Despite struggles, Jim Leyland not planning changes atop Tigers lineup

Torii Hunter has been a problem atop the Tigers lineup in the postseason so far.
Torii Hunter has been a problem atop the Tigers lineup in the postseason so far. (USATSI)

DETROIT -- In terms of runs per game, the Tigers had the second-best offense in baseball this season. Their 4.91 runs per game mark trailed only the Red Sox (5.27), their ALCS opponent. Detroit was a powerhouse.

In the postseason, however, the Tigers have averaged just 3.29 runs per game, a huge drop from their regular-season performance. Obviously you would expect scoring to come down in the playoffs because teams shorten their pitching staffs and only use their best arms, but you wouldn't expect it come down that much.

A big reason the Tigers aren't scoring much at the moment is the performance at the top of their lineup. Leadoff man Austin Jackson and two-hole hitter Torii Hunter have gone a combined 7 for 59 (.119) with two walks and one hit-by-pitch in the postseason. That's a combined .161 on-base percentage by the guys getting the most at-bats.

"Obviously they've been struggling a little bit," manager Jim Leyland said Monday. "I don't know where you go at this point in time, this time of the year. You play somebody else? I don't think that's the answer."

Leyland added that, aside from Jackson's and Hunter's track records, the reason he won't make a change atop the lineup is a lack of options. He simply doesn't have anyone else qualified to bat leadoff or second, at least no one guaranteed to be better than Jackson or Hunter. Omar Infante would be a candidate if he wasn't hitting .200 with a .259 on-base percentage in October.

"Those guys have been good all year for us, and I think we just have to continue to go that way and hope they'll come out of it," Leyland added. "I think they're both trying a little too hard. They're two guys that have been good for use all year. I don't see any reason to change now."

The Tigers will make one small change to their lineup in Game 3 on Tuesday though, replacing Don Kelly with Andy Dirks. Dirks will play left field while Jhonny Peralta starts his second straight game at shortstop after replacing Game 1 starter Jose Iglesias on Sunday.

"I think I am going to play Dirks tomorrow night. He's been away from it a little bit and maybe relaxed a little bit," Leyland said. "But I won't hit him top of the order, probably down."

Detroit's three best hitters in the postseason have been Victor Martinez, Peralta and Alex Avila. Right now they bat fifth through seventh in the lineup, respectively. Miguel Cabrera and Prince Fielder will continue to bat third and fourth because they're still elite players who can change the tone of a game with one swing.

The Tigers have had to scratch and claw for every run in these playoffs, but it's not because of the middle of the lineup. The guys who are supposed to drive in runs are doing their job, they just don't have anyone to drive in because Jackson and Hunter have been so unproductive. For Detroit to advance, those two need to snap out of their funk.

CBS Sports Writer

Mike Axisa joined CBS Sports in 2013. He has been a member of the BBWAA since 2015 and has previously written about both fantasy baseball and real life baseball for,,,... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
Our Latest Stories