Pats re-sign KidnPlay and Gisele should stay cute

Mazz just said the defense was a bigger reason



i quit 

With Reyes at the top of the lineup, another year from Miek Stanton, he'll have a much better yaer by default.

Dont count out aram either he put up pretty good numbers on an awful Cubs team and will bat either in front or behind braun

ok, had to vent, i'm out

75 pages today

good job gays


IM OUT!

Say what?

Wright last year in 102 G

.254/.345/.427/.771 114OPS+ 14HR/61rbi/60 runs  1.9 WAR
  
Zimmerman in 101 G

.289/.355/.443/.798 118OPS+ 12HR/49rbi/52 runs  2.5 WAR

I wouldn't say that is considerably better by any stretch.  

I'd also argue zimmerman has been better than wright offensively/defensively 3 years running

Zimmermans WAR over the last 3 years is 17.1 behind only Longoria, Wrights is 10th at 9.5 behind studs like Scott Rolen and Placido Polanco. 


please stay out of this Phislfan

Eagles SUck! 

Gonna be a rough 5 or so years dude....


Like the last 5 years hasn't been rough?

Please, come up with something new about the Mets and their future.

Oh by the way. Brady Sucks

Eli > Brady 

please stay out of this Phislfan

You guys can keep wright...I will be waiting for the Phillies to sign zimmerman that year anyways

Wrights is 10th at 9.5 behind studs like Scott Rolen and Placido Polanco. 



_____________

Kinda tells you all you need to know about  War,it sucks

Kinda tells you all you need to know about  War,it sucks

I think it tells you all you need to know about how bad wright has been in 2 of those 3 years and how bad he is defensively.

You guys can keep wright...I will be waiting for the Phillies to sign zimmerman that year anyways

Do we have a bet for most runs again this year? I need to have something competitive with you outside of fantasy. Straight up team vs team, no if a certain player plays a certain amount of games. 

Yes your right Polanco and Rolen are bettet than Wright

Do we have a bet for most runs again this year? I need to have something competitive with you outside of fantasy. Straight up team vs team, no if a certain player plays a certain amount of games. 

Works for me

Works for me

SAme thing? or do you want to up the stakes?

Maybe the loser takes the winner to the Giatns/Eagles game in the winners home stadium? 

Ryan Howard is just a somewhat better verison of Mark Reynolds.

Yes your right Polanco and Rolen are bettet than Wright

I don't think you realize just how eh wright has been.  He is an absolute butcher at third base...he at least used to be able to make a spectacular play a few years ago while making the routine plays look difficult...he doesn't even do that though anymore.  He is a better hitter than both...far worse defender...and they are pretty bunched together in terms of their WAR over those 3 years...they are pry the only 2 you can make a legit argument that he should be ranked over...but the argument would hinge solely on him being superior offensively...and his numbers vs. rolens aren't much different other than wright has played in 80 more games.

Ultimately it will come down to how much you value defense and trust the ratings that go into them.

Ultimately it will come down to how much you value defense and trust the ratings that go into them.

Rolen is still probably the best defensive 3B in baseball...the guy is amazing.

He can't hit anymore though.

He has said his bum shoulder feels better now than it has in years...we'll see.        

Same thing...without reyes and beltran for half the year i like my chances

Rolen is still probably the best defensive 3B in baseball...the guy is amazing.

---

I'd agree or at least put him right up there

i just think wright is surviving on what he was 3-4 years ago and the idea that he is still young and in his prime years than what he has actually done on the field the last 3 years. 

Ryan Howard is just a somewhat better verison of Mark Reynolds.

Better pure power at this point for reynolds...shame he can't hit at least around .270...he'd be an absolute stud.

Somebody please take a sledge hammer to this dbag's knee-cap already...