San Francisco at Atlanta

W: C. Kimbrel (2-1) L: S. Romo (3-3)
HR: SF - None   ATL - B. Upton (7),B. Upton (8)

Braves rally for two in bottom of ninth to defeat Giants wire reports

ATLANTA -- Justin Upton has seen a lot of Sergio Romo and knew what pitches to look for -- and what pitch to take.

Freddie Freeman didn't have that advantage, so he said he was just looking for anything to hit.

The strategies worked for each of the Braves' hitters in a ninth-inning comeback against the Giants' closer.

Upton drew a bases-loaded walk from Romo to force in the tying run and Freeman followed with a line-drive single off the closer to cap a two-run rally in the ninth that lifted Atlanta to a 6-5 win over San Francisco on Saturday.

"It's just nice to be able to come back," Freeman said. "We battled and to come back and get a win makes it nice."

B.J. Upton hit two homers off Chad Gaudin, but the Braves trailed 5-4 entering the ninth.

Romo (3-3) walked pinch-hitter Evan Gattis, who was replaced by pinch-runner Reed Johnson, with one out. Andrelton Simmons followed with a grounder that skipped past third baseman Joaquin Arias for an error, putting runners on first and second.

Jason Heyward followed with a liner that fell in front of left fielder Andres Torres, loading the bases.

Justin Upton, who came to Atlanta in an offseason trade from Arizona, where the Giants were a division rival, took a close 3-2 pitch for a ball to force in the tying run. The pitch, which had Upton backing away, was close to the inside part of the plate. Romo took a few steps toward the plate to express his disagreement.

"It was a close pitch but I obviously think it's a ball," Upton said. "Pitchers want that pitch. It went my way."

Added Upton: "I've seen him a few times so I know what to look for."

Asked about the 3-2 pitch, Romo said "It really doesn't matter what I think. The outcome of the game is already settled."

Romo said he didn't let the walk affect his concentration against Freeman.

"I was fine," he said. "I had to focus. We were still in the game. Although they tied the game we still had an opportunity to keep playing. You got to dig down deep right there and stay focused."

Romo threw Freeman two sliders -- one ball and one strike -- before trying to sneak a fastball past the big first baseman. The left-handed hitting Freeman turned on the pitch, lining the game-winning single to right field.

"I just put my foot down and swung when I saw the ball," Freeman said. "I don't look for anything. I just put my foot down and swing and hope for the best."

Romo took his third blown save in 19 opportunities.

Braves closer Craig Kimbrel (2-1) struck out Hunter Pence to end the ninth with runners on first and second. Pence drove in two runs.

Gaudin gave up four runs on eight hits in five-plus innings.

Pence had a run-scoring single in the Giants' three-run third inning and a sacrifice fly in a two-run fifth. The Giants had won three straight.

Braves starter Mike Minor gave up five runs, four earned, on seven hits and a walk in six innings.

San Francisco relievers Jean Machi, Javier Lopez and Jeremy Affeldt combined for three scoreless innings before Romo gave up two runs, one earned, on two hits and two walks.

B.J. Upton's long second-inning homer landed about halfway up the lower section of the left-field seats.

Upton's two-run homer to center field in the sixth drove in Brian McCann, who doubled. The homer cut San Francisco's lead to 5-4 and knocked Gaudin out of the game.

Simmons committed two errors after beginning the day with only four miscues for the season. Simmons' fielding error on Tony Abreu's grounder led to an unearned run in the fifth. Buster Posey followed with a run-scoring double that drove in Torres. Abreu scored on Pence's fly ball to right field.

Simmons made a wild throw after fielding an infield single by Juan Perez to open the sixth, but Minor pitched out of the jam.

The Giants took the lead in the third inning with three runs on four hits, including back-to-back RBI doubles by Torres and Abreu, who had three hits. Pence added a run-scoring single.


  • The Braves will wait until after Sunday night's game to name a second pitcher to join Paul Maholm as the starters in Tuesday's doubleheader against the Mets. One possibility is rookie LHP Alex Wood, who was working as a starter for Double-A Mississippi before he was called up on May 30 to pitch out of the Braves' bullpen.
  • RHP Brandon Beachy, recovering from 2012 elbow ligament-replacement surgery, had been on target to make his 2013 debut on Tuesday before having tenderness in the elbow. Beachy had a MRI on Saturday and said the test showed he has only inflammation and no structural damage. "I'm just going to get some rest and it will clear up," Beachy said. "I'm not worried about it at all."
  • The series ends Sunday night when Braves RHP Julio Teheran faces Giants RHP Tim Lincecum.
Copyright 2017 by STATS LLC. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Andrelton Simmons jogs home with the winning run as the Braves rally to win in the ninth. (USATSI)
Andrelton Simmons jogs home with the winning run as the Braves rally to win in the ninth. (USATSI)

