Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!

Best quarterback of the 2004 draft class

Views:      
 
 
-

Best quarterback of the 2004 draft class

February 10, 2012 8:21 am

It is a toss up between Eli and Ben.  They are different QBs, and bring different skill sets to the table.  However, they both win, and that is the final stat that matters.

 

Rivers can't get it done, despite having at times far superior teams at his disposal than Eli or Ben. 

Gastrapod
SinceFeb 18, 2008
-

Best quarterback of the 2004 draft class

February 11, 2012 3:40 am

The funny thing is if Rivers wins a SB then according to you HE will be the best QB because he has the best passer rating of all three by far. Funny how a silly little ring in a TEAM sport can change perceptions... 

Pure Mustard
SinceNov 5, 2006
-

Best quarterback of the 2004 draft class

February 11, 2012 6:26 am

Why is this even a question? Oh, thats right ebcause people live in the moment far too often. The fact remains when it comes to numbers Big Ben is ahead of Manning in most of the key stats that emasure a QB's effectiveness.

 

As far as the Super Bowl argument goes: Ben has participated in more Super Bowls and not too mention he secured (2) titles in a lesser amount of time than it took ELI. But too be completely honest, a SB title is the measure of a team's overall success. Not just the QB's play during the game.

HallofSteel
SinceFeb 11, 2012
-

Best quarterback of the 2004 draft class

February 11, 2012 8:45 am

The Giants where a good story this year winning a crappy division and staying hot throughout the playoffs. We will see the Gaints be hot again in 4 years. See you in 2015
Try next year numbnuts......Eli has become too damn great to simply take a dive next year...their team is built to win for years to come right now.  While last I looked, Pig Ben and his team were getting beat by Tim friggin Tebow in the playoffs.
Tikis-Barber
SinceFeb 7, 2007