Colin Kaepernick will get $20M deal whether 49ers pay now or later
Colin Kaepernick wants to be paid like a top-five QB, and the numbers back him up. The Niners' two options? Pay up before the 2014 season -- or risk paying even more later.
Colin Kaepernick won't be signing any contract for $18 million a season. Not for $18.5 million per year, either. The idea he would be happy to land a deal in the range of what Tony Romo or Jay Cutler is earning is a complete and total misnomer. Ain't happenin'.
So I'll let you in on a little secret: The 49ers already know this. Unequivocally. Their negotiations with their young franchise quarterback are still in their infancy, but they are quite aware there aren't any bargain deals to be had here. Far from it. Talks with Kaepernick, if they truly get off the ground, will begin at $20 million a year.
As I first reported back in January, Kaepernick is perfectly willing to gamble on himself, a la Joe Flacco, and will play out his rookie contract if need be (he is signed through 2014). He won't be doing any "bridge contracts" or "band-aid deals," and I can tell you that an extension in the range of the Romos and Cutlers and Staffords simply is not happening.
This kid is confident enough and stubborn enough and motivated enough and focused enough to stick to that position no matter what the 49ers put before him. I can assure you that. He won't budge for less than he believes he is worth. This shouldn't be a revelation based on what I've reported before the NFC title game and earlier this offseason and again, last week, during the combine.
But in the wake of a Boston Globe report pegging Kaepernick's magic number around $18 million, I cannot emphasize strongly enough how far a deal structured in that manner will fall short.
So I'm going to let you in on another little secret: Kaepernick believes he is a top-five quarterback. Staunchly. Now, you and I can debate this -- and likely will, later in this here column -- but in the end, what I think and what you believe is irrelevant. San Francisco eventually has to get Kaepernick to agree to sign away the next five-plus years of his playing career, and that absolutely, positively will not come cheap. At a time when Aaron Rodgers is the league's top-rated passer at $22 million a year, and an aging Peyton Manning is the fifth-highest paid at $19.2 million a season, Kaepernick feels, in his bones, to his core, that he belongs somewhere between there, and I bet sometime in the next three months he gets just that, same as Flacco and Ryan did a year ago.
Now, Kaepernick would never express any of these feelings publicly, and there's no need for him to. In the end, all the talking that needs to occur happens on the field. The body of work speaks loudest.
So, Kaepernick, if he signs a contract extension with the 49ers, will be doing so in the range of $20 million per season, putting him among the top five or six salaries in the history of the game. Otherwise, he'll play for his $1M in 2014 and then force the issue with the 49ers as to whether they franchise him, or sign him to what will in all likelihood be an even more massive contract come 2015 if this kid continues to develop as rapidly as he has to this point. And you can go ahead and ask the Ravens if they would have preferred to have Flacco signed at around $16.6M annually, as they could have in 2011, or Flacco at $20.1M annually, as was the case when he put pen to paper after winning the Super Bowl following the 2012 season.
Timing, alas, is everything. And time is very, very much on Kaepernick's side.
If you think after starting only a season-and-a-half it's too soon to start talking contract extension with him, you are entitled to your opinion. If you maintain the sample size is still too small to go big on Kap, so be it.
But the reality is the 49ers kicked off contract talks with Kaepernick's agents at the unmistakable corner window table at Prime 147 in Indianapolis a few weeks back -- a ubiquitous hot spot that is overflowing with media, agents, GMs and coaches every night during the combine -- so the club very much wants the league to know Kaepernick is their guy and they want to do a deal with him now (furthermore, these negotiations also serve as a positive public relations distraction from some of the nasty infighting going on in that organization these days, centered around coach Jim Harbaugh).
