UPDATE: Reyes has a left ankle sprain, the team announced. He is heading for more tests, including an MRI.
Reyes was in a lot of pain following the play and remained on the ground for several minutes. The trainers stabilized his foot/ankle before taking him off.
The 29-year-old Reyes has a history of hamstring problems, but this was obviously a fluke injury. Toronto acquired him from the Marlins as part of their 12-player blockbuster this offseason.