MLB Top 10s: Cabrera, Verlander easy picks for AL Central's best

by Dayn Perry | Baseball Writer
  •  

In the Eye On Baseball Top 10s, here's what we do: rank players according to criteria. Those criteria change depending upon week and whim, but the Top 10s will always be informed by some angle or another. (Note that the absence of an angle is itself an angle!)

And that brings us to this week's guiding query: Who are the best position players and pitchers in the American League Central?

In recent weeks, we've been devoting ourselves to rank provincialism by ordering hitters and pitchers from each of baseball's six divisions. So the primary criterion for this week is that each name-checked player must play for the Tigers, Royals, Indians, Twins or White Sox. Beyond that, each player should be good at baseball and stuff.

As for really deciding who merits inclusion, we're focusing on players who are performing at least solidly in 2013 and have the track record and or pedigree to suggest that their 2013 numbers are sustainable or even headed upward. That is, these are good players playing well or soon to play well. What's unfolded in 2013 matters, but so does body of work and established expectations. If a player isn't on here despite strong numbers in the current season, then you should assume that all-powerful I have determined his performance to be somewhat fluke-ish. It is so because I said it is so. Such are the privileges of boundless authority.

And now let us recite baseball names for purposes of SEO and making you angry. As always, feel free to brandish your incorrect opinions and make idle threats in the comments section.