So the reality is these sides are talking, right now, and we can only judge Kaepernick's value based on what he has been able to display so far. And, to me, if you want to talk to this kid now about a contract, you had better be ready to meet him at $20 million a year. I've asked the question to a multitude of GMs and scouts and NFL decisions makers and other agents, and, the vast majority of them agreed that if you are going to start going down the path of a new deal with Kaepernick, a 2011 second-round pick, then based on his performance to this point, including a near Super Bowl win and then a march back to the NFC Championship, you had best be prepared to pay the man, big time.
Here are but a few reasons why:
Kaepernick currently stands third in postseason history in yards per pass attempt (among anyone with 100 playoff pass attempts), at a gaudy 8.48.
His average of 9.9 yards per scrimmage touch, in the NFL playoffs, is the best in league history for any quarterback.
Kaepernick is second all-time among quarterbacks with 507 scrimmage yards in the postseason, behind only Hall of Famer Steve Young (and Young amassed that yardage on 96 carries, while Kaepernick has only 51 playoff rushing attempts). Oh, and those 51 playoff rushes are already 10th in NFL history for any quarterback, yet Kaepernick has played only six postseason games (4-2). John Elway, by comparison, had 94 rushes for 484 yards all-time in the playoffs.
In fact, let's take a deeper look at how Kaepernick stands against his modern-day competition in terms of career playoff performances. And pay special attention to total yards per game (passing and rushing, gross), in the final column. It's fairly staggering. Andrew Luck is the only person close, and Luck has no rushing TDs and more INTs than passing TDs:
|Kaepernick's playoff productivity: A comparison|
|QB||W-L||Win %||QB Rating||Pass Yds||Yds/Att||TD/Int||Rush Yds||Rush Avg||TD||Total Yds (Avg)|
|Colin Kaepernick||4-2||66.7||87.3||1,374||8.48||1.4 (7/5)||507||9.9||4||1,881 (313.5)|
|Tom Brady||16-6||72.7||89.5||5,385||6.79||1.9 (38/20)||80||1.5||3||5,465 (248.4)|
|Peyton Manning||9-10||47.6||88.6||5,389||7.51||1.5 (29/19)||27||1.2||3||5,416 (285.0)|
|Joe Flacco||5-4||55.6||69.0||1,532||6.20||1.0 (8/8)||63||1.9||1||1,595 (177.2)|
|Ben Roethlisberger||5-2||71.4||86.6||1,547||8.19||1.1 (12/11)||125||3.9||2||1,672 (239.0)|
|Drew Brees||4-3||57.1||106.1||2,052||7.20||7.5 (15/2)||25||1.6||0||2,077 (296.7)|
|Eli Manning||4-2||66.7||88.2||1,128||6.88||1.6 (8/5)||14||1.4||0||1,142 (190.3)|
|Mark Sanchez||4-2||66.7||94.3||1,155||7.36||3.0 (9/3)||9||0.8||0||1,164 (194.0)|
|Matt Ryan||1-4||20.0||85.2||1,230||6.58||1.3 (9/7)||18||1.6||0||1,248 (249.6)|
|Philip Rivers||2-2||50.0||81.8||997||8.45||0.8 (4/5)||1||0.1||0||998 (249.5)|
|Tony Romo||1-3||25.0||80.8||832||6.16||2.0 (4/2)||21||3.0||0||853 (213.2)|
|Andrew Luck||1-2||33.3||70.0||1,062||7.59||0.8 (6/8)||85||7.1||0||1,147 (382.3)|
|Andy Dalton||0-3||0.0||56.2||718||5.84||0.2 (1/6)||58||4.8||0||776 (259.3)|
|Jay Cutler||0-2||0.0||84.8||354||8.43||2.0 (2/1)||53||5.3||2||407 (203.5)|
|Carson Palmer||0-2||0.0||66.5||212||5.73||1.0 (1/1)||2||2.0||0||214 (107)|
Now let's take a look at how Kaepernick has fared against every other full-time starting quarterback in the NFL since he took over for Alex Smith in San Francisco midway through 2012 (including regular season and playoffs). It's fairly astonishing.
