AFC | NFC
| AFC | ||
| Offense | ||
| Pos. | Player | Team |
| WR (4) | Marvin Harrison | Indianapolis |
| Andre Johnson | Houston | |
| Chad Johnson | Cincinnati | |
| Hines Ward | Pittsburgh | |
| Tackles (3) | Willie Anderson | Cincinnati |
| Jonathan Ogden | Baltimore | |
| Willie Roaf | Kansas City | |
| Guards (3) | Alan Faneca | Pittsburgh |
| Will Shields | Kansas City | |
| Brian Waters | Kansas City | |
| Centers (2) | Jeff Hartings | Pittsburgh |
| Kevin Mawae | N.Y. Jets | |
| TE (2) | Antonio Gates | San Diego |
| Tony Gonzalez | Kansas City | |
| Quarterback (3) | Tom Brady | New England |
| Drew Brees | San Diego | |
| Peyton Manning | Indianapolis | |
| Running Backs (3) | Jerome Bettis** | Pittsburgh |
| Corey Dillon* | New England | |
| Edgerrin James* | Indianapolis | |
| Rudi Johnson** | Cincinnati | |
| Curtis Martin* | N.Y. Jets | |
| LaDainian Tomlinson | San Diego | |
| Fullback (1) | Tony Richardson | Kansas City |
| Defense | ||
| Pos. | Player | Team |
| Defensive Ends (3) | John Abraham | N.Y. Jets |
| Dwight Freeney | Indianapolis | |
| Jason Taylor | Miami | |
| Interior Linemen (3) | Sam Adams | Buffalo |
| John Henderson** | Jacksonville | |
| Richard Seymour* | New England | |
| Marcus Stroud | Jacksonville | |
| Outside Linebackers (3) | Joey Porter | Pittsburgh |
| Takeo Spikes | Buffalo | |
| Terrell Suggs | Baltimore | |
| Inside Linebackers (2) | Tedy Bruschi** | New England |
| James Farrior | Pittsburgh | |
| Ray Lewis* | Baltimore | |
| Cornerback (3) | Champ Bailey | Denver |
| Nate Clements** | Buffalo | |
| Tory James | Cincinnati | |
| Chris McAlister* | Baltimore | |
| Patrick Surtain* | Miami | |
| Strong Safety (2) | Troy Polamalu | Pittsburgh |
| Ed Reed | Baltimore | |
| Free Safeties (1) | John Lynch | Denver |
| Specialists | ||
| Pos. | Player | Team |
| Punter (1) | Shane Lechler | Oakland |
| Placekicker (1) | Adam Vinatieri | New England |
| Kick Return Specialist (1) | Terrence McGee | Buffalo |
| Special Teamer (1) | Larry Izzo | New England |
|
Starters are bold
* Injured, will not participate ** Replacement | ||
