Play Fantasy The Most Award Winning Fantasy game with real time scoring, top expert analysis, custom settings, and more. Play Now
  • My Scores
  • MLB
  • Golf
  • NFL
  • Tennis

EOB's Imaginary Ballots: How we'd vote for the Hall of Fame

By Eye on Baseball staff

Barry Bonds is an all-time great and he gets EOB's collective Hall of Fame vote.
Barry Bonds is an all-time great and he gets EOB's collective Hall of Fame vote. (Getty)

Hall of Fame cases: Luis Gonzalez | Moises Alou | Lee Smith | Fred McGriff | Don Mattingly | Jack Morris | Rafael Palmeiro | Sammy Sosa | Edgar Martinez | Jeff Kent | Alan Trammell | Larry Walker | Mark McGwire | Tom Glavine | Frank Thomas | Mike Piazza |Mike Mussina | Curt Schilling | Craig Biggio | Tim Raines | Jeff Bagwell | Roger Clemens | Barry Bonds | Greg Maddux

At 2 p.m. ET this afternoon, the BBWAA will announce the 2014 Hall of Fame class. More than 500 voters -- including our own Jon Heyman -- have cast their ballots and players who appeared on at least 75 percent of those ballots will be inducted into Cooperstown. The public ballots collected at Baseball Think Factory suggest as many four players will be inducted today, though that data is incomplete.

Unlike Heyman, our three Eye On Baseball bloggers are not BBWAA members and do not have a Hall of Fame vote. None of us cast ballots this year or any year. That sure as heck won't stop us from having opinions though. Below are our imaginary ballots, the ballots we would submit if we had a vote. Which we don't, just to be clear. The players in the individual ballots are listed alphabetically.

As a reminder: ballots are limited to 10 players maximum, which is a silly and archaic rule and a bit of a problem nowadays.

Matt Snyder's Imaginary Ballot

  1. Jeff Bagwell
  2. Craig Biggio
  3. Barry Bonds
  4. Roger Clemens
  5. Tom Glavine
  6. Greg Maddux
  7. Mike Mussina
  8. Mike Piazza
  9. Curt Schilling
  10. Frank Thomas

My rule on PEDs would always be that if a player was suspended for a PED violation while the Joint Drug Agreement was in place, he will never get my vote. So that's a no to Rafael Palmeiro and a future no to guys like Manny Ramirez, Ryan Braun and Alex Rodriguez (unless he somehow wins his appeal). The guys above are the 10 best players on the ballot in my view, but not the only 10 deserving, as I'm a Big Hall guy, as has been noted in the past. I wouldn't try to strategically vote for guys in danger of falling off the ballot who I deem Hall-worthy, because I would view my responsibility to be attempting to vote for the 10 most deserving candidates and let the chips fall where they may from there.

Who else I'd vote for if no limit: Jeff Kent, Edgar Martinez, Don Mattingly, Fred McGriff, Mark McGwire, Tim Raines, Sammy Sosa, Alan Trammell and Larry Walker.

Dayn Perry's Imaginary Ballot

  1. Bagwell
  2. Biggio
  3. Bonds
  4. Clemens
  5. Glavine
  6. Maddux
  7. Mussina
  8. Piazza
  9. Raines
  10. Thomas

I'm not all that concerned about PED use, mostly because I think every generation of ballplayers in the main used whatever edge they could muster. There was nothing pure about the past; players of various "golden ages" were limited not by moral misgivings, but rather by the limits of technology. So let's all stop being so naive. With that said, I will penalize users based on, let's face it, blind guesses as to how they would've fared in a more "natural" state, but that's a wildly imprecise practice on my part.

Beyond all that, the ballot is now so crowded with obvious worthies that I'd vote for more than 10 if permitted. Here are the other guys I'd vote for if I had more slots to fill: Kent, Martinez, Rafael Palmeiro, Schilling, Trammell, Walker, Sosa and McGwire.

Mike Axisa's Imaginary Ballot

  1. Bagwell
  2. Biggio
  3. Bonds
  4. Clemens
  5. Glavine
  6. Maddux
  7. Mussina
  8. Piazza
  9. Raines
  10. Thomas

Like my two colleagues, there are way more than 10 players I'd vote for if given the opportunity. I'm stuck whittling my list down to the best of the best (of the best) and those are the 10 names who have the best Hall of Fame cases in my book.

I consider the Hall of Fame a museum and a record of the game's history, and PEDs are part of that history. History includes the good parts, the bad parts, and the ugly parts. It's all-encompassing. Pretending that the stuff we don't like didn't happen is disingenuous. Bonds and Clemens (and Piazza and Bagwell, etc.) are some of the greatest players in the history of the sport. A Hall of Fame without them is incomplete.

Other guys I'd vote for if not for the 10-vote limit: Kent, Martinez, McGwire, Palmeiro, Schilling, Sosa, Trammell and Walker.

CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre

mlb Video

August 28, 2014
Cliff Floyd talks David Price's career worst (2:40)
1 August 28, 2014
Yankees with 9-straight hits against David Price
2 August 27, 2014
MLB power rankings: 8/27
3 August 26, 2014
MLB Top 10: Best injured players


Most Popular Shop