More embarrassing: Polanco hitting cleanup or Cedeno starting at SS?

Ronny Cedeno Placido Polanco
Cedeno, left, is a starting shortstop. And Polanco is a cleanup hitter. (USATSI)

The Houston Astros will make their American League debut on Sunday night against the Texas Rangers. And they'll do so with a lackluster lineup. Most notable for me is Ronny Cedeno being the starting shortstop.

This is the same Ronny Cedeno who sports a career .247/.290/.357 line. And, no, he doesn't make up for it on the base paths. He has stolen 34 bases in 55 attempts in his career. And, no, his defense isn't great, either. His career .970 fielding percentage is a tick below the league-average .972 during his time, and his range has yielded a negative dWAR in four different seasons.

Cedeno is so unappealing that the Cardinals cut him March 19 though he was only vying for a backup job. This was after the Mets had no interest in retaining him as a utility backup.

Equally as laughable, however, is that the Marlins' lineup against Stephen Strasburg and the Nationals on Monday will have Placido Polanco batting fourth. Yes, cleanup. The 37-year-old Polanco hit .257/.302/.327 with two homers in 90 games last season. Carlos Zambrano has a career .388 slugging percentage -- 61 points higher than Polanco had last season!

So, yeah, the Astros and Marlins enter the season as whipping boys for media and fans everywhere. I'm not sure they can live down to the expectations. But for now, I'm left wondering which is more embarrassing -- Polanco at cleanup or Cedeno as a starting shortstop. Let me know in the comments.

CBS Sports Writer

Matt Snyder has been a baseball writer with CBS Sports since 2011. A member of the BBWAA, he's now covered the last six World Series beginning with the epic 2011 Fall Classic. The former Indiana University... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
Our Latest Stories