| Dan McGuire Award (Pro Bowl Most Valuable Player) | |||
| Year | Winner | Team | Position |
| 2005 | Peyton Manning | Indianapolis Colts | Quarterback |
| 2004 | Marc Bulger | St. Louis Rams | Quarterback |
| 2003 | Ricky Williams | Miami Dolphins | Running Back |
| 2002 | Rich Gannon | Oakland Raiders | Quarterback |
| 2001 | Rich Gannon | Oakland Raiders | Quarterback |
| 2000 | Randy Moss | Minnesota Vikings | Wide Receiver |
| 1999 | Keyshawn Johnson | New York Jets | Wide Receiver |
| Ty Law | New England Patriots | Cornerback | |
| 1998 | Warren Moon | Seattle Seahawks | Quarterback |
| 1997 | Mark Brunell | Jacksonville Jaguars | Quarterback |
| 1996 | Jerry Rice | San Francisco 49ers | Wide Receiver |
| 1995 | Marshall Faulk | Indianapolis Colts | Running Back |
| 1994 | Andre Rison | Atlanta Falcons | Wide Receiver |
| 1993 | Steve Tasker | Buffalo Bills | Special Teams |
| 1992 | Michael Irvin | Dallas Cowboys | Wide Receiver |
| 1991 | Jim Kelly | Buffalo Bills | Quarterback |
| 1990 | Jerry Gray | Los Angeles Rams | Cornerback |
| 1989 | Randall Cunningham | Philadelphia Eagles | Quarterback |
| 1988 | Bruce Smith | Buffalo Bills | Defensive End |
| 1987 | Reggie White | Philadelphia Eagles | Defensive End |
| 1986 | Phil Simms | New York Giants | Quarterback |
| 1985 | Mark Gastineau | New York Jets | Defensive End |
| 1984 | Joe Theismann | Washington Redskins | Quarterback |
| 1983 | Dan Fouts | San Diego Chargers | Quarterback |
| John Jefferson | Green Bay Packers | Wide Receiver | |
| 1982 | Kellen Winslow | San Diego Chargers | Wide Receiver |
| Lee Roy Selmon | Tampa Bay Buccaneers | Defensive End | |
| 1981 | Eddie Murray | Detroit Lions | Kicker |
| 1980 | Chuck Muncie | New Orleans Saints | Running Back |
| 1979 | Ahmad Rashad | Minnesota Vikings | Wide Receiver |
| 1978 | Walter Payton | Chicago Bears | Running Back |
| 1977 | Mel Blount | Pittsburgh Steelers | Cornerback |
| 1976 | Billy Johnson | Houston Oilers | Kick Returner |
| 1975 | James Harris | Los Angeles Rams | Quarterback |
| 1974 | Garo Yepremian | Miami Dolphins | Kicker |
| 1973 | O.J. Simpson | Buffalo Bills | Running Back |
| 1972 | Jan Stenerud | Kansas City Chiefs | Back |
| Willie Lanier | Kansas City Chiefs | Line | |
| 1971 | Mel Renfro | Dallas Cowboys | Back |
| Fred Carr | Green Bay Packers | Line | |
| 1970 | Gale Sayers | Chicago Bears | Back |
| George Andrie | Dallas Cowboys | Line | |
| 1969 | Roman Gabriel | Los Angeles Rams | Back |
| Merlin Olsen | Los Angeles Rams | Line | |
| 1968 | Gale Sayers | Chicago Bears | Back |
| Dave Robinson | Green Bay Packers | Line | |
| 1967 | Gale Sayers | Chicago Bears | Back |
| Floyd Peters | Philadelphia Eagles | Line | |
| 1966 | Jim Brown | Cleveland Browns | Back |
| Dale Meinhart | St. Louis Cardinals | Line | |
| 1965 | Fran Tarkenton | Minnesota Vikings | Back |
| Terry Barr | Detroit Lions | Line | |
| 1964 | Johnny Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Back |
| Gino Marchetti | Baltimore Colts | Line | |
| 1963 | Jim Brown | Cleveland Browns | Back |
| Big Daddy Lipscomb | Pittsburgh Steelers | Line | |
| 1962 | Jim Brown | Cleveland Browns | Back |
| Henry Jordan | Green Bay Packers | Line | |
| 1961 | Johnny Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Back |
| Sam Huff | New York Giants | Line | |
| 1960 | Johnny Unitas | Baltimore Colts | Back |
| Big Daddy Lipscomb | Pittsburgh Steelers | Line | |
| 1959 | Frank Gifford | New York Giants | Back |
| Doug Atkins | Chicago Bears | Line | |
| 1958 | Hugh McElhenny | San Francisco 49ers | Back |
| Gene Brito | Washington Redskins | Line | |
| 1957 | Bert Rechichar | Baltimore Colts | Back |
| Ernie Stautner | Pittsburgh Steelers | Line | |
| 1956 | Ollie Matson | Chicago Cardinals | Half Back |
| 1955 | Billy Wilson | San Francisco 49ers | End |
| 1954 | Chuck Bednarik | Philadelphia Eagles | Linebacker |
| 1953 | Don Doll | Detroit Lions | Defensive Back |
| 1952 | Dan Towler | Los Angeles Rams | Half Back |
| 1951 | Otto Graham | Cleveland Browns | Quarterback |
 |
|
