Ohio State-Michigan State game film flap a curious case
Michigan State accusing Ohio State of doctoring game tape raises questions about how common this practice really is. A former Florida staffer said Meyer never doctored tape while with the Gators.
|Meyer has emerged as a villain in the Big Ten. (AP)|
File this one in the Urban-Meyer-makes-more-friends-in-the-Big-Ten drawer. The world of presnap motions and shifts made headlines over the weekend as the Detroit Free-Press reported Michigan State was filing a complaint against Ohio State after the Buckeyes doctored opponent’s game film.
Apparently this issue was resolved between athletic directors, without Big Ten involvement. The Big Ten requires opposing teams to share the footage each week. I've put in a call to the Big Ten for more information on how they handle such things.
Curious how much of a common practice this is. What’s the precedent? These coaches obsess all week over every detail. Can a few doctored plays affect winning or losing? Hard to tell. Surely there are other sources of "tape" out there besides an opponent's.
And what should be the punishment for this sort of thing? Seems undefined all the way around. Also, not sure what doctoring tape means. Little incision here, a cut there, and the opponent will never know.
An assistant coach from an AQ conference told me the OSU-MSU tape story wasn't the first time he had heard of such a thing, but that coaches don't always know it's happening. Sometimes, video coordinators will simply send the smallest sample size they can to an opponent, the coach said.
I spoke with a former Florida staffer who said “never once” did he see the Gators doctoring opponent’s game tape. Meyer told the Free-Press he wasn’t involved.
Apparently these exchanges are pretty detailed from a conference level. For reference, here's the SEC bylaw on "Origination" of footage exchange.
Edits will be broken down into “offense,” “defense” and “special teams”. Special team’s edits will be in game sequence with three seconds of color bars before and after sections (KOC, Punt, etc.). All 22 players should be in the video frame, of the side shot, at the snap of the ball. The picture may be zoomed in after each snap. Taping of each play should begin when the team breaks the huddle and heads to the line of scrimmage.
SEC also states potential violations should be reported to the league immediately and not be discussed in the media.
Meyer’s has emerged as a Big Ten villain since last recruiting season -- this incident could fuel this persona -- but he's a villain who’s now 5-0.
Lane Kiffin turned around FAU remarkably fast and has the Owls in the C-USA title game
NCAA football scoreboard, highlights and updates from the biggest Week 12 games
The junior injured his finger diving for the pylon late in the first quarter of the loss to...
Projecting the changes in the new AP Top 25 poll college football rankings after Week 12
There's only one true Turnover Chain in college football, and it belongs to The U
The 72-yard punt return was perfectly executed by the Trojans