Free MLB player props, odds for May 18: Aaron Judge among best bets for Sunday baseball picks
SportsLine's model is on a 12-8 roll on MLB picks and revealed its MLB prop picks and MLB betting picks on sites like PrizePicks, DraftKings and FanDuel

All 30 teams in the MLB will be in action on Sunday. The loaded MLB schedule means that fans will have plenty of opportunities to find value in playing MLB player props. Shohei Ohtani leads baseball with 16 home runs after hitting four homers in his last four games, and his return to the pitching mound also seems imminent after he threw 50 pitches in his last bullpen session. Until then, he'll remain focused on anchoring one of the best lineups in the game and the latest MLB odds from FanDuel list Ohtani at +175 (risk $100 to win $175) to record multiple hits on Sunday against the Angels.
He's already had 16 multi-hit games this season, so can you extract a little value by adding Ohtani to your MLB prop picks on Sunday? With MLB props available for almost every player in every game at sportsbooks, SportsLine's proven computer model can help you find value to add to your MLB total bases parlay picks.
The model simulates every game 10,000 times and is on a 12-8 run on all top-rated MLB money-line picks since the start of the season. The model is up 29.6 units over the last 40 days in its MLB home run props. Now, the model and SportsLine's team of Data Scientists have revealed their projections for some of the most-bet MLB total bases props on Sunday. These three picks can be parlayed for +442 odds and would win almost $450 on a $100 bet on BetMGM.
Ketel Marte, Diamondbacks, Over 1.5 total bases (+105)
The two-time All-Star has been top-five in MVP voting twice now, and he's had another solid offensive season despite battling injuries. He's slashing .257/.375/.514 over 22 games, and he's had multiple hits in two of his last three games, including a two-homer effort on Wednesday.
The over/under for Sunday is 9, but the model is projecting 10.6 runs on average and it rates Marte over 1.5 total bases as a five-star pick. BetMGM is offering the best odds at +105, but most sports betting apps have this line at around even money.
Aaron Judge, Yankees, Over 0.5 RBI (+110)
Judge has been the RBI champion in two of the last three seasons, and he's the current American League Triple Crown leader, with 15 home runs, 41 RBI, and a .402 batting average over the first two months of the season. He's had an RBI in 21 of the 45 games that he's played so far this season, and he's had nine multi-RBI games as well.
BetMGM is offering the best odds at +110. The latest BetMGM promo code CBSSPORTS is good for up to $1,500 in bonus bets if your first bet loses.
Jose Tena, Nationals, Under 0.5 total hits (+165)
Tena broke through with the Guardians in 2023 and then arrived in Washington as part of the Lane Thomas trade last season. He hit .274 in 41 games with the club last season, but he's only hitting .232 this season and has 19 hits in 28 games.
He's gone hitless in 16 of the 28 games that he's played in 2025, so getting significant plus-money is a boon. The model is projecting that he only averages 0.3 hits over 10,000 simulations of Sunday's contest in Baltimore. BetMGM and DraftKings are both offering this price.
Want more MLB picks for Sunday?
You've seen the model's MLB prop picks for some popular props on Sunday. Now, get MLB projections for every player prop at SportsLine.
Also at SportsLine:
You can also see today's best MLB picks from Bruce Marshall, who's on a sizzling 29-19 (+1634) roll on MLB spread picks. Visit SportsLine to see his best bet for Sunday's MLB schedule.