• My Scores
  • NFL
  • MLB
  • Golf
Senior NFL Columnist

Free agency: What players should be top priorities to keep, team by team

More NFL offseason: NFL Mock Drafts | Prospect Rankings | Top free agents

Now that the franchise tags and transition tags are set, and we know who will be available when the free-agent market opens March 11, it's a good time to give advice to the 32 teams on which of their players they should bring back.

Some are obvious. One is the Buffalo Bills bringing back safety Jairus Byrd, a top player at his position at a time when free safeties who can run are at a premium. Yet the Bills chose to not put the franchise tag on him, which means he will hit the market. Buffalo should do what it can to bring him back.

There are other obvious choices, but some teams have so little on their free-agent list that it's tough to find one player who should be brought back. But I managed to scrape together a list for all 32 teams, one that doesn't include any of the six players who received franchise or transition tags. Here goes:

Arizona Cardinals

ILB Karlos Dansby: He played well for them after signing a one-year deal last spring. He will want more this time around, but maybe they can still get him for a decent price.

Atlanta Falcons

DT Jonathan Babineaux: He has been around for a while and done some good things. They would like to get bigger inside, but he's still a decent player for the right money.

Baltimore Ravens

T Eugene Monroe: They will likely let Michael Oher walk, which makes keeping Monroe a priority. They traded to get him during the 2013 season, and he is a priority. But he will get action on the market.

Buffalo Bills

S Jairus Byrd: The Bills opted not to put the tag on Byrd, which is a surprise. He will get a lot of attention from other teams, but the Bills would be foolish to let him walk.

Carolina Panthers

G Travelle Wharton: With Jordan Gross retiring, they can't afford to lose another starting offensive lineman. He played well last season, but he's getting up in age.

Chicago Bears

DT Henry Melton: He is coming off an injury, but he is a good player when healthy. The contract is the issue. The Bears would love to have him back.

Cincinnati Bengals

DE Michael Johnson: The price might be an issue, but if it's reasonable they need to bring him back. The line has a chance to be special when Geno Atkins returns with Carlos Dunlap and Johnson.

Cleveland Browns

S T.J. Ward: Now that they put the transition tag on center Alex Mack, he's likely not going anywhere. So they should make signing Ward, a young safety, a top priority.

Dallas Cowboys

DT Jason Hatcher: They would love to have him back, but only at the right price. They don't have a lot of money. He played good football in 2013, but he's 32.

Denver Broncos

CB Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie: Champ Bailey is getting up in age and Chris Harris is coming off a knee injury. Rodgers-Cromartie needs to be brought back.

Detroit Lions

TE Brandon Pettigrew: It's hard to find tight ends. Yes, he's had his share of drops, but he has a lot of ability. He has flashed at times.

Green Bay Packers

CB Sam Shields: Yes, he is not the bigger corner teams love now. But he's done some good things against some bigger receivers and he has nice man-cover skills. The money will be key to his return. The Packers would like him back.

Houston Texans

DE Antonio Smith: I know he's not a kid anymore, but he can still play at a high level. And he's a good player to have in the locker room.

Indianapolis Colts

CB Vontae Davis: He is a top-level cover corner who is coming off a good season when he was healthy. They traded to get him from Miami, so keeping him makes sense.

Jacksonville Jaguars

QB Chad Henne: He isn't a must, but they want him back to be their starter until they can find a franchise passer. Henne did some good things last season, but he's more of a stop-gap guy, keeping the seat warm.

Kansas City Chiefs

G Jon Asomoah or Geoff Schwartz: They have to keep one of the two players who split time at right guard last season.

Miami Dolphins

DT Randy Starks: He is getting up in years but he still plays at a high level. They will likely make a choice between Starks and Paul Soliai.

Minnesota Vikings

DE Everson Griffin: You would think I would say Jared Allen. But I opt for the younger defensive end. He might come cheaper.

New England Patriots

CB Aqib Talib: With so many teams spreading it out on offense, it's key to have a top corner. Talib is that. When he was out, it showed on the field.

New Orleans Saints

RT Zach Strief: With Jimmy Graham getting the franchise tag, they need to bring back a right tackle who played well in 2013. Strief isn't great, but he fits with what they do on offense.

New York Giants

DT Linval Joseph: He is a power player in the run game, which the Giants need. He doesn't offer much in terms of the pass rush.

New York Jets

RT Austin Howard: He is young and improving, which are two traits you want if re-signing a guy. He isn't top-level, but he's good enough as a starter.

Oakland Raiders

DE Lamarr Houston: He is their best defender and is coming off a good season. At 25, it's rare to see a lineman of his age come free. The Raiders need to get him back.

Philadelphia Eagles

Nobody. They've already re-signed Riley Cooper and Jeremy Maclin. That's enough.

Pittsburgh Steelers

NT-DE Al Woods: He did some good thing last season and he's 26. The price would be decent, too. The price for Emmanuel Sanders, a receiver, would not be. So I go with Woods.

St. Louis Rams

G Rodger Saffold: He wasn't great at tackle, but when he moved inside to guard he played well. They need to find a way to keep him on a line that could lose some guys.

San Diego Chargers

G Chad Rinehart: He missed time early with a toe injury, but really played well down the stretch. He was on a one-year deal after leaving Buffalo. He was really good for the Bills in 2011.

San Francisco 49ers

C Jonathan Goodwin: Their line has continuity and Goodwin fits with what they do. I think they can replace Donte Whitner easier than Goodwin.

Seattle Seahawks

WR Golden Tate: He knows the offense and he's a tough-guy receiver. He had a better year than most think he did. He isn't a No. 1, but he's a quality No. 2.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

LB Dekoda Watson: They really don't have much hitting the market, so I went with Watson, who did some good things last season. He started three games and also played some defensive end late. At 25, He's worth keeping.

Tennessee Titans

CB Alterraun Verner: He is coming off his best season, but he's 5-9 and the league is looking for bigger corners. He's worth bringing back, but at what price?

Washington Redskins

LB Perry Riley: By tagging Brian Orakpo, they will keep their top priority. Riley isn't a star, but he has been a steady player in their defense. London Fletcher is retiring and Riley is only 25. Keep him.

CBSSports Facebook Google Plus
COMMENTS
Conversation powered by Livefyre
NEVER MISS A MOCK DRAFT
Sign up to our newsletter and find out who your team could be picking
 

nfl Video

August 28, 2015
Victory Cruz sitting another preseason game (2:52)
August 28, 2015
Carlos Hyde compares himself to Frank Gore
(1:05)
August 27, 2015
Who is the most dangerous player in the AFC?
(0:27)
August 27, 2015
Quarterbacks London Fletcher wanted to punch
(0:43)

Latest

Most Popular

CBSSports.com Shop

Men's Nike Scarlet Ohio State Buckeyes No. 15 Limited Football Jersey

College Sideline Gear
Get your favorite school
Shop Now

2016 Super Bowl
Super Bowl