2018 Fantasy Baseball Draft Prep: Ranking the Yankees' Fantasy assets

There have been three sets of teammates to hit 100 homers combined in a season, and two of them have been on the Yankees: Roger Maris and Mickey Mantle in 1961; and Babe Ruth and Lou Gehrig in 1927. Will we add a third pairing to that group in 2018? 

You'd get pretty good odds if you bet on it. Last season, Aaron Judge and Giancarlo Stanton combined for 111 long balls, and they are, as you may have heard, teammates now. And they aren't alone, as the Yankees are putting together what is likely to be the best lineup in baseball for 2018, with Gary Sanchez, Didi Gregorius, and Greg Bird leading the rest of the group. The Yankees already led the majors in homers last season, while finishing second in runs, and they have to be the odds on favorite to top the league in both numbers in 2018. 

You'll want to avoid starting your pitchers against them, is what I'm saying. 

Ranking the Yankees' Fantasy Assets
PlayerRoto RankH2H RankRoto POSH2H POS
11 11 5 5
27 36 1 2
12 14 6 7
70 79 3 3
40 32 9 9
101 67 26 24
230 183 26 23
143 118 10 10
147 164 39 34
133 78 30 27
258 218 69 68
220 230 63 61

Players in Scott's Top 100 Prospects

Ranking the Yankees' Fantasy Assets
3 Gleyber Torres
If not for Tommy John surgery in June, Torres might already be entrenched as the Yankees third baseman. Second base may be the final destination for this Carlos Correa comp -- they've left it wide open for him this spring -- so it's really just a matter of him proving his health. Scott's 2018 Fantasy impact: fighting this spring
49 Chance Adams
Despite his sizzling start to the year, the Yankees continually passed over Adams whenever they had a rotation opening, and little by little, his numbers began to wane, to the point he averaged just 6.8 strikeouts per nine innings over his final 12 starts. The slider is special, but the converted reliever needs a third pitch for better consistency. Scott's 2018 Fantasy impact: midseason hopeful
55 Estevan Florial
One of the biggest risers of 2017 offers the power-speed combo that Fantasy owners crave, but he still has some strides to make with his bat, most notably cutting down on his strikeouts. Right now, it's a Curtis Granderson-like ceiling, which is still pretty special, but Florial was raw when the Yankees signed him and may continue to improve. Scott's 2018 Fantasy impact: don't count on it
57 Miguel Andujar
Coming off his best ever minor-league season, which led to an all-too-brief major-league stint in June, Andujar is back in evaluators' good graces, but there are still reasons to wonder if he's in the Yankees' long-term plans. The suspect defense. The flighty mechanics. The limited on-base ability. At his best, though, he hits for average and power. Scott's 2018 Fantasy impact: fighting this spring
94 Justus Sheffield
I find the Sheffield hype curious for a number of reasons. The numbers are so-so, which is especially notable pitching in a venue -- an entirely pipeline, really -- known for padding them, and he's 5-feet-11, which typically raises role concerns. His fastball gives him a Billy Wagner-like quality, though. Scott's 2018 Fantasy impact: cup of coffee

Things to Know

  • This isn't just the Judge and Stanton Show, obviously. Gary Sanchez would be my pick for the top catcher in Fantasy, and with 53 homers in 177 career games, he's just a step below Stanton and Judge in the power department.
  • Greg Bird didn't live up to expectations in 2017, playing just 48 games and hitting .190 while batting an ankle issue. But he still has plenty of talent, and hit .244/.426/.512 in 54 postseason plate appearances. There's 30-plus homer potential in that park. 
  • Jordan Montgomery comes to the mound with a five-pitch arsenal from the left side, but all five might just be average pitches. Can he better than the sum of his arsenal? I like him as a late-round sleeper.
  • Given how strong the lineup and bullpen are overall, there's a chance Aroldis Chapman might see fewer save opportunities than you think he will, ala Wade Davis in 2017. That shouldn't deter you from drafting him, however. 

Lineup & Rotation

1 Brett Gardner LF
2 Aaron Judge RF
3 Giancarlo Stanton DH
4 Gary Sanchez C
5 Greg Bird 1B
6 Didi Gregorius SS
7 Aaron Hicks CF
8 Gleyber Torres 3B
9 Ronald Torreyes 2B
SP Luis Severino
SP Masahiro Tanaka
SP Sonny Gray
SP CC Sabathia
SP Jordan Montgomery
CL Aroldis Chapman
RP Dellin Betances
RP David Robertson
Fantasy Writer

Though he can be found covering three different sports depending on the time of year, there is one unifying theme in how Chris Towers approaches sports; "Where's the evidence?" It doesn't matter how outlandish... Full Bio

Our Latest Stories