Prosecution in Aaron Hernandez case wants judge to recuse herself

If the prosecution gets what it wants, there will be a new judge in the Hernandez case. (USATSI)
If the prosecution gets what it wants, there will be a new judge in the Hernandez case. (USATSI)

If the prosecution in the Aaron Hernandez case has its way, a new judge will be on the bench when Hernandez's murder trial eventually starts. At a pretrial hearing on Wednesday, the prosecution made it known that it would like Judge Susan Garsh to recuse herself. 

Reasons for the request weren't detailed in court, but according to a case filing obtained by the Associated Press, there's a 'well-known and publicly documented history of antagonism' between Garsh and Bristol County Assistant District Attorney William McCauley. 

According to the Fall River Herald News, the tension between McCauley and Garsh dates back to a 2010 murder trial where McCauley believed Garsh made rulings on evidence that handcuffed the prosecution. At the time, McCauley said Garsh "exhibited antagonism to the commonwealth's case through the trial."

McCauley didn't believe that Garsh had the judicial background to preside over the 2010 murder case, which involved a man shooting a 15-year-old boy to death on New Year's Eve in 2008. 

The motion to recuse Garsh will be heard on Oct. 21. 

As for Hernandez, he remains behind bars as he waits for his murder trial to start. Hernandez is facing a first-degree murder charge stemming from the June death of 27-year-old Odin Lloyd. 

CBS Sports Writer

John Breech has been at CBS Sports since July 2011 and currently spends most of his time writing about the NFL. He's believed to be one of only three people in the world who thinks that Andy Dalton will... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
CBS Sports Store
NFL Nike Gear
Our Latest Stories