In both categories, he ranked behind seniors Derek Carr of Fresno State and David Fales of San Jose State, who were the First and Second Team All-Mountain West selections, respectively. Smith was named to the Maxwell Trophy Watch List for 2013. He was named to the Manning Award Watch List for the second consecutive year, and was named a Manning Star of the Week three times this season.
He ended the season ranked No. 3 in the MW and No. 11 in the country in passing TDs (29 total) and No. 3 in the conference and No. 15 in the nation in points responsible for (200 total points responsible for).
Of the top 50 quarterbacks in the nation, only three boasted a higher yards per completion mark than Smith, who averaged 13.84 yards per completion. He led all UW rushers with six TDs on the ground. He started 10 games, missing two due to injury. He completed 62 percent of his passes (205-330). He threw 27 TD passes, with just six interceptions. Smith averaged 284 yards per game through the air, and tallied nearly 309 yards per game in total offense to lead all Cowboys. He was a three-time CollegeSportsMadness.com MW Player of the Week honoree, and a one-time honoree for the MAACO Bowl Las Vegas MW Player of the Week.
He was the conference offensive player of the week three times and earned Honorable Mention All-MW honors. Though just a sophomore, Smith was one of four Cowboys to be selected a team captain for the 2012 season.
That ranked him No. 2 in the Mountain West and No. 33 overall in the NCAA. Smith also ranked fourth in the MW and 61st in the nation in passing yards (201.7 per game). He ranked fourth in the conference in passing efficiency, with a 124.6 passer rating. Along the way, he set a new Mountain West Conference freshman record for total offense (3,332 yards), breaking the previous record of 2,691 yards set by TCU's Andy Dalton back in 2007. Smith ranks third on Wyoming's single-season total offense chart. He also ranks No. 3 on the Mountain West career passing list for a freshman, with 2,622 passing yards. Twice during the season, Smith was named the Mountain West Offensive Player of the Week for his performances versus San Diego State and New Mexico.
His best single-game performance was a 365-yard effort at San Diego State in a key 30-27 road victory that also won Smith the Manning Award National Player of the Week honor. He recorded five 300-yard total offense games his freshman season. He earned the Coach Paul Roach Team MVP and Offensive Back of the Year honors at the team's year-end banquet, along with a letter.
His senior season, he completed 135 of 200 passes (67.5 percent) for 2,146 yards, 26 touchdowns and only five interceptions. He also rushed for 855 yards on 114 carries and scored 22 rushing TDs. His junior season, Smith completed 91 of 146 passes (62.3 percent) for 1,555 yards, 16 TDs and only two interceptions, while rushing for 756 yards on 95 carries and scoring 12 rushing touchdowns. He also started as a sophomore, throwing for 1,260 yards, eight TDs and eight interceptions, while completing 85 of 150 passes (56.7 percent). Smith rushed the ball 93 times for 703 yards and 10 touchdowns as a sophomore. As a freshman, he completed 8 of 13 passes for 103 yards, threw two TD passes and had four rushing attempts for 10 yards.
His career numbers include: 319 of 509 passes (62.8 percent) for 5,064 yards, 52 TDs, 15 interceptions, 306 rushing attempts for 2,324 yards and 44 rushing touchdowns. Among the school records he set include: career passing yards, career rushing yards, career scoring, career touchdown passes and career rushing TDs. He played for head coach Shawn Stanley.