ORLANDO, Fla. -- Lawyers for Dale Earnhardt's widow and the Orlando
Sentinel were headed back to mediation four days after they reached an
agreement over access to the racing star's autopsy photos.
The mediation will allow the newspaper to address its concerns about a
Daytona International Speedway doctor having viewed the photos before they were
sealed, Sentinel attorney David Bralow said Tuesday.
 | |
| Dr. Steve Bohannon viewed Dale Earnhardt's autopsy photos on behalf of NASCAR a day before a judge ordered them sealed.(AP) | |
Bralow emphasized that the agreement was still in place. The meeting will
take place in the Daytona Beach office of mediator John J. Upchurch IV on
Thursday morning.
"Both parties can always change the agreement," Bralow said. "You can
always modify a contract by a meeting of the parties."
Dr. Steve Bohannon, a NASCAR medical expert, looked at the photos three days
after Earnhardt's fatal wreck at the Daytona 500 on Feb. 18. The next day, a
Volusia County judge temporarily sealed them from public viewing at the request
of Teresa Earnhardt.
Sentinel attorneys on Tuesday subpoenaed Bohannon to take his deposition
before the meeting. They later withdrew the subpoena because the doctor was
going on an extended trip to China on Wednesday.
Earnhardt attorney Thom Rumberger disputed whether the agreement could be
changed.
"It can't be anything about Bohannon, or setting aside the mediation,"
Rumberger said. "(Upchurch) doesn't have the authority to do that."
The deal reached last week limits access to the photos, which are public
records under Florida law.
The Sentinel had tried to have its own medical expert review the images.
Under the agreement, an independent medical expert will look at the photos and
then submit a report to the newspaper and the Earnhardt family on the cause of
death and an explanation of certain head injuries. The photos then will be
permanently sealed as requested by Teresa Earnhardt because of privacy
concerns.
"Do you think we would have been as accommodating had we known that NASCAR
had an opportunity for its own expert to review them?" Bralow said Tuesday.
"As far as I'm concerned, when something is private, it's private."
But Rumberger said the Sentinel should think twice
before trying to get out of the agreement.
"As far as I'm concerned, the Sentinel has pledged their honor, their faith
and their fortunes to that agreement," Rumberger said.
Volusia County officials contended that nobody other than the medical
examiner's staff had viewed his autopsy photos. But a visitor's log obtained by
the Sentinel showed that Bohannon looked at the photos for 35 minutes on Feb.
21.
Bohannon is director of emergency services at the speedway and accompanied
Earnhardt in the ambulance to the hospital where he was pronounced dead.
The day after Bohannon viewed the photos, Volusia County Circuit Judge
Joseph Will granted a temporary injunction requested by the Earnhardt family
that sealed the photos from public viewing.
A day later, Bohannon said at a NASCAR news conference in North Carolina
that Earnhardt might have survived the crash if his lap belt had not broken.
Earnhardt probably was thrown into the steering wheel because he wasn't fully
supported, Bohannon said.
The Sentinel is investigating whether safety devices available to stock-car
drivers could have saved Earnhardt.
NASCAR President Mike Helton said Saturday that a NASCAR medical expert had
reviewed the autopsy photos as part of the circuit's investigation into
Earnhardt's death. NASCAR spokesman John Griffin confirmed Tuesday that the
medical expert was Bohannon, but said "he went to view the pictures as an
extension of his duties as the attending physician."
Bralow disputed that conclusion.
"Bohannon is talking about seat belts as a NASCAR expert, not as
Earnhardt's personal physician," he said.
Bohannon doesn't have a published home phone number and Kate Holcomb, a
spokeswoman at Halifax Medical Center where he works in the emergency room,
said Bohannon wasn't granting interviews.
Rumberger said Tuesday he wasn't sure when Mrs. Earnhardt found out that
Bohannon had viewed the photos. The lawyer said he was under the belief that
Bohannon viewed the photos in his role as the attending physician, not a NASCAR
medical expert.
"I have no reason to believe that she would be concerned," Rumberger said.
"It was done by the attending physician and not an intruder or outsider,
someone trying to invade Mrs. Earnhardt's privacy."
Sentinel executives had said repeatedly they had no intention of publishing
the photos, but only wanted a medical expert to review them for an
investigation into NASCAR safety.
But Mrs. Earnhardt's attorneys argued that other news organizations would be
able to have access to the photos if the Sentinel was granted permission.
An independent student newspaper at the University of Florida, the
Independent Florida Alligator, and a website are pursuing their own cases to
gain access to the photos and aren't part of the agreement.
AP NEWS
The Associated Press News Service
Copyright 2001, The Associated Press, All Rights Reserved