Kansas City at Cleveland

Kansas City
W: R. Hernandez (6-9) L: J. Sowers (7-4)
S: J. Nelson (7)
HR: KC - None   CLE - None

Teammates exchange punches in dugout, Royals regroup for win

CBS SportsLine.com wire reports

CLEVELAND -- A season of frustrating losses has taken its toll on the Kansas City Royals.

Starting pitcher Runelvys Hernandez and catcher John Buck exchanged punches in the dugout Tuesday night, but the Royals regrouped for a 5-3 victory over the Cleveland Indians in the 1,000th game at Jacobs Field.

"It's September and there was some sort of misunderstanding," Royals manager Buddy Bell said. "Something was said and both guys are extremely competitive, but they have to have a little more poise. We met and straightened things out."

After striking out Ryan Garko with two runners on to end the third inning, Hernandez (6-9) jogged to the dugout, pointed at Buck and began yelling. The players charged each other and began throwing punches before being separated by teammates and coaches.

"Nothing happened," Hernandez insisted despite being told the skirmish was shown on television. "Everything's cool. Let's talk about the game. This was a good win. I thank my teammates for doing a good job."

Buck was unavailable for comment after Kansas City snapped an 11-game losing streak at Jacobs Field, where the Indians are 570-430 since the ballpark opened in 1994.

Both players remained in the game after the fight, and Hernandez allowed three runs over five innings to earn the win. It was Kansas City's first victory in Cleveland since July 20, 2005.

Joe Nelson pitched the ninth for his seventh save as the Royals got their 23rd road win, surpassing last year's total.

"He's done a good job for us," Bell said.

Nelson is perfect in save opportunities -- a rarity in a Kansas City bullpen that has blown 28 of them.

"I can't worry about anything except getting three outs," Nelson said. "You start thinking about past failures, you are halfway beat right there.

"I'm pitching to keep my job and to try and work my way into the mix for next season."

Esteban German went 4-for-4 and scored three times for the Royals. He doubled leading off the ninth, went to third on a foul out and scored on a throwing error by right fielder Shin-Soo Choo to make it 5-3.

German is batting .351 (39-for-111) in his last 43 games following a 2-for-27 (.074) streak.

Mark Grudzielanek drove in two runs for Kansas City and Buck hit an RBI single.

Indians starter Jeremy Sowers (7-4) gave up four runs and seven hits over five innings in his first loss since July 16 and final start of the season. The 23-year-old rookie is being shut down to avoid too much work after pitching a combined 185 2-3 innings between Triple-A Buffalo and Cleveland.

"It didn't dictate how I pitched," Sowers said. "I feel good. I would have liked to end on a better note."

The left-hander went 9-1 with a 1.39 ERA at Buffalo before being called up on June 24. The four runs Tuesday were the most he yielded in any of his 10 starts since July 22. During that time, he went 6-1 with a 2.33 ERA.

"He's done a fantastic job for us," manager Eric Wedge said. "He's done more than we ever anticipated."

Grudzielanek and Buck had RBI singles in the first inning to put the Royals ahead 2-0.

In the second, Garko was hit on the left elbow by a pitch from Hernandez, but plate umpire Gary Darling did not award him first base. Darling called the pitch a ball, saying Garko didn't try to get out of the way. Garko eventually walked and later scored on a single by Jhonny Peralta to make it 2-1.

Hernandez allowed eight hits and was helped by some solid defense. The Royals' infield turned double plays in each of the first two innings. In the third, left fielder German and center fielder David DeJesus both made nice catches against the wall to take away possible extra-base hits.

German had an RBI triple and scored on single by Grudzielanek to make it 4-1 in the fourth.

Cleveland got single runs in the fourth and fifth on a fielder's choice RBI by Joe Inglett and Garko's run-scoring single to make it 4-3.


  • Cleveland's Casey Blake had a stolen base taken away in the sixth when Peralta struck out and was called for interfering with Buck's throw.
  • Indians DH Travis Hafner had his broken right hand re-examined and said doctors told him he will not need surgery. He's out for the season.
  • Sowers held opponents to two or fewer runs in nine of his 14 starts this season.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Kansas City's Mark Grudzielanek makes a diving catch, robbing Andy Marte of a hit in the fourth inning.  (AP)
Kansas City's Mark Grudzielanek makes a diving catch, robbing Andy Marte of a hit in the fourth inning. (AP)

Players of the Game
Kansas City

E. German
AB 4
R 3
H 4
HR 0

J. Michaels
AB 4
R 1
H 2
HR 0

Related Video

April 21, 2017
This weekend in baseball: AL Central (1:19)
Kansas City Royals
Esteban German, LF-3B4341100
Mark Grudzielanek, 2B5122012
David DeJesus, CF-LF3000200
Emil Brown, RF5010014
Ryan Shealy, 1B5010013
John Buck, C4021001
Jeff Keppinger, 3B3110002
   a- Joey Gathright, PH-CF0000000
Paul Phillips, DH3000011
Andres Blanco, SS4000002
a-hit a sacrifice bunt for Keppinger in the 8th
2B - Esteban German 2 (, Sowers, Cabrera), Emil Brown (, Cabrera), Ryan Shealy (, Sowers)
3B - Esteban German (, Sowers)
SH - Joey Gathright (), Paul Phillips ()
RBI - Esteban German (), Mark Grudzielanek 2 (), John Buck ()
2-OUT RBI - Esteban German (), Mark Grudzielanek (), John Buck ()
Team LOB - 9
DP - Blanco-Grudzielanek-Shealy, Blanco-Grudzielanek-Shealy, Buck
E - Esteban German (, )
Kansas City Royals
Runelvys Hernandez (W,-) 5833310
Scott Dohmann (H,) 1100010
Jimmy Gobble (H,) 1000010
Joel Peralta (H,) 1000020
Joe Nelson (S,) 1100010
Pitches-Strikes - Runelvys Hernandez 95-57, Scott Dohmann 14-8, Jimmy Gobble 9-5, Joel Peralta 23-16, Joe Nelson 8-6
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Runelvys Hernandez 7-5, Jimmy Gobble 1-1, Joel Peralta 1-1
Batters Faced - Runelvys Hernandez 24, Scott Dohmann 3, Jimmy Gobble 3, Joel Peralta 4, Joe Nelson 4
Cleveland Indians
Grady Sizemore, CF5000011
Jason Michaels, LF4120101
Victor Martinez, C3000101
Ryan Garko, 1B3111122
Shin-Soo Choo, RF4020011
Casey Blake, DH4110002
Jhonny Peralta, SS4021011
Joe Inglett, 2B4011011
Andy Marte, 3B4010002
2B - Jhonny Peralta (, Ru. Hernandez), Andy Marte (, Nelson)
RBI - Ryan Garko (), Jhonny Peralta (), Joe Inglett ()
2-OUT RBI - Ryan Garko (), Jhonny Peralta ()
Team LOB - 8
E - Shin-Soo Choo (, )
Cleveland Indians
Jeremy Sowers (L,-) 5744320
Jason Davis 2100020
Fernando Cabrera 2311000
Pitches-Strikes - Jeremy Sowers 89-55, Jason Davis 27-19, Fernando Cabrera 32-23
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Jeremy Sowers 8-5, Jason Davis 3-1, Fernando Cabrera 2-4
Batters Faced - Jeremy Sowers 25, Jason Davis 7, Fernando Cabrera 9
Game Information
Attendance - 18883
Game Time - 2:55
Temperature - 68
Umpires - Home - Gary Darling, First Base - Scott Barry, Second Base - Bruce Dreckman, Third Base - Ed Hickox