• My Scores
  • NFL Draft
  • MLB
  • NBA
  • NHL
  • Golf
  • Tennis

Cincinnati at Miami

W: J. Cueto (12-6) L: T. Koehler (7-8) S: A. Chapman (24)
HR: CIN - None   MIA - G. Stanton (25)

Reds beat Marlins 3-1 with controversial replay

Associated Press

MIAMI (AP) The Miami Marlins were heated after Thursday night's game when a call from Major League Baseball's new instant replay system and the rule preventing catchers from blocking the plate did not go their way.

The Cincinnati Reds thought MLB got it just right.

A long delay in the eighth inning resulted in what the Marlins thought was the third out turning into the tying run.

Zack Cozart was initially ruled out by home plate umpire Mike Winters on the play at the plate. The review extended the inning and Ryan Ludwick delivered a two-run single to help give the Reds a 3-1 victory.

''The fact of that matter is that everyone around baseball should be embarrassed by a call like that,'' Marlins president David Samson said during an expletive-laced postgame tirade.

With the Marlins leading 1-0 in the top of the eighth, the Reds loaded the bases with one out. Bryan Morris got Todd Frazier to fly out to right fielder Giancarlo Stanton whose throw to the plate easily beat Cozart for what appeared to be the final out of the inning when catcher Jeff Mathis tagged out Cozart, who trotted in without a slide.

However, after a 6-minute, 10-second instant replay review, the call was overturned because Mathis was ruled to be blocking the plate and Cozart was called safe, tying the game 1-1.

Marlins manager Mike Redmond was immediately ejected after throwing his hat to the ground and arguing with the umpires. Redmond kicked his hat on his way back to the dugout for good measure.

''As a former catcher in this league for 13 seasons, as a grinder, as a guy who loves this game and respects this game so much, this game has been a part of my life forever, but to lose a ballgame tonight on that play is a joke, it's an absolute joke,'' Redmond said. ''I don't think anybody who plays this game should feel good about winning that game and I would say that if it had been reversed. That guy was out by 15 feet.''

Cozart saw it differently.

''I thought it was pretty obvious from the replay that they made the right call,'' he said.

Reds manager Bryan Price agreed.

''Cozart was out by a fairly reasonable margin, but the catcher, from the inception of that ball going off the bat, had taken away the entire plate with his feet,'' Price said. ''His body was in the middle of the plate.''

During the delay, Mathis, a 10-year veteran, was confident that he did everything right in accordance of the rules.

''I'm just disgusted,'' Mathis said. ''That's a tough way to lose a game. ... For it to be decided like that, it's just disgusting.''

MLB issued a statement about the play after the game:

''We have begun to examine the Crew Chief Review in tonight's Reds-Marlins game, which resulted in a violation of Rule 7.13, the call being overturned and a run scoring on the play,'' the statement said. ''We plan to discuss this situation further with the appropriate parties tomorrow, and we will communicate with the clubs after our discussion about this play.''

Reds starter Johnny Cueto (12-6) struck out nine and allowed one run in seven innings and Aroldis Chapman pitched the ninth for his 24th save.

Stanton hit his 25th home run and Tom Koehler (7-8) took the loss allowing two unearned runs in seven innings.


Chapman had to be tended to by trainers with two outs in the ninth when he had some discomfort in his right leg. He remained in the game and threw a 101 mph pitch to strike out Marcell Ozuna to end the game.

''I had a little discomfort in the leg,'' Chapman said. ''It was an awkward step I took when I made the pitch.''

Reds reliever Manny Parra (stiff back) has not pitched since July 20. ''He is improving,'' Price said. ''He played catch today. It's as day-to-day as it comes. It always seems like it's a day away from him actually being a piece of what we're doing.''


The Reds' Mat Latos (2-3, 3.31) will start Friday's game against the Marlins' Jacob Turner (4-6, 5.69). Latos is 0-3 with a 5.26 ERA in seven starts against the Marlins. Turner will be making his first start at Marlins Park since May 31 against Atlanta.


The Marlins completed a six-player trade with the Houston Astros to acquire 24-year-old right-handed starter Jarred Cosart, who will be in Miami on Friday. There has not been a decision when Cosart will join the rotation.

The Reds did not make any deals at the non-waiver deadline.

''We were involved in a lot of different negotiations, but in the end we were looking mainly for offense and there really wasn't the offensive pieces out there,'' Reds general manager Walt Jocketty said. ''In fact, none of the guys that we had talked about were moved. I think the asking prices were beyond what we felt comfortable with.''

