2018 Fantasy Baseball Draft Prep: Ranking the Fantasy assets for the San Francisco Giants
If age was the Giants' downfall last year, they didn't act like it this offseason. Scott White looks at some of the changes they've made for 2018.
- Draft Prep Tiers:
Perhaps no team crashed harder than the Giants last year, whose 64-98 record tied for worst in the majors even after some prognosticators picked them to win the division.
An early-season injury to ace Madison Bumgarner didn't help. Neither did a farm system depleted by their more successful endeavors. But their biggest issue may have been that they simply got old.
Their solution this offseason? More old guys. In a gambit that seems foreign in today's game yet totally fitting for this organization, the Giants bought low on fading stars Andrew McCutchen and Evan Longoria, who don't produce like league MVPs anymore but offer more than the Giants had at those spots last year. If Brandon Belt bounces back from his concussion, they have the makings of a respectable offense.
And with a respectable offense backing Bumgarner, Johnny Cueto and Jeff Samardzija -- three pitchers who provide the length that's also becoming foreign in today's game -- good things can happen. The window may not be closed. You can't count out an organization that has so often won by defying conventional wisdom.
|Player||Roto Rank||H2H Rank||Roto Pos Rank||H2H Pos Rank|
Madison Bumgarner SF SP
Buster Posey SF C
|#34||#37||#2 (at C)||#2 (at C)|
Andrew McCutchen SF CF
Johnny Cueto SF SP
Mark Melancon SF RP
Jeff Samardzija SF SP
Evan Longoria SF 3B
Brandon Belt SF 1B
|#231||#214||#29 (at 1B)||#26 (at 1B)|
Players in Scott's Top 100 Prospects
|Next in the trifecta of free-swinging power hitters is Shaw, who nearly wound up going to the Marlins in the Giancarlo Stanton trade that never was, leaving him with the misfortune of having to conquer AT&T Park whenever he gets the call. That opportunity should come sooner than later, given the present state of the Giants outfield.|
Scott's 2018 Fantasy impact: midseason hopeful
|Granted, it was in Rookie ball, but rarely do you see a 17-year-old dominate a league the way Ramos did, flashing the sort of power and speed that gets prospect hounds howling. He obviously has a long climb ahead of him and will need to curtail the strikeouts at the higher levels, but he's a long-term investment worthy of your time.|
Scott's 2018 Fantasy impact: don't count on it
Things to Know
- For the Giants to win again in 2018, Johnny Cueto needs to bounce back to his 2016 numbers, which seems possible given that he pitched most of last season with blister issues that finally forced him to the DL in July. He's a younger-than-you'd-expect 32, and you may remember some (including yours truly) were eager to write him off after his disappointing finish with the Royals in 2015.
- Madison Bumgarner's stuff looked fine after spraining his pitching shoulder in a dirt bike accident last April, and he returned to deliver a 3.43 ERA over his final 13 starts. No worries there.
- One of last offseason's big acquisitions, Mark Melancon missed most of the second half with a strained forearm, but the Giants were so far out of the race by then that it didn't make sense to push him. Though long regarded as a top-notch closer for Fantasy purposes, he's a forgotten man now and a candidate to bounce back following offseason surgery. True, Sam Dyson did a decent job filling in, but he's no threat to a healthy Melancon.
- Brandon Belt's concussion last year wasn't his first, and such issues have been known to ruin players even in this sport. It remains to be seen how he'll bounce back, but even in a year in which he hit .241, his on-base ability allowed him to finish just behind Justin Smoak in Head-to-Head points per game, making him a sleeper in that format for 2018.
- The Giants took a flier on Austin Jackson after his impressive work as a part-timer with the Indians last season, and he figures to get the first crack at the center field job. But speedy 24-year-old Steven Duggar, who showed plus on-base ability in the minors, is waiting in the wings.
Lineup & Rotation
| Batting order |
Fantasy Baseball Today Newsletter
You're destined to gain an edge over your friends with advice from the award-winning FBT crew.
Thanks for signing up!
Keep an eye on your inbox for the latest sports news.
There was an error processing your subscription.
The Twins have a number of emerging options poised to make an impact in Week 22 (Aug. 20-26),...
Michael Kopech isn't a sure bet to make two starts in his Week 22 (Aug. 20-26), but our Scott...
Miss out on adding hot-shot prospect Michael Kopech? Chris Towers identifies a few high-upside...
Pitching prospects aren't as likely as hitting prospects to make an immediate impact in Fantasy...
Advanced computer model that has outperformed experts tells you who to sit and start
Some big names have damaged their long-term outlook over the past couple months, but there...