| Rank | Player | Pos. | Pos. Rank | School | Class | Ht. | Wt. | Proj. Round |
| 468 | Robert Marve | QB | 26 | Purdue | rSr | 6-1 | 212 | –– |
| 480 | Matt Brown | QB | 27 | Illinois State | rSr | 6-3 | 229 | –– |
| 489 | Ryan Katz | QB | 28 | San Diego State | rSr | 6-1 | 214 | –– |
| 499 | Ryan Aplin | QB | 29 | Arkansas State | rSr | 6-1 | 202 | –– |
| 515 | Tino Sunseri | QB | 30 | Pittsburgh | rSr | 6-0 | 205 | –– |
| 525 | Jake Mullin | QB | 31 | McMurry University | Sr | 6-3 | 233 | –– |
| 535 | Mike Hermann | QB | 32 | RPI | Sr | 6-6 | 257 | –– |
| 546 | Colton Chapple | QB | 33 | Harvard | Sr | 6-1 | 196 | –– |
| 550 | *Kyle Padron | QB | 34 | Eastern Washington | rJr | 6-3 | 222 | –– |
| 555 | Jake Ryan | QB | 35 | Austin Peay | Sr | 6-0 | 202 | –– |
| 569 | Casey Brockman | QB | 36 | Murray State | Sr | 6-2 | 221 | –– |
| 579 | Mitchell Gale | QB | 37 | Abilene Christian | rSr | 6-2 | 221 | –– |
| 592 | Graham Wilbert | QB | 38 | Florida Atlantic | rSr | 6-4 | 210 | –– |
| 611 | Ryan Osiecki | QB | 39 | New Haven | rSr | 6-4 | 240 | –– |
| 634 | T.J. Pryor | QB | 40 | Eastern Kentucky | rSr | 6-2 | 191 | –– |
| 663 | Nate Montana | QB | 41 | West Virginia Wesleyan | rSr | 6-4 | 221 | –– |
| 683 | Clay Belton | QB | 42 | Findlay | rSr | 6-6 | 232 | –– |
| 705 | Kyle Frazier | QB | 43 | Monmouth (NJ) | rSr | 6-2 | 217 | –– |
| 746 | Caleb TerBush | QB | 44 | Purdue | rSr | 6-5 | 238 | –– |
| 818 | B.J. Daniels | QB | 45 | South Florida | rSr | 5-11 | 222 | –– |
| 889 | Johnny McEntee | QB | 46 | Connecticut | rSr | 6-2 | 204 | –– |
| 918 | Peter Lalich | QB | 47 | California (PA) | rSr | 6-5 | 232 | –– |
| 966 | Ryan Radcliff | QB | 48 | Central Michigan | rSr | 6-3 | 221 | –– |
| 982 | Zach Maynard | QB | 49 | California | rSr | 6-2 | 182 | –– |
| 994 | Nick Elko | QB | 50 | Delaware State | rSr | 6-2 | 212 | –– |