|New Marlins manager Mike Redmond might be smiling, but the fans aren't. (US Presswire)|
FROM: Tom B
I respect your opinion and writings, but in this case I do not understand all the pundits/experts who ripped the Marlins for getting rid of payroll. If I recall, the Red Sox made as big or bigger trade and got praised all over the place. And they got nothing out of the deal. They cut two of the players and let another go as free agent. At least the Fish got some prospects, as they usually do. The Red Sox were sold out for the rest of the year and trashed their team. At least the Marlins did it after the season.
They did trade Hanley Ramirez during the season and helped the Dodgers play worse afterwards. Heath Bell was a mistake from the beginning as several people said he would be. Maybe Ozzie Guillen isn't the genius everyone said he was. The White Sox did much better with a so-called unqualified manager this year. I don't blame the Marlins too much, their fans don't show up even when they win. Jeffrey Loria is an idiotic owner, but they have won two World Series in their existence, better than most teams. Being a Phillies fan, I am glad the Fish are rebuilding, but their trade wasn't bad, their signings the year before were the mistakes. At least they admitted them, unlike Boston. Thanks for you time.
The difference is simple: The Marlins just took millions of dollars from taxpayers on the promise that their payroll would increase and that they would have marquee players. Once they crossed that line, they took on a moral responsibility. To bail after one season and chop payroll to a major-league low is reprehensible. I understand they had a disappointing season. I would even give them a pass had they just traded Josh Johnson. There is a track record of disappointment with that guy. There isn't with the group they signed last year. You don't think Mark Buehrle could have been part of the solution in 2013?
Did you write an article like this when the Red Sox did the same thing, but got nothing in return? I'm not a Miami fan -- Go Rays -- but at least they got some really, really good prospects, and now have money to spend again. Obviously, their plan backfired when they couldn't land Big Al (Pujols). What they did didn't work ... now they got some really good young players, freed up space to try the free agent market again, but be smarter about it this time. I guess my point is this on closing, what the Red Sox did was much worse than what Marlins did.
Clearly, the few remaining defenders of Loria/Samson have their talking points in order. I heard from several people saying that what the Red Sox did was worse than what the Marlins did. Truth: It wasn't. The Red Sox had been around the block several times with Josh Beckett. They won a World Series with him. It wasn't working. At least Adrian Gonzalez was well into Year Two when they dealt him. It clearly was a bad mix of players. With the Marlins, one season is not enough evidence that you need to rip the entire thing up. Especially with the premature shots fired in July by trading Hanley Ramirez and Anibal Sanchez. They pulled the plug on the season then.
I know he gutted the Expos. But Montreal, too? If he gutted the city, please, do tell. I'm all ears.
FROM: Harry O
And you didn't even discuss what these guys did to the Expos! Go back and look at their record ... they pushed that franchise over the cliff.
Now hold on just one minute, Harry. That's not quite correct. First, they tied a one-ton cement block to the franchise's legs. Then they stuffed it into a body bag. Then they knocked it unconscious with a baseball bat. THEN they pushed it over the cliff!
FROM: Phil B
If Bowie Kuhn was alive today and running MLB, he would void the trade in the Best Interest of Baseball, and I would agree. Loria should not be allowed to own a franchise. He rakes in all the money and gives nothing back. He knew what he was doing last year by back-loading these contracts and not allowing no-trade clauses. He stole money, yes stole, to get his stadium built and now the taxpayers of Miami are stuck with the bill while he makes tons of money. The Mets should move their Las Vegas AAA team to Miami, they would be a better draw and more entertaining, and the Marlins should go to Vegas where being irrelevant would not matter. Now Loria can save more money, by not having to open the gates for home games and pay people to work, because both Marlins fans will not bother to show up now. Here is another idea. The Rays should move to Miami and they get the new stadium they deserve and the Marlins can go to Tampa where it will not matter!
Now this is the kind of creative thinking I like, Phil. Then, when Giancarlo Stanton clubs 50 homers in Tropicana Field, the Marlins can trade him, too.