It is the lament of the Buffalo Bills that the Super Bowl was not played
before January 1967, because the members of the 1964 AFL championship team
are convinced they would have taken care of Buffalo's Super Bowl woes.
Lou Saban's outfit won 12 of 14 regular-season games that season, drummed a
very good San Diego team in the AFL title game, and felt reasonably certain
it could do the same to that year's NFL champion, the Jim Brown-led
Cleveland Browns, had the teams met in a pro football championship game.
"We had the best team in football that year," defensive end Tom Day said.
The AFL had built a reputation of being a league enamored with high-powered
offenses, but the '64 Bills changed the model by which future AFL teams were
developed. Saban built a powerhouse defense that featured a dynamic front
four, smart and physical linebackers, aggressive cornerbacks and
ball-hawking safeties.
 | |
| Defensive end Ron McDole starred in the league's best defense. (AP) | |
"They were a good, smart defense," Boston's Gino Cappelletti said. "They were
systemized. They always had people in the right positions."
The Bills allowed just 913 yards rushing, fewest ever in a 14-game schedule,
and their average yield of 65 yards per game ranks third all-time behind the
Bears in 1942 and Eagles in 1944. They led the AFL in fewest points allowed
(242), first downs allowed (206), sacks (50) and interceptions (34).
Buffalo's offense, powered by fullback Cookie Gilchrist, who Raiders coach Al
Davis that season called "the greatest football player in America," was very
productive. But when a game was on the line, it was the defense that always
rose to the occasion.
"A lot of people talk about the wild AFL days, but ours was a solid defensive
team," middle linebacker Harry Jacobs said. "We had some good offensive
players, but our defense won games for us."
Only two regular-season opponents topped 100 yards rushing against the Bills,
the high being 130 by Kansas City. After his Broncos had been throttled by
the Bills in Week 2, Denver quarterback Jacky Lee said, "what an improvement
in that defense. They're really solid."
Charley Hennigan, who set a pro football record in 1964 by catching 101
passes, said of the Bills defense: "You know you've been hit when they hit
you, but they're one of the cleanest teams in the league."
The front four of Day, Ron McDole, Tom Sestak and Jim Dunaway was superb.
Sestak arrived in 1962 as a 17th-round draft choice, Dunaway was a
second-rounder in '63, McDole came via a trade with Houston in '63, and Day
was converted to the defensive line at the start of '64 after Saban received
a call from the player's mother.
It seems Mrs. Day was not pleased that Saban was planning for the third
year in a row to miscast her son as an offensive guard.
``She called Saban up
and said `My son does not play offense, he plays defense,' '' Day recalled.
Saban was a no-nonsense guy who did not take gruff from anyone, but he took
it from Mildred Day. And was he ever glad that he did.
``I enjoyed giving out pain,'' Day said. `` McDole and I had a saying -- `see
you in the backfield.' We had a good crew back then.''
Tackles Sestak and Dunaway would stand up the guards and center, and collapse the pocket from the inside, allowing Day and McDole to use their quickness to control the flanks
and prevent opposing quarterbacks from escaping their wrath.
And when the Bills used their Oklahoma defense -- a three-man line with four
linebackers - rather than take out one of their linemen, they simply dropped
Day into a linebacker role and moved Sestak to end.
Day was the final link up front, but the key player in that group was Sestak.
"I played for a long time, in three decades," said former Chiefs quarterback
and Hall of Famer Len Dawson. "I played in two Super Bowls and I saw a lot of
very good players, but Sestak was one of the greatest defensive players I
ever played against."
Said Day: "Sestak allowed the rest of us to just fly at people. Sestak
actually was the hub of the whole defense. The guy was one of the best,
without a doubt."
| The 1964-65 Bills |
| DE | Tom Day |
| DT | Jim Dunaway |
| DT | Tom Sestak |
| DE | Ron McDole |
| OLB | Mike Stratton |
| MLB | Harry Jacobs |
| OLB | John Tracey |
| CB | Booker Edgerson |
| CB | Butch Byrd |
| S | George Saimes |
| S | Hagood Clarke |
Jacobs keyed the middle tier of defense with his superb ability to read plays
and make the calls, and he was flanked by Mike Stratton and John Tracey, who
could run, tackle and defend against the pass.
In the secondary, Booker Edgerson and Butch Byrd were excellent man-to-man
cornerbacks. "We played man-to-man defense probably 98 percent of the time. That's just the way we did it," Edgerson said. "Joe (Collier, the defensive coordinator) always taught man-to-man. We were 3-4 yards off the ball, so we
were very good in coverage. If we set back 6-10 yards, he'd have a fit."
The reason Collier preferred man-to-man was because he knew he had two
outstanding cover corners in Edgerson and Butch Byrd. And if they could
maintain coverage for a few seconds, that was enough time for the Bills'
front line to get to the quarterback. But when Edgerson and Byrd were beaten,
safeties George Saimes and Hagood Clarke usually covered
their mistake. Saimes was a marvelous player who, like Sestak,
was named to the all-time AFL defensive team.
Saimes, who made 22 interceptions as a Bill, said, "The key was that we had a
good front four and we had two excellent cornerbacks. Booker was a great
cover guy and Butch was very physical. We could play a lot of man-to-man and
do some things that other teams couldn't do. That combination of having those
cornerbacks who you knew you could depend on, and that front four that put
pressure on the quarterback, that was a big key. Those corners could have
started for any team in the NFL."