Pac-12 remains open to playoffs, but Scott wants conference champion requirement
While the SEC and other conferences have made clear their stance on a future college football playoff structure, the Pac-12 enters their annual summer meetings with an open mind and lack of consensus with regard to any stance they will take in the evolution of the postseason.
SAN DIEGO -- While the
"I have a pretty good (feel for our presidents' views on the issue), but I think this will be the meeting when we'll ask (them) for a definitive position and refine and narrow the different options," commissioner
"I'm very open and all ears to everything," Washington AD Scott Woodward added. "I think we need to continue to progress and get it right. I would put myself in the more forward-progressing camp."
Scott has taken heat the past week after suggesting that a plus-one title game following the bowls is still an option despite nearly all of the other conferences agreeing to some form of a four-team playoff. While the commissioner has heard some of the reaction to his comments, he hasn't spoken at length to his colleagues about how realistic a plus-one is down the road.
"I know it's on the table for certain people. It may not be for other people" he said.
One thing Scott did not back down from was an insistence that a playoff include conference champions only in a four-team scenario.
"That's been as important as the format. Having evaluated all of the options, I'm for earning it on the field by winning something," Scott said. "I think what the fans want, in the call for a playoff in the first place, is to see it earned on the field. As I've studied it and talked to various people, if you look at the pro sports playoffs you have to win the division. You win the division, you know you're in. Aside from that, you're in a wildcard situation.
"For me, that's analogous to this. You should have to win your division as a prerequisite to being in, and maybe there's a mechanism for an at-large team."
Especially given the lack of major non-conference games in the sport, Scott noted, winning the conference would create a more equitable playoff. While some -- the SEC in particular -- have campaigned against the requirement, the Pac-12 appears to be thinking much more along the lines of the NFL or MLB when it comes to the postseason.
"We don't have to re-invent the wheel here. If we're moving toward a playoff, we should follow what the pro leagues have done," said Scott. "Some years the Yankees may have a much better record than a divisional winner that gets into a playoff over them. You have to win something, and that's a concept that's accepted by fans and, given the way college football is structured, fair."
It should be noted that national champion Alabama failed to win their division, much less the conference. One reason the Pac-12 has taken such a hard line on the requirement is because the league plays nine conference games and has historically had a relatively tough non-conference slate every year. While the scheduling strategy will not change going forward, it's clear there's some push among member schools to include something that evens the playing field against conferences that load up on weaker non-conference opponents.
"We got some feedback from our coaches in May, and I know the primary concern there was about the strength of schedule that we play and the nine game conference schedule," Pac-12 deputy commissioner Kevin Weiberg said. "Whatever happens with the postseason structure should in some way reflect the strength of schedules that teams play."
Another key consideration that the Pac-12 has kept tabs on at just about every discussion is maintaining their relationship with the
"The Rose Bowl is obviously very concerned about the welfare of the Rose Bowl and rightfully so," UCLA AD Dan Guerrero said. "We've always been great partners with them, and we'll certainly listen to every option that's out there. They are clearly a consideration moving forward."
The conference is expected to reach some formal consensus by Sunday regarding a playoff, when the Pac-12 presidents are scheduled to meet. According to Stanford AD and future Big 12 commissioner
"Obviously, it's all going to be very controversial," Guerrero said. "It's very clear that there are disparate opinions throughout the country and, somewhere along the line, there needs to be some compromise. We'll see if we can find common ground."
Given the talk coming out of San Diego, Destin, Kansas City, Chicago and other places across the country, that might be easier said than done.
There are a handful of conference championship games still to be determined
SportsLine's top college football expert, on a 30-18 run, locks in his top picks for a loaded...
Haynes was 14-45 in five years with the Golden Flashes
True romance isn't dead yet
The Egg bowl will be a Thanksgiving night treat for the college football world
Mayfield disappointed a lot of people with is most recent antics, NFL scouts among them