Minnesota at Philadelphia

W: C. Pavano (8-6) L: R. Halladay (8-6)
HR: MIN - D. Span (2),J. Morneau (15)   PHI - W. Valdez (2)

Pavano outduels Halladay to set up Twins victory over Phillies

CBSSports.com wire reports

PHILADELPHIA -- Carl Pavano and Roy Halladay both threw strikes and pitched to contact. Minnesota was the team that found a few holes.

Pavano finished with a four-hitter for his second complete game this season, and Justin Morneau and Denard Span homered to lead the Twins past Halladay and the Philadelphia Phillies 4-1 on Sunday.

Pavano (8-6) won his third straight start while snapping a three-game road losing streak. The right-hander struck out two and walked none in his ninth career complete game.

"The ground balls were all gobbled up," Pavano said. "The boys played great behind me and we beat a tough pitcher today."

The only run Pavano allowed came on Wilson Valdez's sixth-inning homer. He retired the next 13 batters before Ryan Howard's two-out single in the ninth.

"Pavano was fantastic," Twins manager Ron Gardenhire said. "That's an unbelievable lineup they have over there, but he kept them off balance and got his pitches over for strikes."

Jason Kubel and Joe Mauer had RBI singles for the AL Central leaders, who pounded out 11 hits off Halladay and took the final two games of the three-game series. Minnesota rallied from a five-run deficit in the ninth inning Saturday and won in the 11th.

Halladay (8-6) lost his third straight start, giving up a season high in hits while striking out eight and walking none in eight innings. In his last two starts, the right-hander has yielded 10 runs (nine earned) and 19 hits, including five homers, in 14 innings.

"I pitched to contact and they put the ball in play and sometimes found holes," Halladay said. "The two homers are what really cost me."

Halladay didn't get much help from his offense, which appeared to be snapping out of its funk by scoring 32 runs in its last four games after averaging 2.4 runs during a 6-15 stretch. Besides Valdez's homer and Howard's hit, the Phillies got only a pair of fourth-inning singles by Placido Polanco and Chase Utley.

"We didn't put up enough offense to win," manager Charlie Manuel said. "Pavano held us down. He was moving the ball around, using all of his pitches. We hit some balls hard early, but they got caught."

Philadelphia has totaled nine runs in Halladay's six losses.

"My job is to focus on executing pitches whether we score nine or none," Halladay said.

Mauer's RBI single in the first inning scored Orlando Hudson. The Twins extended the advantage to two runs with Span's one-out homer in the fifth.

Valdez pulled the Phillies within 2-1 in the bottom half by hitting a home run to left for the second straight day. It marked a surprising power surge for Valdez, who homered once in his first 451 major league at-bats before connecting twice in his next six.

Minnesota, however, got the run back in the sixth when Morneau scored on Kubel's single to right.

Morneau reached second in strange fashion. He singled to center, took a big turn around first and raced to second when Shane Victorino threw behind him trying to get him out at first. Victorino was charged with an error on the play.

Kubel went 2 for 4, extending his hitting streak to 12 games while finally solving Halladay. Kubel entered 1 for 17 against the ace right-hander.

Morneau's solo homer to right in the eighth made it 4-1.


  • Minnesota OF Delmon Young has hit safely in 15 of 16 games after going 1 for 4 with a second-inning double.
  • Pavano's second-inning single was his first hit since 2004 with Florida. He had been hitless in his last nine at-bats.
  • Minnesota, which made its first trip to Citizens Bank Park, improved to 139-101 in interleague play.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Carl Pavano pitches a four-hitter to win his third straight start and gets the better of Roy Halladay.  (AP)
Carl Pavano pitches a four-hitter to win his third straight start and gets the better of Roy Halladay. (AP)

Players of the Game

J. Morneau
AB 4
R 2
H 2
HR 1

C. Pavano
IP 9.0
H 4
ER 1
BB 0
K 2

Related Video

April 21, 2017
This weekend in baseball: AL Central (1:19)
Minnesota Twins
Denard Span, CF4121001 .282
Orlando Hudson, 2B4110023 .292
Joe Mauer, C4011012 .304
Justin Morneau, 1B4221003 .340
Michael Cuddyer, 3B-RF4000021 .269
Jason Kubel, RF4021000 .255
    Matt Tolbert, 3B0000000 .227
Delmon Young, LF4010012 .306
Nick Punto, SS4010012 .255
Carl Pavano, P3010010 .333
2B - Delmon Young (17, Halladay)
HR - Denard Span (2, Halladay), Justin Morneau (15, Halladay)
SH - Carl Pavano (1)
RBI - Denard Span (26), Joe Mauer (31), Justin Morneau (47), Jason Kubel (39)
SB - Orlando Hudson (5, 2nd base off Halladay/Schneider)
Team LOB - 5
Minnesota Twins
Carl Pavano (W,8-6) 9411021 3.64
HBP - Victorino (by Carl Pavano)
Pitches-Strikes - Carl Pavano 105-76
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Carl Pavano 14-11
Batters Faced - Carl Pavano 32
Philadelphia Phillies
Shane Victorino, CF3000000 .247
Placido Polanco, 3B4010010 .313
Chase Utley, 2B4010001 .267
Ryan Howard, 1B4010003 .290
Jayson Werth, RF4000003 .278
Raul Ibanez, LF3000002 .244
Brian Schneider, C3000010 .250
Wilson Valdez, SS3111000 .250
Roy Halladay, P2000000 .116
   a- Ross Gload, PH1000000 .220
    Chad Durbin, P0000000 .000
a-grounded out for Halladay in the 8th
HR - Wilson Valdez (2, Pavano)
RBI - Wilson Valdez (12)
Team LOB - 4
DP - Utley-Valdez-Howard, Utley-Valdez-Howard
E - Shane Victorino (1, Throwing)
Philadelphia Phillies
Roy Halladay (L,8-6) 81143082 2.43
Chad Durbin 1000000 3.15
Pitches-Strikes - Roy Halladay 106-79, Chad Durbin 11-7
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Roy Halladay 10-4, Chad Durbin 1-2
Batters Faced - Roy Halladay 33, Chad Durbin 3
Game Information
Attendance - 45202
Game Time - 2:17
Temperature - 91
Umpires - Home - Adrian Johnson, First Base - Tim McClelland, Second Base - Todd Tichenor, Third Base - Mike Everitt