Oct. 1, 2001
One of the few ways a reporter can draw a positive word from Larry Bowa after a Phillies loss is to ask about Jimmy Rollins. But even that can start a losing argument.
The problem is that for all of Rollins' importance in the Phillies' playoff hopes, he has no chance of winning the NL Rookie of the Year Award.
"You have to be realistic," Bowa said. "The numbers that [Albert] Pujols has put up are eye-shattering. What Jimmy has done is eye-shattering, too. But most of the time, the player who puts up the best power numbers will win."
Pujols' numbers have rendered the award debate silent since May, unless that debate extends to whether Pujols can rival Ichiro by attempting to win MVP as well. Rollins likely won't be a respectable rookie runner-up, either. Roy Oswalt has second place all but sealed for his mastery to shore up Houston's pitching staff.
So what does this 22-year-old speedster have to do for respect? Lead the National League in stolen bases, lead the Phillies into the postseason and bat leadoff well enough to set up the struggling hitters in the middle of the order.
While Scott Rolen earned the credit for slugging Philly back into the NL East race two weeks ago against Atlanta, Rollins has enjoyed nearly as strong a second half. His .274 average for September made him the team's only everyday player besides Rolen to bat better than .255 for the month. Not that .274 makes a fantastic average, but it stands out in a division loaded with teams struggling on offense.
When the Phillies blew a 5-1 lead Friday at Florida, Rollins proved to be one of the few bright spots. His two walks led to a pair of runs. He made a spectacular grab and throw to nearly nab Dave Berg at first on the infield single that started the Marlins' game-tying, ninth-inning rally. The previous week, he scored five times in the club's three wins over the Braves coming out of the postponements.
"He's got an awareness of big games for a young kid," Bowa said. "He thrives on big games, it seems."
His work batting second in the order was good enough to make him the Phillies' lone All-Star in Seattle. Now that he's batting atop the order, his numbers are earning even more recognition.
"He's going to be solid," center fielder Doug Glanville said. "He's going to be a good player for a long time. He already provides a lot. He gets a little overlooked. Pujols is the main thing."
That means plenty coming from Glanville, whose leadoff spot turned out to be Rollins' best steal when Bowa shuffled the lineup at the end of July. At that point, Rollins' on-base percentage stood barely above .300, bad enough for a No. 8 hitter. His on-base percentage from the top spot through Saturday was .354.
The difference isn't in his batting average. Since going 5-for-9 in a May 23 doubleheader against Pittsburgh, his average hasn't dipped below .266 nor risen above .282.
Instead, he's developing a batting eye. He has walked as many times in the past two months as he did over the first four.
"I think he's going to walk a lot more next year," Bowa said. "He has done a great job. The one area he needs to address, and he has told it to me, is that as a switch-hitter he strikes out too much (105 times entering Sunday). That's just experience."
The other areas he has covered. He's the only National League player to have double digits in doubles, triples, home runs and stolen bases. He'll become the first player to lead the Senior Circuit in steals and triples since Lou Brock in 1968. His stolen-base work became well-known in the first half when he ran off 35 consecutive steals without being caught from May 9 until Aug. 25. His 95 runs scored rank behind only San Francisco's Rich Aurilia among NL shortstops.
"He's definitely getting better with experience," said second baseman Marlon Anderson, who jumped from batting eighth into Rollins' old No. 2 spot. He's batting .326 there.
Glanville, meanwhile, has taken his newfound 14-homer power down in the order to the sixth and seventh spots. Batting sixth, he had a pair of two-out RBI singles Saturday in a Phillies win.
What Rollins doesn't have are Pujols' lofty home run and RBI numbers, nor can he match Oswalt's record.
In a lineup where Bowa's tinkering might become a full-blown overhaul next season, especially if Scott Rolen is traded, Rollins could soon become a beacon of stability.
"I think now he would be a great No. 2 hitter," Bowa said. "But he's doing a great job at leadoff."