His passer rating of 92.8 is eighth best in the entire league of qualified passers in that span, ahead of Matt Ryan and Tom Brady and Ben Roethlisberger and Cam Newton and Jay Cutler and plenty of others. It's also way, way ahead of Luck and Flacco and Ryan Tannehill, for comparison's sake. (Oh, and Matt Stafford, he of the $18 million contract, is not even in the top 25).
In yards per attempt, Kaepernick trails only Aaron Rodgers and Russell Wilson in that span (Wilson isn't eligible for a contract extension until 2015, as a 2012 draft pick, and, trust me, count Pete Prisco among those who know I will be constructing a column just like this on Wilson's behalf a year from now, as I am a champion of his as well). Kaepernick stands 11th in TD passes in the NFL (38) since taking over as starter, one behind Flacco and three behind Luck -- despite far fewer attempts -- and only four behind Wilson and five behind Ryan.
However, Kaepernick's 16 INTs -- in 29 total regular season and playoff games -- puts him in the most elite company, as Rogers, Alex Smith, Wilson and RG3 are the only full-time starters with fewer picks in that span. In terms of TD-to-INT ratio, Kaepernick is right there with Brees since taking over as a starter, and his percentage of first-down passes is sixth best (37 percent), on equal footing with guys like Rogers and Brady and Brees. Always impressive company to keep.
Only Brees (68) and Peyton Manning (67) have more completions of 25-plus yards since Kaepernick became a starter (he has 61) and only eight other men have more overall passing yards since he took over for Smith. And when you factor in total scrimmage yards, in the regular season and playoffs, Kaepernick's uniqueness becomes even more unmistakable.
Since Kaepernick received his first NFL start, he has 185 rushes (regular season and playoffs), tied with Cam Newton for most among all quarterbacks. Yet Kaepernick has 1,269 rushing yards, over 200 more than Newton in that span (Wilson is the only other quarterback in the league with over 1,000 scrimmage yards). Newton and Kaepernick are tied with 10 rushing TDs (playoff and regular season) since Nov. 18, 2012 (no other quarterback has more than six in that span), while Kaepernick's 43.8 scrimmage yards per game are most of any regular starter in that span (Cam is at 42.8). Kaepernick's mark of 6.9 yards per rush blows away the competition (Wilson is next at 6.1), and further cements him as a freak-of-nature talent.
Don't believe me? Check out this chart, which includes the NFL leaders at quarterback in the regular and postseason since Nov. 18, 2012, the week that Kaepernick made his first NFL start (with a minimum of 10 starts since then):
Now let's consider how young Kaepernick is. How much he has flashed already in the postseason. How, compared to anyone other than Nick Foles in this above chart, he looks like a baby, just making his first start at a time when even other relative youngsters like Wilson already has a career in minor-league baseball and had been starting games in the NFL in the first half of 2012 before a concussion to Smith first opened the opportunity for Kaepernick.
