Integrity clause about to have a big month in Hall of Fame arguments

Bonds, Clemens and the integrity clause will be popular topics the next few weeks. (Getty Images)

We've seen it cited a seemingly infinite number of times in the past few years, and the frequency of its use is bound to increase now in the face of the circumstances surrounding this season's Hall of Fame ballot -- and those for the next 10 to 20 years. "It" would be the following clause from the Baseball Writers Association of America's Hall of Fame election rules:

Voting shall be based upon the player's record, playing ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character, and contributions to the team(s) on which the player played.

Now, in my continuing quest for sanity -- a battle I realize will never come close to fruition -- I would like to point out that whether or not someone feels a certain player is a Hall of Famer is an exercise in subjectivity. That is, it's based on opinion, and opinions by definition cannot possibly be wrong.

Baseball Hall of Fame
Related coverage

Nevertheless, I fully expect the next month in baseball discussions on the Internet to center around name-calling, pissing matches and put-downs. Sanctimony will be aplenty. Most of it will focus on whether or not Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens should be inducted into the Hall of Fame, and nearly 100 percent of those arguments will involve the integrity clause, quoted above, because there's no realistic way to portray them as non-Hall of Famers without the integrity clause.

Just as with the vote itself, I believe the interpretation of "integrity" and "sportsmanship" is subjective.

To some, Bonds and Clemens were absolutely "cheaters" and violated the game's integrity, thus there's no way they should be allowed in the Hall of Fame. On the other extreme, there's the school of thought that these two were merely products of an era where so many were using that it's tough to keep track -- not to mention the concrete evidence of those two using PEDs can be validly questioned -- so we shouldn't question integrity and should induct two of the greatest players in baseball history into the Hall. 

There will be references to some players in the Hall of Fame with questionable character traits. To wit:

 Ever hear of Pud Galvin? He used Brown-Sequard elixir, which contained animal testosterone, in the late 19th century. He's a Hall of Famer.

 Gaylord Perry admitted in a 1974 autobiography (Me and the Spitter) that he threw illegal spitballs throughout most of his career. He was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1991.

 Willie Stargell has been accused of openly handing out "greenies" (amphetamines) to other players during his career, and he's in. It's worth noting Stargell emphatically denied the charges. Then again, hasn't Clemens pretty vehemently denied using PEDs (and won a court case)?

 Yankees Hall of Fame pitcher Whitey Ford's penchant for cutting and doctoring the baseball has been widely reported.

 Hank Greenberg once had a sign-stealer sitting in the upper deck with a telescopic lens (via DC Sports Bog, which has more details on the mildly funny story).

There are more, and this isn't even including a few racists, alcoholics and generally nasty men in the Hall.

So, the pro-Bonds/Clemens side might say: What's the difference? Why now is the standard changing?

The anti-Bonds/Clemens side would probably reply that what's done is done and we can't start throwing people out of the Hall. We can, however, start to better uphold the integrity clause explicitly outlined in the voting rules.

So when picking a side to the argument, make sure to consider everything above. The integrity clause is going to be bandied about for the next month.

For more baseball news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnBaseball on Twitter, subscribe to the RSS feed and "like" us on Facebook.

CBS Sports Writer

Matt Snyder has been a baseball writer with CBS Sports since 2011. A member of the BBWAA, he's now covered the last six World Series beginning with the epic 2011 Fall Classic. The former Indiana University... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
Our Latest Stories
    Astros ALCS Champs Gear