Players of the Game

B. Upton
AB 4
R 3
H 2
HR 2
San Francisco

T. Abreu
AB 5
R 2
H 3
HR 0

Related Video

February 17, 2017
NL West Preview: San Francisco Giants (2:03)
San Francisco Giants
Andres Torres, LF5221001 .266
Tony Abreu, 2B5231010 .368
Buster Posey, 1B3011201 .313
    Sergio Romo, P0000000 .000
Hunter Pence, RF4012013 .298
Joaquin Arias, 3B4010013 .284
Juan Perez, CF4010031 .455
    Jeremy Affeldt, P0000000 .000
    Brandon Belt, 1B0000000 .246
Brandon Crawford, SS4110022 .293
Guillermo Quiroz, C4000023 .154
Chad Gaudin, P2000001 .000
    Jean Machi, P0000000 .000
    Javier Lopez, P0000000 .000
    Gregor Blanco, CF1010000 .281
2B - Andres Torres (12, Minor), Tony Abreu 2 (4, Minor, Kimbrel), Buster Posey (20, Minor)
SF - Hunter Pence (2)
SH - Chad Gaudin (1)
RBI - Andres Torres (15), Tony Abreu (2), Buster Posey (41), Hunter Pence 2 (38)
2-OUT RBI - Andres Torres (5), Tony Abreu (1), Hunter Pence (19)
CS - Gregor Blanco (3, 2nd base by Kimbrel/McCann)
Team LOB - 8
DP - Arias-Abreu-Posey
E - Joaquin Arias (2, Misplayed grounder)
San Francisco Giants
Chad Gaudin 5844102 2.83
Jean Machi (H,4) 1.2100110 2.01
Javier Lopez (H,3) 0.2000010 1.62
Jeremy Affeldt (H,10) 0.2000000 2.31
Sergio Romo (BS,3; L,3-3) 0.1221210 2.84
WP - Chad Gaudin 2 (3)
Pitches-Strikes - Chad Gaudin 86-49, Jean Machi 20-10, Javier Lopez 11-6, Jeremy Affeldt 5-3, Sergio Romo 24-14
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Chad Gaudin 2-13, Jean Machi 2-1, Javier Lopez 1-0, Jeremy Affeldt 1-1, Sergio Romo 1-0
Batters Faced - Chad Gaudin 24, Jean Machi 6, Javier Lopez 2, Jeremy Affeldt 2, Sergio Romo 6
Atlanta Braves
Andrelton Simmons, SS5100001 .248
Jason Heyward, RF4020100 .217
Justin Upton, LF4011102 .250
Freddie Freeman, 1B5011003 .312
Brian McCann, C4120010 .255
B.J. Upton, CF4323001 .166
Dan Uggla, 2B3000101 .188
Chris Johnson, 3B3021011 .324
   a- Ramiro Pena, PH1000010 .280
Mike Minor, P2000002 .107
   b- Jordan Schafer, PH1010000 .302
    Anthony Varvaro, P0000000 .000
    Luis Avilan, P0000000 .000
    Craig Kimbrel, P0000000 .000
   c- Evan Gattis, PH0000100 .256
    Reed Johnson, PR0100000 .254
a-struck out for Johnson in the 9th
b-singled for Minor in the 6th
c-walked for Kimbrel in the 9th
2B - Brian McCann (2, Gaudin)
HR - B.J. Upton 2 (8, Gaudin, Gaudin)
RBI - Justin Upton (32), Freddie Freeman (45), B.J. Upton 3 (15), Chris Johnson (17)
2-OUT RBI - Chris Johnson (9)
SB - B.J. Upton (5, 2nd base off Gaudin/Quiroz)
Team LOB - 9
E - Andrelton Simmons 2 (6, Misplayed grounder)
Atlanta Braves
Mike Minor 6754170 2.68
Anthony Varvaro 1100000 2.29
Luis Avilan 1100020 2.05
Craig Kimbrel (W,2-1) 1200110 1.78
IBB - Posey by Mike Minor
WP - Mike Minor (2)
Pitches-Strikes - Mike Minor 92-64, Anthony Varvaro 20-14, Luis Avilan 11-9, Craig Kimbrel 18-9
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Mike Minor 5-7, Anthony Varvaro 3-0
Batters Faced - Mike Minor 27, Anthony Varvaro 4, Luis Avilan 4, Craig Kimbrel 5
Game Information
Attendance - 47178
Game Time - 3:10
Temperature - 84
Umpires - Home - Jerry Meals, First Base - Paul Emmel, Second Base - Bruce Dreckman, Third Base - Gary Darling