Batters
1. Miguel Cabrera, 3B - Detroit Tigers
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 1
Justin Verlander He's the reigning AL MVP and triple-crown winner, he's hitting .358/.451/.638, and he's on pace for 45 homers and 169 RBI. Yes, Miguel Cabrera tops this list without debate or hesitation.
Key Stats: 268 AB, 19 HR, .358 AVG, 71 RBI, 55 R, 2 SB
2. Joe Mauer, C - Minnesota Twins
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 24
Chris Sale The three-time batting champion and only AL catcher ever to win a batting title is at it again. Maybe it's the Twins' struggles and geographic location, but is Joe Mauer the most underrated player in baseball right now? The question can plausibly be asked.
Key Stats: 249 AB, 6 HR, .321 AVG, 21 RBI, 38 R, 0 SB
3. Prince Fielder, 1B - Detroit Tigers
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 2
Max Scherzer If he picks up the pace substantially, then he'll notch his 300th career homer in this, his age-29 season. Even if he doesn't, he's batting a nifty .292/.391/.500.
Key Stats: 260 AB, 12 HR, .292 AVG, 54 RBI, 35 R, 0 SB
4. Salvador Perez, C - Kansas City Royals
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 10
James Shields Perez stands as one of the best young catchers in the game today. The 23-year-old is a career .311/.337/.458 hitter across his first 169 major-league games. Perez also grades out as a plus defensive catcher, and he's come back successfully from knee surgery performed in early 2012. From his arm to his bat to his game-calling skills to his attitude, Perez earns praise for every facet of his game. He's got the stuff of a franchise player.
Key Stats: 207 AB, 3 HR, .304 AVG, 26 RBI, 22 R, 0 SB
5. Jason Kipnis, 2B - Cleveland Indians
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 5
Doug Fister Kipnis is an up-the-middle defender with a career OPS+ of 112. As well, 2013 is shaping up to be his best season, as he's batting .270/.342/.465 with nine homers and 14 doubles. He's also on pace to steal 35 bases.
Key Stats: 234 AB, 9 HR, .265 AVG, 34 RBI, 34 R, 15 SB
6. Alex Gordon, LF - Kansas City Royals
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 18
Anibal Sanchez The two-time Gold Glove winner is indeed one of the best defensive corner outfielders in all of baseball. Gordon's also a nifty hitter, as he's put up OPS+'s of 140, 125 and 116 in 2011, 2012 and 2013.
Key Stats: 273 AB, 6 HR, .297 AVG, 36 RBI, 40 R, 2 SB
7. Carlos Santana, C - Cleveland Indians
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 7
Jake Peavy The man can hit. Criticize his defensive skills or his ability to squat behind the plate on a regular basis if you wish, but Santana can rake. He gets on base and hits for power by catcher standards, and that's why Santana is a valuable commodity.
Key Stats: 226 AB, 10 HR, .283 AVG, 31 RBI, 35 R, 1 SB
8. Nick Swisher, 1B - Cleveland Indians
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 64
Glen Perkins Swisher's hurt and slumping at the moment, but he remains the owner of a 118 career OPS+ and 216 homers. He's had "old player" skills for some time (i.e., low contact rate offset by walks and extra-base hits), but the career numbers are impressive.
Key Stats: 224 AB, 7 HR, .237 AVG, 24 RBI, 33 R, 0 SB
9. Alex Rios, RF - Chicago White Sox
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 19
Justin Masterson Mechanical adjustments made prior to the 2012 season have paid off for Rios, who's batted .298/.337/.504 with 36 homers and 51 doubles over that span.
Key Stats: 260 AB, 11 HR, .288 AVG, 33 RBI, 36 R, 11 SB
10. Jhonny Peralta, SS - Detroit Tigers
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 24
Jeremy Guthrie The stalwart shortstop is enjoying his finest season at the plate. His career OPS+ of 102 is quite strong by the standards of the position, and that's why he's on here.
Key Stats: 241 AB, 6 HR, .332 AVG, 30 RBI, 32 R, 2 SB
Pitchers
1. Justin Verlander, SP - Detroit Tigers
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 2
Justin Verlander The top spot is Verlander's by default. Maybe the workloads of his early 20s are catching up to him, but the body of work speaks for itself: one MVP, one Cy Young, four top-five Cy Young finishes, 128 ERA+.
Key Stats: 87.0 IP, 8-4 W-L, 0 SV, 3.41 ERA, 101 Ks, 28 BB
2. Chris Sale, SP - Chicago White Sox
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 13
Chris Sale You wonder how long the slightly built Sale can hold up, given his high-stress delivery, but, wow, what a start to his career. After 121 games, 41 of which have been starts, Sale boasts a 2.78 ERA and a 155 ERA+. He's still just 24 years of age.
Key Stats: 85.1 IP, 5-5 W-L, 0 SV, 2.43 ERA, 86 Ks, 19 BB
3. Max Scherzer, SP - Detroit Tigers
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 11
Max Scherzer These days, only Yu Darvish is capable of missing bats like Scherzer. The difference is that this season, Scherzer is flashing the best command of his career.
Key Stats: 96.1 IP, 10-0 W-L, 0 SV, 3.08 ERA, 116 Ks, 24 BB
4. James Shields, SP - Kansas City Royals
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 14
James Shields Ignore the 2-6 record: Shields is having one of the best seasons of his career. Right now, he boasts a sub-3.00 ERA, and he's notched 12 quality starts in 14 chances. Shields is also headed for his seventh-straight season of at least 200 innings pitched and his seventh-straight season of a K/BB ratio of better than 3.00.
Key Stats: 106.0 IP, 2-6 W-L, 0 SV, 2.72 ERA, 95 Ks, 30 BB
5. Doug Fister, SP - Detroit Tigers
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 37
Doug Fister Yes, another Detroit starter. Dig Fister's numbers since being traded from the Mariners to the Tigers at the 2011 non-waiver trade deadline: 24-15, 3.02 ERA, 4.82 K/BB ratio, 139 ERA+. When healthy, he's pitched like an ace in Motown and is doing so again in 2013.
Key Stats: 92.2 IP, 6-4 W-L, 0 SV, 3.21 ERA, 76 Ks, 14 BB
6. Anibal Sanchez, SP - Detroit Tigers
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 20
Anibal Sanchez Yes, another Detroit starter. Sanchez is presently on the DL with shoulder problems, but what a year he's having: 2.76 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, 4.39 K/BB ratio. Thus far, he's very much living up to that pricey contract.
Key Stats: 81.2 IP, 6-5 W-L, 0 SV, 2.76 ERA, 101 Ks, 23 BB
7. Jake Peavy, SP - Chicago White Sox
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 25
Jake Peavy Is it me, or does it seem like Peavy should be, oh, 38 or 39 years of age? Maybe it's the warhorse mentality, or maybe it's all those injuries. Whatever the reasons, Peavy (who's actually just 32) is coming off a highly effective 2012 campaign. Can he get healthy and pick up where he left off? That remains to be seen.
Key Stats: 67.0 IP, 6-4 W-L, 0 SV, 4.3 ERA, 66 Ks, 15 BB
8. Glen Perkins, RP - Minnesota Twins
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 6
Glen Perkins The best closer in the division? Yep. Over the past three seasons, Perkins's worst ERA has been 2.56, thanks in large part to his refinement of the two-seam fastball. It takes a little extra for a lefty to win a spot as closer, and Perkins has that something extra.
Key Stats: 25.2 IP, 1-0 W-L, 16 SV, 2.45 ERA, 36 Ks, 6 BB
9. Justin Masterson, SP - Cleveland Indians
Fantasy Ranking by Position: 42
Justin Masterson The maddeningly inconsistent Masterson appears to be on the upswing again, as he's pitched to a 3.52 ERA, 1.18 WHIP and 2.49 K/BB ratio thus far in 2013. Increased reliance on his slider may have something to do with his success.
Key Stats: 102.1 IP, 8-5 W-L, 0 SV, 3.52 ERA, 102 Ks, 41 BB
10. Jeremy Guthrie, SP - Kansas City Royals
Jeremy Guthrie It's been 183 innings since Guthrie became a Royal, and over that span he's posted an ERA of 3.44. Can he continue being effective in 2013 despite some fairly grim underlying numbers?
Key Stats: 92.0 IP, 7-4 W-L, 0 SV, 3.72 ERA, 44 Ks, 31 BB
  •  
 

CBSSports Facebook Twitter
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
 
 
 
image description
MLB matinee: Dodgers back in Bronx
The Dodgers pay their first visit since the '81 World Series in Game 1 of a doubleheader. Follow LIVE: LAD-NYY  
 

Latest