Tag:College Football Hall of Fame
Posted on: May 1, 2009 12:52 am
Edited on: May 1, 2009 12:53 am

The college football hall of fame and the f word

You might have noticed that the College Football Hall of Fame announced its latest inductees on Thursday. Fine men, all of them, but as long as Chuck Ealey remains off that list, the hall is a fraud.

With a capital F.

Try being a black quarterback at any level in the late 60s, early 70s. That was Chuck Ealey. In his four seasons at Toledo he went 35-0 as a starter. That's the best record, ever, by a college starting quarterback. From the beginning of high school to his first year of a distinguished career in the CFL, Ealey lost once.

The NFL didn't draft him after Ealey made it known that he wanted to play quarterback, having led the Rockets to what is now the fourth-longest winning streak in history. Unfortunately, discrimination was alive and well back then. Coaches and general managers didn't consider him at his natural position largely because of his race.

He has been kept out of the hall because of a technicality. To be considered for the hall of fame, players must make an All-American team recognized by the NCAA. Ealey was a Football News All-American in 1971. The NCAA didn't recognize the Football News All-American team until 1983. Is that a reason to keep out one of the most accomplished players in history?

Of course not. The site InductChuck.com is doing all it can to keep Chuck's legacy alive. Today, he is a 58-year-old businessman in Toronto, a credit to his company, his school and his sport. He was long ago resigned to his fate despite having every reason to be bitter.

The hall of fame is supposed to be about athletic accomplishments and also fame. Ealey has been a credit to the game and also his race. The hall looks petty and foolish for not allowing Ealey in. It changed its rules a couple of years ago by inducting Joe Paterno and Bobby Bowden while they were still active. The hall wanted to honor the two coaching greats while they were still alive.

One of Thursday's inductees was Harvard's William Lewis, the first African-American All-American in history (1893). One-hundred sixteen years later, the winningest African-American quarterback in history can't join Lewis because of some fine print. The hall should do the right thing for Chuck Ealey. It would bring glory to a great player and credibility to a hall that lacks what it takes to be truly great.

Posted on: March 13, 2008 1:48 pm
Edited on: March 13, 2008 2:35 pm

National notes

I don't have much of a problem with Clemson getting out from underneath Ray Ray McElrathbey's scholarship. I do have a problem with the way they announced it.

The school has done everything possible to avoid saying they are trying to free up a scholarship by offering the backup tailback a graduate assistant's job. It's obvious that McElrathbey is not longer needed now that Clemson has one of the deepest tailback stables in the country. McElrathbey is not going to get on the field. His brother Fahmarr has $100,000 in a trust fund that the NCAA graciously allowed to be formed when their parents' negligence forced Ray Ray to take in his brother.

McElrathbey's situation is not so much a gesture of largesse on the part of Clemson, but as a way to make the school and athletic department look good. And it hides a little-known way of doing business.

For example, it is up to the school's discretion whether a scholarship player transitioning to grad assistant is able to eat at the training table. Kids sign an athletic scholarship expecting all the accompanying perks. McElrathbey seemingly will be well taken care ofl. He would receive a stipend for his meals if he chooses to become a GA, the school said. AD Terry Don Phillips has said McElrathbey will receive financial aid if he becomes a grad assistant..

Clemson isn't being as heartless as it might seem.  It will help Ray Ray find another school if he chooses to transfer in order to play out his final two years of eligibility. This is a lot more than they could have done for a kid who has been in academic hot water in the past.

Somewhere in there, though, I'd like to see the school admit it needed the scholarship rather than covering itself with glory.

 There are a lot of things messed up about the college football hall of fame process. Some no-brainer candidates have been left out for years. One player who should already be in is Arizona State's Pat Tillman who appeared on this year's 75-player ballot this week.

Tillman is a national hero, plus an athletic (and academic) inspiration who should have been inducted posthumously the moment he died four years ago in Afghanistan. This is his first year on the ballot. Please, please, please voters. Do the right thing. The voters, by the way, are 12,000 National Football Foundation members and current hall of famers.

Here's the link so you can determine who you would pick to put in this year. Here's my list alphabetically:

Troy Aikman, UCLA (1984-88) He made two schools better. When Aikman determined that he wasn't going to work in a pro style offense at Oklahoma, he transferred to UCLA. When he left OU in 1985, it won a national championship with the triple option. Then there are all those Super Bowl rings.

Tim Brown, Notre Dame (1984-87)  The 1987 Heisman winner was one of the most durable and reliable receivers in NFL history.

Dave Casper, Notre Dame (1971-73) Before there was Kellen Winslow, there was Dave Casper.

Eric Dickerson, SMU (1979-82) He took the money and ran, or so they say. It's weird how many modern-day backs are compared Dickerson. He must have done something right.

Major Harris, West Virginia (1987-89) The precursor to the modern dual-threat quarterbacks. He was Vince Young before Vince Young.

Deion Sanders, Florida State (1985-88) How is this guy not in? Possibly the best college or pro corner ever. I hope the voters aren't turned off by his fashion sense.

Chris Spielman, Ohio State (1984-87) I hope my son grows up to be like Chris Spielman. A man's man, a great football player and a gentleman who gave up his career to be with his cancer-stricken wife. Hello, voters?

Lawrence Taylor, North Carolina (1977-80) Remember what I told you about no-brainers? The voters are obviously turned off by Taylor's brash style and NFL drug use but get over it. This guy changed the game and unlike a certain Heisman Trophy winner didn't beat a double murder rap.

 From the Too Much Information Dept.: Former Oklahoma linebacker Curtis Lofton recently explained why he ran slow 40s at the NFL combine. "I ate so much food, and I didn't use the bathroom the whole time I was down there."


The views expressed in this blog are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of CBS Sports or CBSSports.com