|NFL QB leaders since Nov. 18, 2012: Regular and postseason (minimum 10 starts)|
|1. Peyton Manning||Den||27||1083||739||68.2||8631||7.97||79||7.3||20||1.8||78t||32||206||108.8||451||41.6||67|
|2. Aaron Rodgers||GB||19||613||411||67.0||5156||8.41||35||5.7||10||1.6||83t||51||297||105.2||231||37.7||52|
|3. Russell Wilson||Sea||27||677||434||64.1||5744||8.48||43||6.4||12||1.8||80t||72||418||104.6||265||39.1||59|
|4. Nick Foles||Phi||20||583||365||62.6||4566||7.83||34||5.8||6||1.0||63t||48||312||102.0||205||35.2||39|
|5. Philip Rivers||SD||25||814||542||66.6||6226||7.65||46||5.7||14||1.7||60t||62||348||101.1||320||39.3||48|
|6. Drew Brees||NO||25||1019||682||66.9||8051||7.90||59||5.8||24||2.4||76t||50||331||100.3||387||38.0||68|
|7. Tony Romo||Dal||22||839||537||64.0||6128||7.30||47||5.6||16||1.9||85t||54||429||96.6||301||35.9||45|
|8. Colin Kaepernick||SF||29||770||457||59.4||6179||8.02||38||4.9||16||2.1||64t||61||362||92.8||287||37.3||61|
|9. Matt Ryan||Atl||25||992||675||68.0||7109||7.17||44||4.4||27||2.7||81t||54||370||92.1||362||36.5||37|
|10. Alex Smith||SF-KC||17||555||339||61.1||3697||6.66||27||4.9||7||1.3||79t||41||225||91.7||181||32.6||25|
|11. Ben Roethlisberger||Pit||20||717||450||62.8||5239||7.31||37||5.2||18||2.5||67||54||364||91.6||253||35.3||37|
|12. Cam Newton||Car||24||712||433||60.8||5372||7.54||36||5.1||17||2.4||79t||60||453||91.1||255||35.8||42|
|13. Robert Griffin III||Was||20||606||370||61.1||4494||7.42||30||5.0||15||2.5||68t||50||364||90.1||221||36.5||40|
|14. Tom Brady||NE||27||1064||640||60.2||7664||7.20||46||4.3||18||1.7||83t||57||378||89.6||395||37.1||52|
|15. Jay Cutler||Chi||17||534||328||61.4||3840||7.19||26||4.9||16||3.0||67||29||182||87.0||182||34.1||31|
|16. Sam Bradford||StL||14||525||308||58.7||3317||6.32||25||4.8||10||1.9||80t||25||158||85.2||171||32.6||21|
|17. Andy Dalton||Cin||25||880||532||60.5||6094||6.93||43||4.9||28||3.2||82t||58||302||84.3||293||33.3||44|
|18. Mike Glennon||TB||13||416||247||59.4||2608||6.27||19||4.6||9||2.2||85t||40||314||83.9||126||30.3||15|
|19. Carson Palmer||Oak-Ari||22||762||477||62.6||5569||7.31||31||4.1||27||3.5||91t||50||361||83.5||268||35.2||34|
|20. Ryan Tannehill||Mia||22||764||458||59.9||5087||6.66||30||3.9||19||2.5||67||74||481||82.5||263||34.4||31|
|21. Joe Flacco||Bal||27||962||566||58.8||6538||6.80||39||4.1||25||2.6||74||70||471||82.1||312||32.4||53|
|22. Matt Schaub||Hou||19||716||459||64.1||4910||6.86||21||2.9||22||3.1||54t||38||309||81.1||243||33.9||27|
|23. Matt Cassel||KC-Min||10||270||161||59.6||1900||7.04||11||4.1||9||3.3||79t||17||86||80.8||84||31.1||13|
|24. Andrew Luck||Ind||26||975||551||56.5||6627||6.80||42||4.3||26||2.7||73t||59||385||80.7||317||32.5||51|
The warts in Kaepernick's game -- a completion percentage below 60, for instance -- only stand to improve, and his accuracy I suspect will shine over time (recall he played almost exclusively in the shotgun in college in an offense that, at the time, was considered a novelty). He is just starting to morph into what he will become, he has the kind of size and speed and instincts that cannot be taught, and he has thrived despite having to deal with some offensive limitations around him in terms of game-breaking personnel.
So start the bidding at $20 million a season, and see where it goes. Because with a salary cap that is finally on the rise, and playing the most glamorous of positions, and with the franchise tag for quarterbacks ascending, too, Colin Kaepernick would never be short of suitors, and the 49ers are plenty smart enough to realize they could never give him the opportunity to find out exactly what the open market might bear.
Our Latest Stories
It looks like the two men have finally buried the hatchet
This is the most delicious version of Tom Brady that you'll ever see
It was a rough morning for the Ravens safety
It's not easy being an NFL head coach in the offseason
The Jets have been doing some serious housecleaning this week
Kyle Shanahan is already beefing up his defensive line