How do you value Joe among all other QBs

Views:      
 
-

How do you value Joe among all other QBs?

February 24, 2013 1:09 pm
My previous post is just because I said I would answer questions as long as I (finally) got a straight answer.  Now that I know that you agree with what I've been saying this whole time (Manning and Ryan are average at best playoff QBs) and since I've only been focusing on playoff performances for Manning, Ryan, and Flacco, I can now bow out of this thread even though I'm sure DT will still continue arguing for the sake of arguing.  Enjoy folks
Oh, the irony. I never once said Manning/Ryan were anything better than average in the postseason as a whole. Never. All I said in the beginning was that I'd put Ryan ahead of Flacco, "but would understand if someone disagreed"

Now, I get it's committing a sin if a reg. disagreed with another reg, but, seriously, who was arguing just to argue?

It does need to be added that you are the one who said a guy is a poor playoff performer when certain stats regress in the postseason as opposed to the playoffs. Read again, especially the part where it's noted YOU said this. Not me. 

It was then proven that Brady was worse than Manning if we examined what makes a poor playoff performer. another reminder, it was you who said the above. Not me.

I certainly understand no one likes to kick his own ass, but just own up and say you might have made a mistake. Either that, or let me know you realize Manning is an equal playoff QB to Manning. You can choose.

dtgold88
SinceOct 29, 2012