Here's how the major awards would be doled out if the season ended today:
| NL Player of the Year |
| 1. Barry Bonds, Giants |
| Why: Say, if Bonds can upstage the Rickey Henderson show, this home-run thing must be pretty big. But c'mon, Giants fans, it's not big enough to force the Dodgers into a postgame ceremony had Bonds broken the record in Los Angeles. With the Gonzalez struggling mightily for the West-leading D-Backs, Sosa's Cubs tailing off and the nation's writers warming up to our favorite target, Bonds has this award wrapped up. |
| 2. Sammy Sosa, Cubs |
| Why: His résumé includes the NL lead in RBI and runs scored while standing second in home runs -- the same places he held in 1998 when he won the MVP award. The difference this time is that the guy who leads him in home runs has strong overall hitting stats and what is perceived to be a stronger team. |
| 3. Luis Gonzalez, Diamondbacks |
| Why: He entered the weekend batting .211 for September with just nine RBI. His accomplishments this season leading up to Labor Day warrant top-three honors, but now one could argue for putting Albert Pujols ahead of Gonzo. On the bright side, he took over the majors' longest active consecutive games streak when Shawn Green sat for Yom Kippur. |
| AL Player of the Year |
| 1. Jason Giambi, A's |
| Why: Even if writers could decide for certain which Mariners player deserved their MVP consideration, Giambi would likely beat out Ichiro and Bret Boone. His home run and RBI numbers aren't as flashy as they were last year, but his slugging percentage is nearly identical, his AL-leading on-base percentage is 25 points higher, and his final month could turn out just as impressive. |
| 2. Bret Boone, Mariners |
| Why: As much consideration as Ichiro deserves for MVP in Seattle, leadoff hitters don't beat out middle-of-the-order guys that often -- not since Rickey Henderson topped Cecil Fielder's 50-homer season in 1990. Boone is set to become the fourth major-league second baseman ever to hit .300 with 30 home runs. Yes, Ichiro has allowed him plenty of chances with runners in scoring position, but he's batting over .300 in those situations. |
| 3. Juan Gonzalez, Indians |
| Why: The same criteria that works against Ichiro does so for Roberto Alomar, who has never finished higher than a third-place tie in MVP voting despite similar seasons. With Thome's home-run lead gone, that opens the way for Gonzalez, who has gone from replacing Manny Ramirez to outplaying him in nearly every statistic. |
| NL Pitcher of the Year |
| 1. Randy Johnson, Diamondbacks |
| Why: Twenty wins, zero debate remaining on his merits. He needs 17 strikeouts in his next start (or two if Arizona doesn't clinch a playoff berth by the season finale) to match Nolan Ryan's single-season record, or 16 to tie Sandy Koufax's National League mark. He need only match teammate Curt Schilling in wins to take the NL pitching triple crown (wins, ERA and strikeouts). |
| 2. Curt Schilling, Diamondbacks |
| Why: The major-league wins leader pitched a gem for his 21st victory, fanning 13 Dodgers in eight innings last weekend. He improved his ERA to third-lowest in the NL behind Johnson and Darryl Kile. He has long since stood second in strikeout behind the Big Unit. |
| 3. Matt Morris, Cardinals |
| Why: His 21 wins make him a default third candidate, but his drubbing at Houston raised his ERA more than a quarter of a point and continued his mediocrity on the road, something the Cards will need to consider when formulating a playoff rotation. |
| AL Pitcher of the Year |
| 1. Roger Clemens, Yankees |
| Why: Everyone talks media bias against Bonds, but how much sentiment would there be against a 20-2 pitcher had that controversy with Mike Piazza never happened last year? His streak-ending defeat came in a decent start that featured no run support from the Yankees. |
| 2. Mark Mulder, Athletics |
| Why: He's so good he got a $14 million, 4-year contract from the thrifty A's. He's also a 20-game winner, having put the Mariners in a swivet for one run and six hits in seven innings. His ERA is making progress toward All-Star respectability. |
| 3. Freddy Garcia, Mariners |
| Why: Garcia and Jamie Moyer might have a similar split as Boone-Ichiro in the MVP voting, though Moyer's value lies more in career perseverance. He surrendered three Oakland homers in a 7-4 loss last weekend, but his ERA will remain the league's lowest barring a complete thumping. |
| NL Rookie of the Year |
| 1. Albert Pujols, Cardinals |
| Why: The Astros held him hitless in three straight games for the first time all season. With a rookie record for RBI, a chance to crack the NL's top five in batting average and an outside chance at 40 home runs, one tough series won't break his lock on this award. |
| 2. Roy Oswalt, Astros |
| Why: Those daily updates on Oswalt's ailing hamstring should indicate his value to the NL's best team. |
| 3. Jimmy Rollins, Phillies |
| Why: See above. |
| AL Rookie of the Year |
| 1. Ichiro Suzuki, Mariners |
| Why: He broken Shoeless Joe Jackson's record for hits by a rookie, will soon top Wade Boggs' AL single-season record for singles and become the first rookie to win a batting title since Tony Oliva in 1964. |
| 2. C.C. Sabathia, Indians |
| Why: Nearly every time he gets roughed up to raise doubts about his ability to top the staff for the postseason, he comes back with a beauty of a start. The latest featured 11 strikeouts over seven shutout innings in a no-decision against Minnesota. |
| 3. Alfonso Soriano, Yankees |
| Why: Formerly the best No. 9 hitter in the majors, Soriano has finally earned enough of Joe Torre's respect to bat leadoff on occasion despite a .307 on-base percentage. Tommie Agee is the only player with higher numbers in both homers and steals as a rookie. |
| NL Manager of the Year |
| 1. Larry Bowa, Phillies |
| Why: You know a manager has made it when he gets his own bobblehead doll night at the stadium and three-quarters of the fan mail he receives in Philly is positive. |
| 2. Jim Tracy, Dodgers |
| Why: The postseason looks out of reach for Tracy, but how many times have we thought that this season? And how many times has the Anti-Bowa, the Professor or whatever you want to call him baffled everyone with his calm demeanor and straight-forward results? |
| 3. Tony La Russa, Cardinals |
| Why: Larry Dierker could have slid into Don Baylor's old spot here, too. But given everything the Cardinals have endured this year, having Albert Pujols isn't enough of an excuse to dismiss La Russa's juggling act with this club that has no business holding the National League's second-best record. |
| AL Manager of the Year |
| 1. Lou Piniella, Mariners |
| Why: You have to love a manager willing to change strategies and give up a chance at the record for most wins in a season because he doesn't want scouts to pick up on his team's tendencies for the playoffs. |
| 2. Art Howe, Athletics |
| Why: OK, he no longer has more job security than Tony La Russa, but that's more because the Cards are headed to the playoffs. Howe's secure enough to put Cory Lidle in the playoff rotation. |
| 3. Tom Kelly, Twins |
| Why: At this point in the Twins' late-season fade, this says more about the quality of the other teams in the AL than the value of what might end up a third-place finish for Minnesota. |