| Offense |
| QB |
Brett Favre |
First player in history to win three Most Valuable Player awards (1995-97). Led Packers to victory in Super Bowl XXXI. Had decade-best 235 TD passes. |
| RB |
Terrell Davis |
Named 1998 league MVP after rushing for 2,008 yards and 23 TDs. Rushed for 6,624 yards and 58 TDs in six seasons. Named to three Pro Bowls (1997-99). |
| RB |
Thurman Thomas |
Named 1991 league MVP with 2,038 yards from scrimmage. Named to four straight Pro Bowls (1991-94). Went to four Super Bowls with Bills (XXV-XXVIII). |
| WR |
Tim Brown |
Ranked third in decade with 726 receptions. Named to seven Pro Bowls (1992, 1994-98, 2000). His 10,211 yards and 70 TDs rank fourth in 1990s. |
| WR |
Michael Irvin |
Won three Super Bowls with Cowboys (XXVII-XXVIII, XXX). His 10,872 receiving yards rank second in 1990s. Selected to five straight Pro Bowls (1992-96). |
| OT |
Tony Boselli |
Named to four consecutive Pro Bowls (1997-2000). First draft choice in Jacksonville Jaguars history (#2 overall in 1995). |
| OT |
Richmond Webb |
Selected to seven consecutive Pro Bowls (1991-97). Set Dolphins record with 118 consecutive starts from 1991-98. |
| G |
Larry Allen |
Won Super Bowl XXX with Cowboys. Named to five consecutive Pro Bowls (1996-2000) as both guard and tackle. |
| G |
Steve Wisniewski |
Started 159 of possible 160 games in decade. Named to seven Pro Bowls, including six in row (1991-96, 1998). |
| C |
Mark Stepnoski |
Won Super Bowl XXVII and XXVIII with Cowboys. Selected to five consecutive Pro Bowls (1993-97). |
| TE |
Ben Coates |
Had second-most catches among tight ends in decade with 490. Named to five consecutive Pro Bowls (1995-99). Went to Super Bowl XXXI with Patriots. |
| Defense |
| DE |
Chris Doleman |
His 107.5 sacks in decade rank third among defensive linemen. Named to five Pro Bowls (1991, 1993-94, 1996, 1998). |
| DE |
Neil Smith |
Won two Super Bowls with Broncos (XXXII & XXXIII). Had 95.5 sacks in decade, ranking fifth among defensive ends. Selected to six Pro Bowls (1992-96, 1998). |
| DT |
Warren Sapp |
Named 1999 Defensive Player of the Year. Selected to three straight Pro Bowls (1998-2000). Has 42 sacks in five seasons in 1990s, including 30.0 in last three. |
| DT |
Bryant Young |
Named to 1997 and 2000 Pro Bowls. Had 48 sacks in six seasons in decade. Named 1994 Defensive Rookie of the Year. |
| LB |
Cornelius Bennett |
Played in five Super Bowls in 1990s, four with Buffalo (XXV-XXVIII) and one with Atlanta (XXXIII). Also selected to four Pro Bowls (1991-94). |
| LB |
Hardy Nickerson |
Selected to five Pro Bowls, including last four (1994, 1997-2000). In 1999, led Buccaneers to first NFC Championship Game since 1979. |
| LB |
Levon Kirkland |
Has started every game since 1995 season (96 consecutive). Named to 1997 and 1998 Pro Bowls. Went to Super Bowl XXX with Steelers. |
| CB |
Darrell Green |
Led club to victory in Super Bowl XXVI. Played in 152 games in decade recording 27 INTs. Named to four Pro Bowls (1991-92, 1997-98). |
| CB |
Aeneas Williams |
His 41 interceptions rank second in decade among all cornerbacks. Named to six straight Pro Bowls (1995-2000). Tied for NFL lead with nine INTs in 1994. |
| S |
Carnell Lake |
Started 155 of possible 160 games in decade. Selected to five Pro Bowls (1995-98, 2000). Went to Super Bowl XXX with Steelers. |
| S |
Ronnie Lott |
Named to 1991 and 1992 Pro Bowls. Led league in 1991 with eight interceptions when with Raiders. |
| Special Teams |
| K |
Gary Anderson |
Scored most points in decade (1,130). Set NFL record with 40 straight FGs over 1997-98. Did not miss field goal (35) or PAT (59) in 1998, scoring 164 points. |
| P |
Sean Landeta |
Selected to 1991 Pro Bowl. Had 43.5 gross average for decade, seventh best, and led NFC in gross average in 1994 and 1995. |
| KR |
Mel Gray |
Named to four Pro Bowls (1991-93, 1995). Led league in 1991 and 1994. Had five TDs in decade, including three in '94, tied for second-most ever in season. |
| PR |
Mel Gray |
Had 10.5 average in decade and two touchdowns. Led league with 15.4 average in 1991. Had seven total return TDs in 1990s. |
| Head Coach |
| Coach |
Marv Levy |
In eight seasons, led Buffalo Bills to four consecutive Super Bowls (XXV-XXVIII), six playoff appearances and four AFC East titles. Had 82-46 (.641) regular-season record. |