• My Scores
  • NFL
  • MLB
  • NHL
  • NBA

Green Bay at Cleveland

Couch and Holcomb throw TDs, but Packers win

SportsLine.com wire reports

CLEVELAND -- Time's up for Butch Davis. So, is it Tim Couch or Kelly Holcomb?

"I'm glad I'm not the man making that decision," Browns wide receiver Quincy Morgan said.

Holcomb and Couch certainly didn't make things any easier for Cleveland's coach. The two quarterbacks, neck-and-neck in their fight to be the starter, both played well in their final auditions for Davis before the Green Bay Packers beat the Browns 38-31 in an exhibition Friday night.

Holcomb started and threw two TD passes in the first quarter before being replaced by Couch, who completed his first four passes - the last a 20-yard TD to Kevin Johnson - to give the Browns (0-2) a lead in the second quarter.

Davis said he'll spend Saturday reviewing game film, and after consulting with his coaching staff, he'll sleep on it and announce his decision Sunday.

"Both of them threw the ball very well," Davis said. "They were in total command of what Green Bay was doing."

Holcomb isn't sure who the winner will be.

"I don't know," he said. "Did you ask coach Davis? I'm sure it's pretty hard."

Green Bay's Brett Favre went 9-of-14 for 102 yards and threw one TD pass in his three series with the Packers' first-team offense, which was at full strength for the first time this preseason.

Ahman Green rushed for 55 yards and scored on a 1-yard run for the Packers (2-1), who rallied behind TD runs from Herbert Goodman and Nick Luchey in the third quarter.

Akili Smith's 13-yard TD shovel pass to Goodman in the fourth put the Packers up 38-28.

"I thought we moved the ball real, real well," Favre said. "There's still room for improvement, but considering how we played the last two weeks, we got a lot done."

Holcomb, a career backup, appeared to land the knockout blow in the Browns' too-close-to-call QB competition, by throwing TD passes on Cleveland's first two possessions.

Holcomb finished 7-of-10 for 166 yards, making him 14-of-21 for 237 yards in two preseason games. He hopes it was enough to give him the job.

"I did what I can do and after that, I can't do anything else. I have no regrets about it."

As he has done all preseason, Davis praised both his quarterbacks and remained noncommittal. But he wasn't so enthusiastic about his defense.

"I was disgusted," he said. "The tackling was about as poor as I've seen."

On the Browns' second play, Holcomb made two nice fakes before hooking up with running back William Green on an 82-yard TD screen pass to tie it 7-7.

That was mostly Green, but the next time he came out, Holcomb quickly moved the Browns down the field.

He lofted a 39-yard pass down the left sideline to Morgan and capped a 74-yard drive with a 14-yard scoring strike to Steve Heiden, giving Cleveland a 14-7 lead.

Favre responded with a 79-yard drive as Ahman Green barreled in.

Then it was Couch's turn to impress Davis. He got a lukewarm greeting by Browns fans, who booed him relentlessly last year and appear to favor Holcomb, who passed for 429 yards in a playoff loss to Pittsburgh last season.

"I was prepared for the worst," Couch said of the fan reaction, "and I thought it was a little better than expected."

Couch was up to Holcomb's challenge and directed a 55-yard drive that ended with him zipping his TD pass over the middle to Johnson, his favorite target the past four seasons.

Couch, who started the exhibition opener at Tennessee, finished 4-of-7 for 53 yards. He's 8-of-15 for 70 yards in the preseason.

Green Bay has no quarterback issues, and Favre looked sharp on the Packers' opening possession going 4-for-5 - one was dropped - and throwing a 22-yard TD pass to Donald Driver.


  • William Green bruised his neck, but Davis said it wasn't serious.
  • Packers LT Chad Clifton played in his first game since being injured when he was blindsided by Tampa Bay's Warren Sapp last season. "It all felt good," Clifton said. "It's been a long time and I had a lot of excitement tonight."
  • Browns DE Courtney Brown didn't make his 2003 debut after asking if he could have another week of practice before testing his surgically repaired left knee. Team president Carmen Policy dismissed reports the Browns were upset with the former No. 1 overall pick's decision. "Disappointed," Policy said. "Not upset."
  • Packers CB Mike McKenzie (neck stinger) and LB Na'il Diggs (bruised shoulder) were injured in the first half and didn't return. RB Najeh Davenport (strained calf) got hurt in the third.
  • QB Josh Booty (lacerated hand) and LB Chaun Thompson (knee) were the Browns' most notable injuries.

The Associated Press News Service

Copyright 2003, The Associated Press, All Rights Reserved
CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
Conversation powered by Livefyre

Related Video

October 12, 2016
Cowboys @ Packers Preview (1:23)
October 10, 2016
Eddie Lacy leaves game with ankle injury
October 7, 2016
Keys to Victory: Giants at Packers
October 7, 2016
Week 5 Best Bets: Giants at Packers
Scoring Summary
TDDonald Driver, 22 Yd pass from Brett Favre (Ryan Longwell kick is good), 11:22. Drive: 7 plays, 78 yards in 3:38.
TDWilliam Green, 82 Yd pass from Kelly Holcomb (Phil Dawson kick is good), 10:27. Drive: 2 plays, 82 yards in 0:55.
TDSteve Heiden, 14 Yd pass from Kelly Holcomb (Phil Dawson kick is good), 5:29. Drive: 9 plays, 74 yards in 4:22.
TDAhman Green, 1 Yd run (Ryan Longwell kick is good), 12:16. Drive: 14 plays, 79 yards in 8:13.
TDKevin Johnson, 20 Yd pass from Tim Couch (Phil Dawson kick is good), 2:44. Drive: 10 plays, 55 yards in 6:30.
FGRyan Longwell 33 Yd, 1:05. Drive: 8 plays, 39 yards in 1:39.
TDHerbert Goodman, 8 Yd run (Ryan Longwell kick is good), 9:21. Drive: 10 plays, 61 yards in 4:43.
TDNicolas Luchey, 1 Yd run (Ryan Longwell kick is good), 6:27. Drive: 5 plays, 17 yards in 2:38.
TDBilly Blanchard, 7 Yd pass from Nate Hybl (Phil Dawson kick is good), 1:11. Drive: 3 plays, 7 yards in 0:55.
TDHerbert Goodman, 13 Yd pass from Akili Smith (Ryan Longwell kick is good), 9:33. Drive: 11 plays, 76 yards in 6:38.
FGPhil Dawson 39 Yd, 4:01. Drive: 10 plays, 57 yards in 5:32.
Green Bay
B. Favre9/1410210
D. Pederson9/177701
A. Smith5/54510
C. Nall3/53700
H. Goodman198019
A. Green955113
N. Davenport315015
N. Luchey51517
C. Nall1202
A. Smith1-10-1
H. Goodman456117
D. Driver443122
N. Davenport440013
W. Walls536011
R. Ferguson231019
J. Walker118018
C. Jackson114014
K. Bailey21106
L. Broughton1909
A. Chatman1707
C. Ford1505
A. Green1505
K. Holcomb7/1016621
T. Couch4/75110
N. Hybl4/93211
J. Booty0/2000
J. Jackson1256019
B. Blanchard62005
W. Green21508
W. Green297182
Q. Morgan251039
K. Johnson436120
D. Sanders220010
S. Heiden217114
D. Northcutt116016
B. Blanchard1717
R. Alston1505
Complete Player Stats