Cincinnati at Cleveland

W: F. Herrmann (1-0) L: C. Contreras (0-1)
HR: CIN - M. Olivo (1),D. Mesoraco (1)   CLE - L. Chisenhall (1),R. Raburn (1)

Indians 11, Reds 10


GOODYEAR, Ariz. (AP) - Terry Francona froze like a rookie manager.

When the winning run crossed home plate in the ninth inning Friday, giving Cleveland an 11-10 comeback win over the Cincinnati Reds in Francona's spring debut with the Indians, the two-time World Series winner wasn't quite sure what to do.

"I just don't know if everybody knew it was a walk-off," Francona said with a laugh. "Everybody was kind of looking around. Nobody knew how to act."

For Francona, it had been a while.

Back in a dugout for the first time since parting ways with the Boston Red Sox after the 2011 season, Francona opened a new era with the revitalized Indians, who after luring him away from broadcasting in October, spent nearly $120 million on free agents to improve a club that lost 94 games last season.

Francona's got some work to do to get the Indians back into contention, but this was a start.

"Yeah, today was good," Francona said. "The starters got three innings just like we wanted. Everybody got an at-bat or two to kind of shake off the rust a little bit."

There was plenty of corrosion as the teams combined for 21 runs, 27 hits, four homers and some horrendous pitching.

The Reds led 10-8 going to the bottom of the ninth before the Indians loaded the bases against reliever Carlos Contreras. Cincinnati manager Dusty Baker brought in Drew Hayes and Mike McDade, acquired on waivers from Toronto in November, sliced a three-run double into the left-field corner to win it.

Cincinnati's Joey Votto singled in his first two at-bats as the defending NL West champions built a 5-0 lead in the first with some help from the Indians, who let an easy fly ball drop to score two runs.

Votto, the 2010 NL MVP, reported to training camp healthy after missing 48 games in 2012 following two arthroscopic surgeries on his left knee. He's been given a spot on Team Canada's roster for the upcoming World Baseball Classic, but Votto wants to play a few more games and see how he feels before committing to the event.

Baker likes what he's seen so far from his first baseman.

"Joey looked great, actually," he said. "He was running the bases well. You didn't see any signs of anything. He swung the bat well."

Before the game, Francona lamented the Cactus League opener coming so early in camp.

"I wish we had a couple more days to do fundamentals, but we'll go play," he said. "We have a lot of stuff to go over because we're still new. It's a long spring."

It didn't take long to see the revamped Indians have some kinks to work out.

The Reds jumped to a quick 2-0 lead off starter Giovanni Soto on two hits, two walks and a passed ball by Indians catcher Carlos Santana, who tied for the AL lead with 10 last season.

Francona pulled Soto after seven batters, but the Indians' troubles continued when a soft fly ball hit by Cincinnati's Ryan Hanigan to right-center fell between Michael Bourn and Drew Stubbs for a two-run double.

Playing together for the first time, Bourn, a two-time Gold Glove center fielder with Atlanta and Stubbs, who played center for Cincinnati last season, looked at each other as the ball landed on Goodyear Ballpark's manicured grass like a golfer's wedge shot kissing a green.

"Not that I want those things to happen, but it's spring training," Francona said. "We can work on it."

Bourn accepted blame for the miscue and miscommunication. With Bourn, Stubbs and left fielder Michael Brantley, the Indians have a speedy outfield that will save runs so long as the ball gets caught. Bourn said it will take some time for the trio to gel.

"That's the biggest key in the first couple weeks, finding out what kind of range each other has," said Bourn, who signed a four-year, $48 million contract. "Because I'm in the middle, I want know what the corners look like and we have real good corner outfielders.

"There's pretty much three center fielders out there. We'll learn as we go."

The Indians scored three runs in their first at-bat with Nick Swisher, Brantley and Santana all driving in runs. Lonnie Chisenhall, who begins the season as Cleveland's everyday third baseman, hit a two-run homer to put the Indians ahead 7-5 in the third.

After he came out of the game in the fourth, the always-upbeat Swisher, given a four-year, $56 million free agent contract, was excited about his teammate's first real swings of the spring.

"We popped seven runs in the first three innings of our first game, man," he said. "Guys are really excited, just to get out there and get in those game-type situations where you can compete, not only against your own guys but against other teams.

"It was nice to get out there and shake the cobwebs off a little bit."

NOTES: INF/OF Ryan Raburn also homered for the Indians. He's trying to win a utility job after spending several seasons with Detroit. ... Catchers Devin Mesoraco and Miguel Olivo homered for the Reds. .... The two teams will play again Saturday with Cincinnati as the home team in the ballpark shared by Ohio's major leaguers. ... Francona met with baseball officials Joe Torre and Steve Palermo to discuss new rules, including the change that prohibits pitchers from faking to third and throwing to first. It's now a balk. "I'm OK with it," Francona said. "It was very difficult for umpires. I understand why they want to take it out." .... The announced attendance was 3,188.

Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Players of the Game

C. Santana
AB 2
R 1
H 2
HR 0

J. Votto
AB 3
R 1
H 2
HR 0

Related Video

Cincinnati Reds
Shin-Soo Choo, CF2100100 .000
    Denis Phipps, CF2000000 .000
Brandon Phillips, 2B3110010 .333
    Jason Donald, 2B2010000 .500
Joey Votto, 1B3121000 .667
    Neftali Soto, 1B2000001 .000
Ryan Ludwick, LF10101001.000
    Chris Heisey, LF-RF3110010 .333
Jay Bruce, RF2000002 .000
    Xavier Paul, RF-LF3110000 .333
Todd Frazier, 3B2101000 .000
    Jack Hannahan, 3B2011000 .500
Zack Cozart, SS2110000 .500
    Cesar Izturis, SS2111001 .500
Ryan Hanigan, C2012000 .500
    Devin Mesoraco, C11120001.000
   a- Corky Miller, PH-C1000011 .000
Miguel Olivo, DH2111001 .500
   b- Emmanuel Burriss, PH-DH2000000 .000
a-struck out for Mesoraco in the 7th
b-grounded out for Olivo in the 5th
2B - Zack Cozart (1, Soto), Ryan Hanigan (1, Nieve)
HR - Devin Mesoraco (1, Martinez), Miguel Olivo (1, Martinez)
RBI - Joey Votto (1), Todd Frazier (1), Jack Hannahan (1), Cesar Izturis (1), Ryan Hanigan 2 (2), Devin Mesoraco 2 (2), Miguel Olivo (1)
2-OUT RBI - Ryan Hanigan 2 (2)
Team LOB - 4
DP - Soto-Izturis-Villarreal
Cincinnati Reds
Tony Cingrani 1333110 27.00
Curtis Partch (BS,1) 1.2544111 21.60
Clay Hensley 2.1100010 0.00
Pedro Villarreal (H,1) 2211101 4.50
Carlos Contreras (H,1; L,0-1) 1.1233320 20.25
Drew Hayes (BS,1)0100000 0.00
WP - Carlos Contreras 2 (2)
Pitches-Strikes - Tony Cingrani 12-7, Curtis Partch 19-12, Clay Hensley 10-10, Pedro Villarreal 11-7, Carlos Contreras 23-10, Drew Hayes 1-1
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Curtis Partch 2-2, Clay Hensley 3-3, Pedro Villarreal 1-4, Carlos Contreras 1-1
Batters Faced - Tony Cingrani 6, Curtis Partch 11, Clay Hensley 8, Pedro Villarreal 8, Carlos Contreras 9, Drew Hayes 1
Cleveland Indians
Michael Bourn, CF1000100 .000
    Ezequiel Carrera, CF1000100 .000
    Cedric Hunter, CF1000002 .000
Asdrubal Cabrera, SS1101100 .000
    Juan Diaz, SS2010001 .500
    Luis Hernandez, SS1000002 .000
Jason Kipnis, 2B2000023 .000
    Cord Phelps, 2B1000001 .000
    Ryan Raburn, 2B12111001.000
Nick Swisher, 1B2111000 .500
    Chris McGuiness, 1B1000011 .000
    Jesus Aguilar, 1B1100100 .000
Michael Brantley, LF22210001.000
    Ben Francisco, LF1000000 .000
    Tim Fedroff, LF2110000 .500
Carlos Santana, C21220001.000
    Yan Gomes, C1000000 .000
    Omir Santos, C2000013 .000
Mark Reynolds, DH2110001 .500
   a- Jason Giambi, PH-DH1000000 .000
   b- Mike McDade, PH-DH2013010 .500
Lonnie Chisenhall, 3B2112001 .500
    Mike Aviles, 3B1000000 .000
    Nate Spears, 3B10100001.000
Drew Stubbs, RF2010000 .500
    Jeremy Hermida, RF10100001.000
    Matt Carson, RF0000100 .000
a-popped out for Reynolds in the 5th
b-struck out for Giambi in the 8th
2B - Juan Diaz (1, Hensley), Michael Brantley 2 (2, Cingrani, Partch), Mike McDade (1, Hayes), Nate Spears (1, Contreras)
HR - Ryan Raburn (1, Villarreal), Lonnie Chisenhall (1, Partch)
RBI - Asdrubal Cabrera (1), Ryan Raburn (1), Nick Swisher (1), Michael Brantley (1), Carlos Santana 2 (2), Mike McDade 3 (3), Lonnie Chisenhall 2 (2)
2-OUT RBI - Nick Swisher (1), Michael Brantley (1), Carlos Santana (1), Lonnie Chisenhall 2 (2)
SB - Asdrubal Cabrera (1, 2nd base off Cingrani/Hanigan)
PK - Carlos Santana (1, Cingrani)
Team LOB - 7
DP - Phelps-Diaz-McGuiness
PB - Carlos Santana (1)
Cleveland Indians
Giovanni Soto 0.2355200 67.50
Fernando Nieve 1.1300010 0.00
Vinnie Pestano 1000000 0.00
Joe Martinez (BS,1) 2555002 22.50
Rich Hill 1100010 0.00
Matt Langwell 2100010 0.00
Frank Herrmann (W,1-0) 1000000 0.00
Pitches-Strikes - Giovanni Soto 13-5, Fernando Nieve 9-9, Vinnie Pestano 3-3, Joe Martinez 13-13, Rich Hill 5-5, Matt Langwell 9-9, Frank Herrmann 3-3
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Giovanni Soto 2-0, Joe Martinez 5-1, Rich Hill 1-0, Matt Langwell 3-2, Frank Herrmann 2-1
Batters Faced - Giovanni Soto 7, Fernando Nieve 7, Vinnie Pestano 3, Joe Martinez 11, Rich Hill 3, Matt Langwell 7, Frank Herrmann 3
Game Information
Attendance - 3188
Game Time - 3:24
Temperature - 60
Umpires - Home - Shaun Lampe, First Base - Dale Scott, Second Base - UMP Nonindividual, Third Base - Jim Wolf