
San Diego Chargers (4-5) @ Denver Broncos (6-3) (CBS 4:25)
“Ac-cen-tuate the positive.“ That’s Norv Turner’s motto this week in prep for Denver re-match. First half of Wk-6 loss (35-24) was Chargers’ heaven, going up big. Whatever worked that half to stop the lordly one (Peyton), do it again. Fox does the same, using 2nd half battle plan to befuddle the mystery man (Rivers). David’s still got it (2203 / 7.3 / 68%) but presses at times (15-12). Risky going against Manning, McGahee & Woodyard at home but SD has balance, knows Denver and like Jets, are motivated. Upset Alert: Chargers win.
Indianapolis Colts (6-3) @ New England Patriots (6-3) (CBS 4:25)
If you're an advertiser, this is the time-slot you want. Luck v Brady is marketing gold. Both teams sizzle, winning 5 of 6, though most weren’t mettle-games. Andy looks the young pro most expected (58% / 2631 / 7.3) with growing pains (10-9), while Tom is the un-sung MVP aspirant (65% / 18-3 / 2645 / 7.4) beaming over run-game (Ridley / Bolden) and improved run-D (9). NE injuries mount but Belichick battle-plan red-lights Colts’ joy-ride in Foxsborough. Patriots win.
NFL Hunch Line