Tiger Woods vs. Rory McIlroy: Who had the better 2012?

Tiger Woods and Rory McIlroy measure up in China. (GettyImages)

Mention golf to a casual fan these days and two names (and only two names) come to mind.

Tiger Woods and Rory McIlroy.

Tiger and Rory.

Tiger vs. Rory.

Rory vs. Tiger.

On Monday, Woods acknowledged that theirs is not a full-blown rivalry yet, but fans are sure trying their hardest to make it one.

And if this is going to turn into a 15-year bout for the title belt (I hope it does), young McIlroy took Round 1 (2011) by TKO and narrowly edged out Tiger in Round 2 as well.

Let's look at their tale of the tape for 2012:

PGA Tour starts

Woods: 19

McIlroy: 16

Both had a pretty scaled down schedule (as Woods has been doing for years). McIlroy played a number of events on the European Tour as well.

PGA Tour wins

Woods: Three (16 percent)

McIlroy: Four (25 percent)

Woods won three of his favorites (Arnold Palmer, Memorial, AT&T National) while McIlroy got super hot at the end of the season -- between Aug. 12 and Sept. 9 he won three of the four tournaments he entered!

Advantage: McIlroy

PGA Tour top 10s

Woods: Nine (47 percent)

McIlroy: 10 (63 percent)

McIlroy had the best top 10 percentage on tour. Tiger tied Dustin Johnson for second best at 47.

Advantage: McIlroy

PGA Tour top 25s

Woods: 13 (68 percent)

McIlroy: 11 (69 percent)

This is where McIlroy fell off a little bit. He actually missed the cut at three tournaments --including the Players and U.S. Open. Woods only missed two cuts.

Advantage: Woods

PGA Tour money earned

Woods: $6.1M ($323K per tournament played)

McIlroy: $8M ($503K per tournament played)

The top two money winners on Tour; nobody else was within $1 million. They actually earned more money combined ($14.2 million) than the bottom 180 Tour golfers combined ($14 million).

Advantage: McIlroy

World ranking

Woods: 3  (8.53 pts.)

McIlroy: 1 (13.22 pts.)

As was noted the other day, the gap between McIlroy and Woods is larger than the gap between Tiger and world no. 26 Hunter Mahan. That's pretty incredible.

Advantage: McIlroy


Tiger: 0

Rory: 1

The only place Mr. Woods keeps score.

Advantage: McIlroy

Major top 35s

Tiger: 3

Rory: 1

Really the only blemish on McIlroy's incredible 2012 was his poor performance in majors not named the PGA Championship. He missed the cut at the U.S. Open and finished T40 and T60 at the Masters and British Open, respectively. Woods tied for third at the British Open and at least competed at the PGA and U.S. Open.

Advantage: Woods

Ryder Cups

Woods: 0

McIlroy: 1

Advantage: This stings. McIlroy.

Head to head

Woods: 0

McIlroy: 1

Advantage: McIlroy

It didn't mean much, or so we were led to believe, but McIlroy beat Woods heads up in China last month.

McIlroy was obviously better than Woods this year, but not by as much as you might have thought. Woods is fully in the "I only care about majors" portion of his career and you could argue he was more consistent and, despite McIlroy's PGA win, actually better overall in the four big ones.

There's not a storyline on tour that will be more intriguing in 2013 than whether these two can finally hook up on the back nine of a major. It's a jolt the golf world wouldn't know what to do with and I for one am hoping it takes place.

For more golf news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnGolf and @KylePorterCBS on Twitter and like us on Facebook.

CBS Sports Writer

Kyle Porter began his sports writing career with CBS Sports in 2012. He covers golf, writes poetry about Rory McIlroy's swing, stays ready on Tiger watch and loves the Masters more than anyone you know.... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
Our Latest Stories