Copyright 2016 by STATS LLC. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC is strictly prohibited.
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre
Players of the Game

G. Stanton
AB 4
R 1
H 1
HR 1

R. Ludwick
AB 4
R 0
H 1
HR 0

Related Video

April 27, 2016
Fantasy Update: Brandon Finnegan (4/27) (0:54)
April 27, 2016
Reds at Mets review
April 25, 2016
Fantasy Update: Adam Duvall (4/25)
April 12, 2016
Reds youngsters stepping up
Cincinnati Reds
Billy Hamilton, CF3100011.270.300.404
Kris Negron, 2B4010013.261.292.522
Todd Frazier, 3B3001001.277.337.468
Ryan Ludwick, LF4012010.261.325.391
   Jonathan Broxton, P0000000.000.000.000
   Aroldis Chapman, P0000000.000.000.000
Brayan Pena, C-1B4020001.264.294.396
Chris Heisey, RF4000002.220.271.356
Jack Hannahan, 1B3000012.000.000.000
   Skip Schumaker, LF1000000.235.285.313
Zack Cozart, SS4110001.224.273.289
Johnny Cueto, P2010000.140.157.140
   a-Devin Mesoraco, PH-C2110001.296.368.588
a-singled for Cueto in the 8th
2B - Brayan Pena (14, Koehler)
SF - Todd Frazier (3)
SH - Billy Hamilton (7)
RBI - Todd Frazier (56), Ryan Ludwick 2 (29)
2-OUT RBI - Ryan Ludwick 2 (16)
SB - Billy Hamilton (42, 2nd base off Morris/Mathis)
Team LOB - 6
Outfield Assists - Billy Hamilton 1
DP - Cozart-Negron-B. Pena
PB - Brayan Pena (1)
Cincinnati Reds
Johnny Cueto (W,12-6) 7411191 2.05
Jonathan Broxton (H,17) 1100120 0.95
Aroldis Chapman (S,24) 1000110 2.10
Pitches-Strikes - Johnny Cueto 93-63, Jonathan Broxton 24-13, Aroldis Chapman 16-8
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Johnny Cueto 5-6, Aroldis Chapman 1-0
Batters Faced - Johnny Cueto 25, Jonathan Broxton 5, Aroldis Chapman 3
Miami Marlins
Christian Yelich, LF4010020.273.353.412
Jordany Valdespin, 2B3000110.243.282.514
Giancarlo Stanton, RF4111022.293.393.546
Casey McGehee, 3B3010110.304.371.377
Garrett Jones, 1B3010011.256.318.423
   a-Jeff Baker, PH1000001.243.291.354
Marcell Ozuna, CF3010120.269.318.451
Adeiny Hechavarria, SS3000012.274.302.341
Jeff Mathis, C3000001.192.271.267
Tom Koehler, P2000011.059.086.059
   Mike Dunn, P0000000.000.000.000
   Bryan Morris, P0000000.000.000.000
   b-Donovan Solano, PH1000010.261.313.321
   Sam Dyson, P0000000.000.000.000
a-grounded into a double play for G. Jones in the 9th
b-struck out for Morris in the 8th
2B - Casey McGehee (22, Cueto), Marcell Ozuna (16, Cueto)
HR - Giancarlo Stanton (25, Cueto)
RBI - Giancarlo Stanton (73)
2-OUT RBI - Giancarlo Stanton (26)
Team LOB - 5
E - Mike Dunn (1, Misplayed grounder), Jordany Valdespin (1, Dropped fly)
Miami Marlins
Tom Koehler (L,7-8) 7520030 3.70
Mike Dunn 0010000 3.86
Bryan Morris (BS,6) 1100010 1.87
Sam Dyson 1100000 1.98
Pitches-Strikes - Tom Koehler 83-54, Mike Dunn 1-1, Bryan Morris 12-9, Sam Dyson 11-9
Ground Balls-Fly Balls - Tom Koehler 7-12, Mike Dunn 1-0, Sam Dyson 2-1
Batters Faced - Tom Koehler 27, Mike Dunn 1, Bryan Morris 4, Sam Dyson 4
Game Information
Attendance - 18056
Game Time - 2:43
Temperature - 73
Umpires - Home - Mike Winters, First Base - Andy Fletcher, Second Base - Tom Woodring, Third Base - Mark Wegner