Is Eli an Elite qb and/or A Hall of Famer?

Request: Please don't put Romo in this catagory because for obvious reasons he's not one of the elite.  You're not elite until you've done it all and Romo hasn't done anything lately let alone done it all. 

Eli Manning didn't do it all...

The he was consistantly good all season (as was Tony), but noticed they only started winning games and got hot when the defense got healthy and chemistry going.

How long till you understand it takes a defense to win a championship... FUCK****!

not an elite QB yet but will be before he is finished.

Your right the defnse did get hot in the playoffs and played great in the playoffs, but again I will ask the same question I always do.  Where were they in the regular season?  In the regular season they were playing terrible, and Eli was keeping the team afloat.  If not for Eli the Giants wouldnt have even sniffed the playoffs. 

God I hope not.  But probably will.

the reason i dislike Eli Manning is because of the mockery he made of the draft - "im not going ot a small market team, based on the reputation of my big borther".

It still annoys me now.

He is good, but has fluked his way to two superbowls and now he is spoken in more glowing terms that Peyton.  Which is obviously rubbish.