NL Managerial Hot Seat

Are Collins and Guillen under fire with a month of play left? (Getty Images)

Thursday we checked in on the top candidates for Manager of the Year in each respective league. We're now here to do the opposite. Who is on the hot seat now or may be by the end of the season?

Here's a look at the National League skippers who may be on the hot seat, with varying degrees of heat on each respective seat. Please note this is speculative and for discussion purposes.


Kirk Gibson, Diamondbacks: The 2011 NL West champions returned largely intact, and at this rate -- with the Padres playing great baseball -- the D-Backs could be looking at a fourth-place finish. It's difficult to see Gibby canned after last season, but this season has been a complete flop.

More from Eye on Baseball

Charlie Manuel, Phillies: He's the most decorated Phillies manager of all-time and this season's disappointment has not really been his fault. Sometimes, though, general managers use seasons that fall well short of expectations as an excuse to get some new blood in the dugout.

Dale Sveum, Cubs: The chances of Sveum getting canned are extremely slim, because the Cubs' front office made this hire for the long haul and had no illusions of contending this season (or next, for that matter) during the complete rebuild. Still, any time a club looks like it's going to lose 100 games, we cannot dismiss the possibility of a firing.

Jim Tracy, Rockies: The front office has continued to support Tracy and given him the managerial job "indefinitely," so it's doubtful he's going anywhere. With a last place finish and a front office that has already been shaken up, however, we can't assume Tracy is 100 percent safe.


Terry Collins, Mets: The Mets are 15-31 since July 7 and while they've had some injuries, they haven't had Blue Jays-level injuries. The roster construction and payroll situation are in decent enough shape that the Mets will likely have hope of competing in the 2013. Considering the flop in the second half and the front office maybe feeling a renewed hope for next season, Collins has to be feeling the heat. Even if it's only like having left his car seat warmer on high for a bit too long, he's feeling something.

Ozzie Guillen, Marlins: Marlins' brass went to great lengths to finally pry Guillen away from the White Sox, so pulling the plug after one season would be a bit of a surprise. This one season, however, has been an unmitigated disaster both on and off the field for Guillen and his Marlins. If upper management feels a drastic organizational change is needed, firing Guillen would surely be on the table.

*Fredi Gonzalez, Braves: This comes with an asterisk, because as things stand right now, the Braves are comfortably in the playoffs and there's no chance Gonzalez loses his job. Just keep in mind, though, the Braves' historic collapse last season. If they collapsed again -- and it would be far less historic, as their spot is 3.5 games safe -- Gonzalez would almost certainly get the ax. So how worried would you be with a 3.5 game lead? I'm guessing it crosses his mind from time to time.


None. Out of 16 teams in the National League, it does not appear there is a single manager that is completely under fire in the eyes of his bosses, now that the Astros have already fired Brad Mills. We could list Tony DeFrancesco here, as there's no way he gets that Astros job, but he's only an interim manager anyway.

As things stand now, my guess is Collins is the most likely to be fired. We have a month left, though, so lots can change.

For more baseball news, rumors and analysis, follow @EyeOnBaseball on Twitter, subscribe to the RSS feed and "like" us on Facebook.

CBS Sports Writer

Matt Snyder has been a baseball writer with CBS Sports since 2011. A member of the BBWAA, he's now covered the last six World Series beginning with the epic 2011 Fall Classic. The former Indiana University... Full Bio

Show Comments Hide Comments
Our Latest Stories
    CBS Sports Shop