Why Eli Manning is Overrated

Sigh. Said it before & I'm saying it again. Giants fans need this argument like fish need water. Without the "eli is/isn't elite" debate Giants fans wouldn't know what to do with their lives. This thread & any other that questions Eli's greatness stay at the top for months thus proving it.

I didnt know that a Giants fan started this thread!! Maybe if the haters stop making threads like this we would then know what to do with ourselves. Lame and weak bro!!

If you take a look Optimus, you would see that the top 4 active posters on any given Eli Manning thread at this point are some Giants fans, but definitely 3 Steelers fans and 1 Eagles fan that have united like Voltron.  They create them and when they die down, they either bump the old or start one brand new.  I spend plenty of time talking about all things Giants on the Giants boards with other fans, but some of us venture out here to the mains and respond.  As I'm sure you would respond if I were to start a thread proclaming that Harbaugh is an idiot or that the 49ers defense is overrated and just average.  I'm a tried and true Giants fan, I don't prefer to stand idly by and let some idiots try to talk about Eli Manning like he's freaking Trent Dilfer.  Surely you could understand that.

Navy, Eli Manning IS a Trent Dilfer.