Grading the Weekend Series: Tribe on top

When you get an A, it causes you to jump in weird ways. Just look at Nick Swisher.
When you get an A, it causes you to jump in weird ways. Just look at Nick Swisher. (USATSI)

More MLB: Scoreboard | Standings | Probable Pitchers | Sortable Stats | Odds

It's time, once again, to hand out some letter grades. For the sake of brevity and avoiding overkill over the course of the season, we just give one team per actual letter grade, so only five teams get graded while 25 do not.

First things first, congrats and an honorary A to each team that swept its respective series. So, nice work and a sticker to the Chicago Cubs , Kansas City Royals (who have decided not to be trade deadline sellers!), Braves and Detroit Tigers . We'll go with the most impressive series win, relative to how good the teams playing each other this weekend were as the tiebreaker, and that lands us in Cleveland -- barely over the first-place Braves sweeping the first-place Cardinals.

TeamGradeAnalysis
A The Texas Rangers are really struggling right now, but they're still a team with quality talent and entered the series with a better record than the Cleveland Indians . That's not the case now, though, as the Indians swept the Rangers in three games by an overall mark of 18-8. Ubaldo Jimenez was brilliant Sunday and is now 8-3 with a 3.12 ERA since a dreadful start. Also, the Indians pitching staff leads the majors in shutouts (team version).
B- The Colorado Rockies are hanging around in contention -- six games back of the uber-hot Los Angeles Dodgers -- and won a series. Still, they had to scratch and claw to take two of three from the last-place Milwaukee Brewers (now without Ryan Braun), so we have to downgrade them a bit. It's obviously better than average (which would be a C), but they need better to hang with the Dodgers.
C- In losing two of three, we can't get them even a stand-alone C. But they're up to a C-minus due to some circumstances. Alfonso Soriano is back in Yankee pinstripes and came through with a four-hit game -- including a homer and a walkoff single Sunday. Derek Jeter is back in the lineup and went 2-for-4 with a homer. The New York Yankees overcame an awful start by Phil Hughes to topple the Tampa Bay Rays , who have been arguably the best team in baseball lately. Salvaging that victory in the manner they did gains them mention here.
D Losing a series to the Miami Marlins isn't what it was in the first two months of the season. They have been pretty good since the end of May overall. On the flip-side, they recently lost nine of 12 games and endured an embarrassing offensive drought. A team with aspirations like the Pittsburgh Pirates -- which are far beyond a winning season for the first time since Barry Bonds was skinny -- needs to win series over the Fish. It's pretty simple. It wasn't a disaster, as they won Saturday and, again, the Marlins aren't the embarrassment they were in mid-May, which is what keeps the Bucs from an F. Also, the good news for the Pirates is they're still only 1.5 games out and have a huge five-game series with the Cardinals at home this week.
F A five-game losing streak turned into eight, as the Philadelphia Phillies were swept by the Tigers and outscored 24-5. This pretty much ends any illusions of contending this season, I'd guess. It wasn't just the scoreboard. There was an embarrassing inning Sunday in which the Phillies gave up eight unearned runs on only two hits -- one a bunt single. They did commit three errors and walk two runs in during the frame, though. And then after the game came more comments from Jonathan Papelbon about how he didn't sign up for this and the franchise needs a new direction. What an utter debacle of a weekend.
CBS Sports Writer

Matt Snyder has been a baseball writer with CBS Sports since 2011. A member of the BBWAA, he's now covered the last five World Series beginning with the epic 2011 Fall Classic. The former Indiana University... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
CBS Sports Shop
MLB All-Star Gear
Our Latest Stories