A tough call, but give me Manning. I love Big Ben's resilience; the guy is tougher than last week's steak, and he makes few mistakes. He's the perfect fit for the Steelers, and he's a guy I'd take over almost anyone. But Manning is not anyone. I tilt ever so slightly toward him because he's a superior passer, especially down the field. He has a strong and accurate arm, and he can make plays with his feet. So can Roethlisberger, but Eli is becoming the quarterback the Giants envisioned when they gave away the store for him. Both these guys have won Super Bowls, and both are almost impossible to get out of the lineup. The knock on Manning was his inconsistency, but that's gone. Over his last nine games he has 16 touchdown passes, three interceptions, eight wins and one Super Bowl. That clinches it for me.
Bigger surprise: The Falcons at 3-2 or the Chargers at 2-3?
Matt Ryan That's tough, but I'll have to go with the Falcons at 3-2. I really didn't think they would be as good as they've been. With a rookie starter at quarterback, I expected some growing pains. But they've run the ball and they've controlled the clock. One thing about the Falcons is that they are feisty. They don't back down from anybody. Just watching them you see a physical team that pushes the envelope when it comes to hitting close to the whistle. And that's OK. That's what they have to do. They're still a couple of years away from being a legitimate playoff contender, but one or two drafts will fix that. For now, they will be a handful for every team they face this season. As long as Matt Ryan continues to take care of the football and Michael Turner keeps ripping off the yards, they will be competitive. If they beat the Bears this week, they'll be 4-2. Can you believe it? Amazing. Michael Turner The Falcons, but only by a nose. Were it not for Ed Hochuli, the Chargers would be 3-2, and we wouldn't be having this conversation. The Falcons, however, were viewed as a preseason doormat, pegged to win no more than four games. Now they're only a game out of first in a competitive division. Mike Smith should be commended. So should GM Tom Dimitroff. They had a plan, and it's working. They bought free-agent running back Michael Turner, and, in so doing, freed themselves to take a quarterback with the third pick of the draft. Good idea. I didn't foresee either of these two clubs having these starts, but at least the Chargers have been here before. They were 1-3 a year ago and made it to the AFC Championship Game. But Atlanta with a rookie quarterback? That win in Green Bay convinced me something is right with the Falcons.
What has happened to the Jaguars?
They can't stop anybody on third down and their passing game lacks any threat down the field. All offseason they talked about how they would amp up the passing game. Well, David Garrard's passer rating is way down and his yards-per-attempt is down over a yard from last season. They just don't threaten down the field. In turn, that leads to teams loading up against the run, which is why Fred Taylor and Maurice Jones-Drew can't shook loose, except for one game. Jerry Porter and Dennis Northcutt, their two high-priced receivers, have a combined six catches. Nobody stretches the field. Or at least tries it. On defense, they have eight sacks in five games. That's awful. That's a big reason why they are last in third-down defense, allowing teams to convert on 49 percent of their third downs. That will keep a lot of drives alive. It's also why the defense has given up game-winning scores in all three losses in the fourth quarter. No pass rush and no deep passing game make for a lot of problems in this pass-happy NFL. The Jaguars are proof of that. After 'sickening' loss, owner tell Browns fans: I'm committed - NFL - CBSSports.com News, Rumors, Scores, Stats, Fantasy
Forgot Log-in or  Password? |  Help  Not a member, Register Now!
 

After 'sickening' loss, owner tell Browns fans: I'm committed

  •  

BEREA, Ohio -- Cleveland Browns owner Randy Lerner says he will wait until after the season before deciding on the future of coach Romeo Crennel and general manager Phil Savage.

During a rare interview Tuesday, the intensely private Lerner addressed a wide-range of topics, but steered clear of specific questions about Crennel or Savage. The two are under fire with the Browns at 4-7 and out of the playoff picture one year after winning 10 games and sending six players to the Pro Bowl.

Lerner has not yet decided whether he'll bring back Crennel or Savage, whom he hired in 2005. The Browns are just 24-35 in that span and have yet to make the postseason.

"I will take issues and concerns and criticisms very seriously and think through them and evaluate them in January," he said.

Lerner did outline his criteria for evaluating his GM, who was forced to apologize to a fan last week for sending a profane e-mail following Cleveland's game at Buffalo.

"You weigh strengths and weaknesses," he said. "I think that Phil recruits as aggressively as anybody could ever ask a guy to do and as thoroughly as anyone could ask a guy to do. I think we've been a beneficiary of those skills and that determination and commitment."

The 46-year-old Lerner has been criticized by some Browns fans for not seeming more involved with the daily operations of his franchise, which he inherited following his father's death in 2003. Lerner also owns Aston Villa of the English Premier League, leaving some to wonder about his commitment.

"I care totally about the team," Lerner said. "When I reflect on that concern and criticism, it's probably a byproduct of the management approach I've chosen. If you're going to give people authority and hold them responsible and ultimately accountable for their performance, you've got to get out of the way. Especially when they have unique skills that you don't have, like picking players or coaching."

Lerner said he has no plans to sell the franchise and denied a rumor he has been approached about a possible deal.

"I'm not prepared to throw in the towel at 46 and suggest I can't get the job done," he said. "On the other hand, I don't want to live in some delusional bubble somewhere."

Lerner expressed frustration about not being able to build an identity for the Browns and described Sunday's home loss to Houston as "sickening."

Copyright 2012 by STATS LLC and The Associated Press. Any commercial use or distribution without the express written consent of STATS LLC and The Associated Press is strictly prohibited.
  •  
 
 
 
 
Related Links
 
Top NFL
 

CBSSports.com Shop

Nike Andrew Luck Indianapolis Colts 2012 Draft Game Jersey

NFL Draft Gear
Get yours today Shop Now