Hall of Fame cases: The receiver trio (Marvin Harrison, Andre Reed and Tim Brown) | Charles Haley | Jerome Bettis | Eddie DeBartolo | Aeneas Williams | Kevin Greene | Tony Dungy | John Lynch | Morten Andersen | Will Shields
The day before the Super Bowl, 46 Hall of Fame voters will enter a conference room somewhere in New York City, and they won't leave until they emerge with the 2014 Pro Football Hall of Fame class. The election will take hours, because each of the finalists will be presented by a media member who extols his virtues and the reason why that particular man should be inducted in with the next class. Then, the debates will begin, and they will rage for hours. Eventually, a Hall of Fame class will be elected, and all will rejoice.
Until then, we're left to ponder the possibilities. On this page during the next few weeks, we'll debate most of those who have a chance to land a spot in Canton this year. At the end of the debate, we'll come up with our own ballot of those who we feel deserve to be enshrined (a quick FYI: I am not a Hall of Fame voter, and neither is anybody else on the current CBSSports.com roster). I can tell you right now that I'll include linebacker Derrick Brooks, defensive end Michael Strahan and offensive tackle Walter Jones on my ballot, so those three won't be among those we debate.
Until then, let's think things through with former coach Tony Dungy.
|2014 Hall of Fame Finalists|
|Jerome Bettis||Running back|
|Tim Brown||Wide receiver|
|Edward J. DeBartolo, Jr.||Owner (49ers)|
|Tony Dungy||Head coach (Bucs, Colts)|
|Kevin Greene||Linebacker/defensive end|
|Charles Haley||Defensive end/linebacker|
|Marvin Harrison||Wide receiver|
|Claude Humphrey||Defensive end|
|Andre Reed||Wide receiver|
|Michael Strahan||Defensive end|
Why he should be elected: Dungy did amazing work in Indianapolis. Sure, he had a quarterback by the name of Peyton Manning that helped Dungy's reputation, but it's hard to argue with a .759 winning percentage. Plus, Dungy's overall regular-season winning percentage is .688, which ranks ninth all time with those who have coached in at least 100 games. Other positive attributes: he was the first coach to score a win against all 32 teams, and he's only one of three NFLers who have won the Super Bowl as a player and as a head coach. And though the voters aren't necessarily supposed to weigh the sociological impact of Dungy, it's worth noting that he's been a wonderful ambassador for the game, and he was a trailblazer, becoming the first African-American to win an NFL title.
Why he shouldn't be elected: Though Dungy made the postseason 11 times (out of 13 seasons) in his coaching career and won at least 10 games in 10 different years, the lone Super Bowl victory isn't that impressive when you consider that 12 coaches who also have that accomplishment are not in the HOF -- and three (Tom Flores, George Siefert and Jimmy Johnson) have won two Super Bowls and aren't in. And even with Dungy's impact on the game from a larger standpoint, the voters really aren't supposed to consider that as part of his candidacy. If you take away his trailblazing ways, Dungy's case gets weaker.
What a Hall of Fame voter thinks: "The thing is with Dungy -- and it's the elephant in the room -- is that you're supposed to measure on-field accomplishments. It's not supposed to, but with Tony, you have to take a look at it. The first black coach to win a Super Bowl and things like that. Let's put it this way. the [Dick] LeBeau case is the perfect example. You're supposed to look at just what he did on the field [as a player] but everybody in that room remembers what LeBeau has done as a defensive coordinator. Even though you're not supposed to, you're looking at the entire body of work.
"[Bill] Parcells was, by far, the better coach, and he didn't get in on his first ballot. How could I put in Dungy on the first ballot?"
How are his chances: Dungy is well-liked, so there's a chance he could get into the Hall of Fame one day. But it probably won't happen this year. Despite his off-the-field work and his trailblazing ways, his resume simply isn't strong enough to warrant his induction at this point. Though Dungy's winning percentage is impressive, he might have retired too soon in order to make his chances a slam-dunk case. Almost certainly not on his first time on the ballot.
Coming Tuesday: The case for and against John Lynch
Follow Josh Katzowitz on Google+